I tried to discuss this
here.
The "problem", if we want to call it like that, is not just the makeup. Women tend to be overall artificial.
That means their fashion style, their interests and their other body parts are equally important.
For example finger nails. You can have the best natural-look makeup, but your fingers will tell everything.
Or you can have no makeup at all, but dress like a fashion-junkie.
And beauty means time. That means less time for other things. And this causes the problem that those women have no real interests at all. That means they know what's up currently. Mainstream things, mainstream music, mainstream small talk. But I did not meet one fashion-woman who could hold intellectual conversations. Their general knowledge is horrible. Like something happened in Mogadischu or Ottowa, where is that, right? So they know what happens superficial around the world, more than that they are lost. And the things they follow are fashion, beauty products, tv, popular music.
What to do?
Good question.
Try to wait for the unique ones and hope that she falls in love with you.
Or change your view with the probability that you will never be satisfied and be artifical as they are.