The Student Room Group

christians dating non christians

Christians I need your help... i was going to post this in the religion forum but i couldnt seem to do it as anonymous, and wanted it as anon. so hopeful someone on here wil be a christian and able to help.

I have been brought up as an Anglican, and was always taught that I should never go out with a non-christian. I know the verses/theory behind that view, however I have never known the reasons against that and the theory behind the opposite view that it is ok. Current situations have lead me to want to know what this view is. If someone could enlighten me that would be great. thank you

(i want the christian view not the worlds view.. i know that!)

Scroll to see replies

Reply 1

I really forsee no problem with dating a non christian. What are the reasons for christians only dating christians? If God is so ever loving then im sure he's not going to punish you for dating a decent person, regardless of religion. In terms of catholicism(i.e. my religion) you can marry whoever you like but its preferred that the children be brought up catholic.

But Im not one for obeying all the daft man made laws of the church that clearly defy the idea of an ever loving god.

Reply 2

i dont want to get into a debate about why some christians think they shouldnt date non christians - each to their own. but the core reason, i believe, is that in their eyes a relationship is supposed to be God centreed, and if you arent in a rel with another christian, you cant pray together, worship together, etc. ... but as i said, i really dont want to debate that. i understand and know that different people, different religion, different cultures have differnet views on it, so there no point in debating.

i was after a more bibically referenced reason rather than just that catholics are allowed to!... do you have any verses to suport why you are allowed to?

Reply 3

The bible cant be used in the sense of textual evidence, its not all supposed to be taken literally.

Reply 4

Dhesi
The bible cant be used in the sense of textual evidence, its not all supposed to be taken literally.


again debatable! like everythign to do with religion!!! oh wel!

Reply 5

It doesnt say in the bible, so why not!

Reply 6

Its not debatable. The parables, for example, did not actually occur, they are images that are used as representation.

"According to the law in force in the Latin Church, a mixed marriage needs for liceity the express permission of ecclesiastical authority.135 In case of disparity of cult an express dispensation from this impediment is required for the validity of the marriage.136 This permission or dispensation presupposes that both parties know and do not exclude the essential ends and properties of marriage and the obligations assumed by the Catholic party concerning the baptism and education of the children in the Catholic Church."

Thats from the catechism, if you really want some kind of text.

Reply 7

it does say so in the bible
basically the point of dating (for some people)
is to lead to marriage
a marriage between 2 different people of 2 different faiths probably would not help your faith
also on the shorter run your bf/gf etc may want a sexual relationship, which you may or may not want. So lots of christians choose to simplify things and just date christians :smile:

Reply 8

Anonymous
It doesnt say in the bible, so why not!


it talks about being unequally yolked with an unbeliever - however ther is debate and confusion as to the context and meaning under which that it so to taken.
it also talks about a 3cord which cannot be broken - man, wife and God. however, to create that 3cord each one has have hold of the other 2

Reply 9

May I also point out that with time comes change so a 2000 year old book is perhaps not the best resource for modern day problems. The basics are there but we cant extrapolate very far without making a complete mess of it. Many a time have I heard christians say: "I think what God meant to say", making blind assumptions.

Reply 10

Anonymous
it does say so in the bible
basically the point of dating (for some people)
is to lead to marriage
Where does the Bible talk about dating? :confused:
Anonymous
a marriage between 2 different people of 2 different faiths probably would not help your faith
Why not? My dad's Christian and my mum's an atheist. Doesn't sour his relationship with God or her.

Anonymous
also on the shorter run your bf/gf etc may want a sexual relationship, which you may or may not want. So lots of christians choose to simplify things and just date christians :smile:
This could be a problem, although the issue of sex before marriage is also more complex than it appears.

@other Anonymous (Why you need to be anonymous is beyond me): Can you give references for the yoked and 3cord ideas?

Reply 11

Mercer
Where does the Bible talk about dating? :confused:
Why not? My dad's Christian and my mum's an atheist. Doesn't sour his relationship with God or her.


Im in exactly the same position except its my mum who is a catholic but my dad is an athiest. It does not affect anyone in my household's relationship with God.

Reply 12

Mercer
@other Anonymous (Why you need to be anonymous is beyond me): Can you give references for the yoked and 3cord ideas?



being unequaly yolked - 2 Corinthians 6:14

a three cord - ecclesiastes 4:12

Reply 13

Well, the ecclesiastes doesn't say anything about marriage or one of the three being God, so it requires an immense amount of extension of what looks to me like a 'hang together and you'll be stronger' point.

The Corinthians could be used more clearly, but again it is not explicitly about marriage as far as I can see.

Reply 14

I dont know anything about the anglican views...but being a christian dating a non-christian i see no problem with it!

I think that as long as ur partner respects ur religion/faith its fair enough! :smile:

Reply 15

Do what you want to do, not what your religion wants you to do.

Reply 16

I have to say that, as a Christian, I think that it is definately a wiser choice not to date non-Christians. I have seen too many of my Christian friends make the decision to ignore that advice and go out with an unbeliever, and it has always ended badly.
I'm not saying it would in every case, but from the people I know who have gone out with a non-Christian, it has caused them problems with their relationship to God, gradually dragged them away from their church life, and in one case led to serious sin.
I know too how tempting it can be, and have myself questioned the logic behind it, but you have to believe that the advice God gives us in the Bible is for the best.

PM me if you want more advice - I haven't gone into too much detail here as it's a public forum and most of the people who read it won't be Christians.

Reply 17

Yet another example of the divisive power of religion in the world...

Reply 18

I don't really think that being Anglican, Roman Catholic, Methodist or another denomination of Christianity would mean you could only go out with someone of the same religious faith. Christianity isn't as strict as Islam or [random example], Mormonism. I have a few Christian friends and they have all dated Christians and non-Christians.

Reply 19

Optimistic
Yet another example of the divisive power of religion in the world...

Wow. That was called for. :rolleyes:. It's H&R, not D&D.