Back
to top
Why is aspirin not a sweet smelling substance?
Watch
Announcements
Page 1 of 1
Go to first unread
Skip to page:
(Original post by PythianLegume)
Because aromatic rings don't automatically lead to sweet smells...
Because aromatic rings don't automatically lead to sweet smells...
0
reply
Report
#4
(Original post by ANEXIS kZstaR)
Could you elaborate on that please, since aroma is Latin meaning fragrance, then how come organic materials produced from plant material gives off fragrant smells whereas in benzene it is odourless.
Could you elaborate on that please, since aroma is Latin meaning fragrance, then how come organic materials produced from plant material gives off fragrant smells whereas in benzene it is odourless.
0
reply
Report
#5
(Original post by PythianLegume)
Because aromatic rings don't automatically lead to sweet smells...
Because aromatic rings don't automatically lead to sweet smells...
Also touching on the matter of smells in Chemistry, as you said above is a very complex matter! It's a combination of stereoisomers, more than one benzene ring perhaps and maybe positional isomers that can lead to such a variety of compounds (which might be the reason for it having a scent!??)
Something like the famous 2,4,6-trichlorophenol compound is TCP and is used as an antiseptic that has a pleasant odour.
1
reply
(Original post by PythianLegume)
Umm, the Chemistry of smell is ridiculously complex. As simple things as different stereoisomerism can completely alter the smell. No-one really knows how to predict smells. The name 'aromatic' is historical, and exists purely by coincidence. It is unrelated to the smell of compounds.
Umm, the Chemistry of smell is ridiculously complex. As simple things as different stereoisomerism can completely alter the smell. No-one really knows how to predict smells. The name 'aromatic' is historical, and exists purely by coincidence. It is unrelated to the smell of compounds.
0
reply
(Original post by James A)
This.
Also touching on the matter of smells in Chemistry, as you said above is a very complex matter! It's a combination of stereoisomers, more than one benzene ring perhaps and maybe positional isomers that can lead to such a variety of compounds (which might be the reason for it having a scent!??)
Something like the famous 2,4,6-trichlorophenol compound is TCP and is used as an antiseptic that has a pleasant odour.
This.
Also touching on the matter of smells in Chemistry, as you said above is a very complex matter! It's a combination of stereoisomers, more than one benzene ring perhaps and maybe positional isomers that can lead to such a variety of compounds (which might be the reason for it having a scent!??)
Something like the famous 2,4,6-trichlorophenol compound is TCP and is used as an antiseptic that has a pleasant odour.
0
reply
Report
#8
(Original post by ANEXIS kZstaR)
So benzene is an aromatic compound, with aroma meaning fragrance, but benzene isn't actually sweet-smelling and it is all a big co-incidence then?
So benzene is an aromatic compound, with aroma meaning fragrance, but benzene isn't actually sweet-smelling and it is all a big co-incidence then?
0
reply
(Original post by labking)
Benzene does smell aromatic... Though I wouldn't recommend smelling it due to its carcinogenic properties.
Benzene does smell aromatic... Though I wouldn't recommend smelling it due to its carcinogenic properties.
0
reply
Report
#10
Volatility also comes into play with compounds and if they smell or not.. benzene is highly volatile but asprin is not... smells are very specific.. small changes in chemical structure have large impact on smells (compare carboxylic acids and esters)
0
reply
Report
#11
(Original post by ANEXIS kZstaR)
I maeant aspirin isn'ts sweet smelling..
I maeant aspirin isn'ts sweet smelling..
0
reply
(Original post by labking)
There is more to the structure of asprin than the benzene ring.... toluene (benzene with methyl group) smells completely different to anisoles (benzenes with methoxygroup)
There is more to the structure of asprin than the benzene ring.... toluene (benzene with methyl group) smells completely different to anisoles (benzenes with methoxygroup)
So just coincidence that aspirin has no "aroma" despite it being an aromatic compound, then?
0
reply
Report
#13
(Original post by ANEXIS kZstaR)
But aspirin being an aromatic compound and it containing a benzene ring - has nothing to do with it having no odour.
So just coincidence that aspirin has no "aroma" despite it being an aromatic compound, then?
But aspirin being an aromatic compound and it containing a benzene ring - has nothing to do with it having no odour.
So just coincidence that aspirin has no "aroma" despite it being an aromatic compound, then?
Aspirin does not have a sweet smell
Therefore, not all aromatic compounds have an aroma. The presence of a benzene ring doesn't automatically cause a fragrance. The naming is coincidental.
1
reply
(Original post by Hype en Ecosse)
Aspirin is aromatic
Aspirin does not have a sweet smell
Therefore, not all aromatic compounds have an aroma. The presence of a benzene ring doesn't automatically cause a fragrance. The naming is coincidental.
Aspirin is aromatic
Aspirin does not have a sweet smell
Therefore, not all aromatic compounds have an aroma. The presence of a benzene ring doesn't automatically cause a fragrance. The naming is coincidental.
Thank you.
0
reply
Report
#15
To quote wikipedia on http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aromatic_hydrocarbon:
So, in chemistry 'aromatic' means something different.
An aromatic hydrocarbon or arene (or sometimes aryl hydrocarbon) is a hydrocarbon with alternating double and single bonds between carbon atoms forming rings. The term 'aromatic' was assigned before the physical mechanism determining aromaticity was discovered; the term was coined as such simply because many of the compounds have a sweet or pleasant odor.
0
reply
X
Page 1 of 1
Go to first unread
Skip to page:
Quick Reply
