Of the two, I prefered the Warwick campus, but the York course. Have you visited?
I thought it was brand new at Warwick, not York? And the typical grade requirements were AAB for both, I thought. Or do you mean your offers? I'm not sure if either would be considered significantly better for PPE.
The guy at York told me only a few people get the ABB offer... I got an AAB offer, so kind of regarded them as the same.
I found visiting helped a lot, especially with a subject like PPE where you're studying in more than one department. It makes it that bit harder to decide, as there are three departments to be considered. I found it helpful to visit and talk to people from all areas. At York, though, it is just the one department, which could be seen as a pro or a con, i guess.
I think then, if I were you, I'd go for Warwick. I did find the Warwick accomodation/campus to be far nicer, and the guy from the Politics department was great.
Are you applying for 2005 entry, or making your final decision?
Is this for your firm or insurance?
Unfortunately, I don't believe Warwick and York have equal Kudos at all; if they did, I'd find this decision far harder. I believe York is the most overshadowed of the top 10 unis.
Reputation: Warwick wins
Environment: Warwick wins
Course: Warwick wins
I see no reason to choose York over Warwick, i think...