The Student Room Group

Manic depression?

Hi all! I've been through a long period of depression, some of which I feel that I may have been manically depressed before my more severe depression, for me. What I am asking you is whether you could point me in some directions for information regarding different types of depression with their symptoms etc? If the NHS has something similar to what I require, I'd like the link to that also. Or if anyone here has been manically depressed or experienced another type of depression and would like to share their experiences so as to help me and one another, would be good also.

Scroll to see replies

Reply 1

Erm, wouldn't visting a doctor be a better idea, rather than diagnosing yourself?

Reply 2

Please go and speak to a doctor (arrange an appointment), or even give a call to somebody like The Samaritans (http://www.samaritans.org.uk/) who will be able to put you in touch with one. Depression is serious, but with the right advice, help and support you can get through it.

Reply 3

3232
Erm, wouldn't visting a doctor be a better idea, rather than diagnosing yourself?

i agree there can be large grey areas between different forms. it would be best to talk to someone about it as merly knowing what it is you have is not particularily useful.

yes i know a manic depressent.

Reply 4

Don't go on tablets, whatever the doctor says. You do need to see a doctor though, the internet is a hive of rubbish any idiot can put stuff on.
If it is manic depression, which it doesn't really sound like (although I'm not a doctor) then you'll miss the manic phases when the tablets start making you numb. What are your symtoms?

Reply 5

doll-heart
Don't go on tablets, whatever the doctor says.


What kind of advice is that? Unless you're Tom Cruise, most people tend to accept that Anti-Depressants do help.

Reply 6

doll-heart
Don't go on tablets, whatever the doctor says.


Please keep your medical advice to yourself, unless you are a qualified doctor.

Reply 7

doll-heart
Don't go on tablets, whatever the doctor says.

Bull****. If the doctor feels you're going to kill yourself within the week unless you have the tablets, then you take the bloody tablets. Certainly don't take them if you feel you don't need them, but if your doctor insists you take them, then take them. Side-effects are nasty but so's depression, and for some people a numbing of emotions is better than being depressed.

Reply 8

dazmanultra
Please keep your medical advice to yourself, unless you are a qualified doctor.


Please don't tell me what I can and can't do unless you are my mother:p:

Reply 9

generalebriety
Bull****. If the doctor feels you're going to kill yourself within the week unless you have the tablets, then you take the bloody tablets. Certainly don't take them if you feel you don't need them, but if your doctor insists you take them, then take them. Side-effects are nasty but so's depression, and for some people a numbing of emotions is better than being depressed.


Manic depression is not the same as just being sad all the time, you go through hyperactive phases, you miss them when the tablets take them away.

Reply 10

doll-heart
Please don't tell me what I can and can't do unless you are my mother:p:

ive got something to tell you, i think you should sit down.....

Reply 11

doll-heart
Please don't tell me what I can and can't do unless you are my mother


doll-heart
Don't go on tablets, whatever the doctor says. You do need to see a doctor though, the internet is a hive of rubbish any idiot can put stuff on.

Ahem.

Reply 12

doll-heart
Manic depression is not the same as just being sad all the time, you go through hyperactive phases, you miss them when the tablets take them away.

I am aware of what manic depression is. And, being the medical expert you are, you will know that manic depressives also go through depressed periods, during which they may become suicidal and kill themselves. So anti-depressants are better than depression, whether the depression is constant or not.

Reply 13

generalebriety
Ahem.



Well duh; we're posting on some ****ty health forms and none of us are medical experts! Anon asked for our advice. Not going on tablets is my advice on the matter. They're mood-killers.

I'd rather be dead than apathetic.

Reply 14

doll-heart
Well duh; we're posting on some ****ty health forms and none of us are medical experts! Anon asked for our advice. Not going on tablets is my advice on the matter. They're mood-killers.

I'd rather be dead than apathetic.

Fine.

OP: follow this idiot's advice if you want to cure your depression by killing yourself.

Reply 15

doll-heart
Please don't tell me what I can and can't do unless you are my mother:p:


Giving out medical advice regarding something as serious as depression is not something you can do as a layman. As far as I'm aware, you have no experience of treating patients with various degrees of depression, and as such have no real idea as to the method of treatment that will suit the OP best. Hence everyone in the thread urging the OP to visit a doctor where a proper diagnosis can be given, and the most appropriate course of treatment ascertained.

Reply 16

generalebriety
Fine.

OP: follow this idiot's advice if you want to cure your depression by killing yourself.



Haha, you are taking this so personally, chill out; you're gonna give yourself a heart-attack. It's the internet! No-one cares what any of us think.

Right, there are good and bad points to taking tablets as there are with anything. Let's be more productive and give good point and bad points? Yes?

I'll start; they can be addictive and hard to come off, you can become dependant upon the tablets and believe you NEED them to stay happy.

Reply 17

If your doctor does prescribe you medication for the condition, then take it.

One of my neighbours is a manic depressant and the drugs helped a lot with the condition.

The consequence of not taking the medication? The depression was even worse, and the manic phases lead to shopping bills of well in excess of £1000. It is essential to know that in these situations, this condition effects the families of the victims just as much as the sufferer itself!

Take the medication that you are given...

Reply 18

dazmanultra
Giving out medical advice regarding something as serious as depression is not something you can do as a layman. As far as I'm aware, you have no experience of treating patients with various degrees of depression, and as such have no real idea as to the method of treatment that will suit the OP best. Hence everyone in the thread urging the OP to visit a doctor where a proper diagnosis can be given, and the most appropriate course of treatment ascertained.


If you're gonna post asking for advice your going to get it. You might not like it. You don't have to take it. I advised said person to see a doctor, and advised them not to take tablets.

I've had problems coming off tablets before. I just don't like people making the same mistake if I can advise them against it I'm gonna.

Reply 19

doll-heart
Haha, you are taking this so personally, chill out; you're gonna give yourself a heart-attack. It's the internet! No-one cares what any of us think.

Right, there are good and bad points to taking tablets as there are with anything. Let's be more productive and give good point and bad points? Yes?

I'll start; they can be addictive and hard to come off, you can become dependant upon the tablets and believe you NEED them to stay happy.

Course I'm taking it personally. I myself suffer/have suffered from depression, and I know people who suffer/have suffered from depression and manic depression. And I don't believe you should be handing out appalling advice to people who are in such a fragile condition. Clearly the OP cares what we think, or he/she wouldn't have asked. I don't care about your silly good point/bad point rubbish. I'm saying do not attempt to override a qualified medical professional's advice before it's even been given, especially on such a dangerous topic.

Besides, if you know anything about depression, as you seem to, you'll know that as it's due to a chemical change in the brain you do need the pills to stay happy and that you can't just "snap out of it" like most people think you can.