The Student Room Group

Controversial Debate topics...

There is a debating competition at school and am looking for a controversial topic for my house to do a debate on.... It has to appeal to the sixth form (so nothing too boring) and I want at least one side to generate a lot of questions... .Another house is doing 'Was Hitler a great man' so I'm trying to think of an equally controversial topic... Any ideas?

Scroll to see replies

Reply 1

Is race really unimportant? (See DandD thread of the same name)

Reply 2

Reply 3

Is one sex superior to the other?

Reply 4

Is one race superior to another?

Is the concept of human rights bunk?

Reply 5

Black people are slaves and always will be
Women should not be allowed to leave the house
Nuclear power plants should be set up in the third world to power the first world

Reply 6

We had to do a similar debate in my college.

My group opted to debate on whether animal testing is justified (or morally wrong).

Given that the group I was, the chosen debate got pretty heated although most of us didn't feel even slightly passionate about the matter - if we had chosen anything slightly more controversial which we actually had an interest in, the debate would have become violent!

Reply 7

Pepsi or Coke? :p:

How about colonialism, and whether it truly is to blame for the entirety of the third worlds problems or not? Ok that is obviously biased...let me re-word it...:p:

'Can colonialism be seen as the main factor in modern day third world strife?'

Reply 8

The uni debating society did "this house believes political correctness has gone mad' last night, which was quite lively.

Reply 9

Chrism
The uni debating society did "this house believes political correctness has gone mad' last night, which was quite lively.


Was their any throwing of furniture? :p:

Reply 10

The colonial one isnt a debate. If you said "Did the end of colonialism destroy any hope for Africa?"

Reply 11

Abortion's always good for a giggle.

Reply 12

How about...."The Ku Klux Klan - bunch of backward thinking racist rednecks or merely misunderstood"?

Reply 13

Howard
How about...."The Ku Klux Klan - bunch of backward thinking racist rednecks or merely misunderstood"?


The most controversial debate would be one that involves casting our nation as villainous. :biggrin:

Reply 14

yawn
The most controversial debate would be one that involves casting our nation as villainous. :biggrin:

You're american?!?! :eek3:

Reply 15

Pizza or Chinese

Reply 16

_jackofdiamonds



Nice to see my work is appreciated...

Reply 17

"THBT white people are superior to black people". Controversy 101.

Or "THBT the Final Solution was justified". You'd never get a proposition, but theoretically it still counts as a debate.

Reply 18

Agent Smith
"THBT white people are superior to black people". Controversy 101.

Or "THBT the Final Solution was justified". You'd never get a proposition, but theoretically it still counts as a debate.


You may get a proposition. I'd be willing to propose, I'd take it as a challenge. Before anyone gets the wrong idea, that doesn't mean I agree with the motion, the holocaust was undeniably an evil act, just it would be interesting to try to defend something SO indefensible.

Reply 19

Yes, I know what you mean. I too relish such challenges. But there's a line beyond which I really would feel, well, just bad about doing so.

It's interesting to consider that with the Holocaust, people who secretly wish it had been completed make insane claims that it is a lie propagated to help propel Jews to global supremacy, but no-one has ever said the same thing about the Armenian genocide.

How The Student Room is moderated

To keep The Student Room safe for everyone, we moderate posts that are added to the site.