You are Here: Home >< Maths

Problem with solutions to trig equations watch

Announcements
1. Hey guys just a slight issue with the question,
sqrt3sinx=cosx
The obvious way to solve is to divide by cos x and get
Sqrt3tanx=1
And solve for x

However, when solving it I did this,
Sqrt3sinx-cosx=0

Sinx=cosxtanx

Sqrt3cosxtanx - cosx = 0

Factoring out cos x

Cosx( sqrt3tanx - 1) = 0

So you'll still get the same solutions from the tan part as before, but new ones are introduced.

Between 0 and 360 degrees you have solutions for cosx at 90 and 270, neither of which work in the original equation.

Why is this?

Thanks, sorry for the long post
2. Bump

Posted from TSR Mobile
3. Could you explain the equation a bit more? Do you mean Square root of (3sinx) = cosx
or cube root(sinx) = cosx or something else entirely?
Hey guys just a slight issue with the question,
sqrt3sinx=cosx
The obvious way to solve is to divide by cos x and get
Sqrt3tanx=1
And solve for x

However, when solving it I did this,
Sqrt3sinx-cosx=0

Sinx=cosxtanx

Sqrt3cosxtanx - cosx = 0

Factoring out cos x

Cosx( sqrt3tanx - 1) = 0

So you'll still get the same solutions from the tan part as before, but new ones are introduced.

Between 0 and 360 degrees you have solutions for cosx at 90 and 270, neither of which work in the original equation.

Why is this?

Thanks, sorry for the long post
Hmmm. Unfortunately this is one of those things with trig. It is easy to create phantom solutions, and you should always check your solutions.

cosx(sqrt3tanx - 1) = 0 is just the equation sqrt3tanx - 1 = 0, multipied by cos x. You could multiply the equation by anything, and provided that thing can equal zero, you'll get phantom solutions.

For example, you could have had sinx(sqrt3tanx - 1) = 0, which would have given you the solutions 0 and 180, which are obviously wrong.

Nothing wrong with your method, and provided you check them, you'll get the correct solutions.

Sometimes you can all but guarantee phantom solutions, eg if you square both sides of an equation. This one is not as clear, but changing one trig term into two might have been an indicating factor.

Sorry its not a full explanation!
Hey guys just a slight issue with the question,
sqrt3sinx=cosx
The obvious way to solve is to divide by cos x and get
Sqrt3tanx=1
And solve for x

However, when solving it I did this,
Sqrt3sinx-cosx=0

Sinx=cosxtanx

Sqrt3cosxtanx - cosx = 0

Factoring out cos x

Cosx( sqrt3tanx - 1) = 0

So you'll still get the same solutions from the tan part as before, but new ones are introduced.

Between 0 and 360 degrees you have solutions for cosx at 90 and 270, neither of which work in the original equation.

Why is this?

Thanks, sorry for the long post
When you multiply by something you can add in extra solutins

It should be clear that cosx cannot equal zero as cos and sin cannot be zero at the same time
6. Okay, thanks guys

Posted from TSR Mobile

TSR Support Team

We have a brilliant team of more than 60 Support Team members looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.

This forum is supported by:
Updated: January 11, 2015
Today on TSR

Choose Respect

University open days

• Manchester Metropolitan University
Wed, 14 Nov '18
• University of Chester
Wed, 14 Nov '18
• Anglia Ruskin University
Ambitious, driven, developing your career & employability? Aspiring in your field, up-skilling after a career break? Then our Postgrad Open Evening is for you. Postgraduate
Wed, 14 Nov '18
Poll
Useful resources

Maths Forum posting guidelines

Not sure where to post? Read the updated guidelines here

How to use LaTex

Writing equations the easy way

Study habits of A* students

Top tips from students who have already aced their exams

Chat with other maths applicants