His life, his past. He has every right to want to save some aspects of it, if only a series of notes on his computer.
In the end, the chances are that you are simply "his next girlfriend". He may know that, and simply be with you because he kinda likes you and you are convinient, or he may be thinking "is she the one?" However, I doubt that he would tell you he loves you if he didn't at least *think* that he did, but who knows if he is in love with you? One can only truly evaluate ones relationships when they have all passed, and one can weigh up how they felt with different people. Chances are, he *thought* he loved the other girls as well, but maybe he has realised (through being with you) that it wasn't real love.
basicaly, you have to accept that people have pasts, and that they might not want to be explicitly honest with you about them (for exactly this reason - people get upset if they don't think they are really unique and special). The WORST thing you can do is bug him about it. Do you have any reason to doubt insincerity on his part, setting aside the fact that (OMG) he said "I love you" to someone in his past and then lied about it (understandable, how else could the conversation have gone - "oh darling, I have never felt this way for anyone before, I have never told anyone I love them before... how about you".... "well, actualy there was this one girl" I don't think so). if you put pressure on people, if you put them in uncomfortable situations, then they are going to wriggle out of them. They will not suddenly give you the answers you want. Put too much pressure on (ie. keep bugging him about this) and they will run, and run fast. In the end, people don't want the hassle. I wouldn't risk it. Just be lovely, drop the issue, keep an eye on how he acts and take things from there.