# 2 Quick questions (M1 and exams)

Watch
Announcements

Page 1 of 1

Go to first unread

Skip to page:

1. In M1, why do we assume that the strings are light and inextensible? I've been told that assuming that it's inextensible guarantees common acceleration but I can't see why. As for light, I've seen two different explanations that both make sense to me one is that it being light lets you treat the mass term in F=ma as zero, meaning that the string must be in equilibrium, making tension problems far easier. The other explanation I've seen is that if the string is light, we don't have to worry about it's mass causing anything to accelerate.

2. I wanna quickly check the whole thing with modules being swapped between maths and further maths, can modules which are ladled as A2 be swapped with modules that are ladled as AS? I've been told that to get an A* in further, you need to average 90% over 3 A2 modules and get a A overall but what would happen if say for example you say FP2, M2 and M3 but didn't score highly enough for either an A or an A*? Could they then swap something like M1 from normal maths to give you an A in further? (of course, this assumes that the swap doesn't effect your maths grade and that the M1 mark is sufficient, and I'm under the impression that FP2 cannot be swapped).

2. I wanna quickly check the whole thing with modules being swapped between maths and further maths, can modules which are ladled as A2 be swapped with modules that are ladled as AS? I've been told that to get an A* in further, you need to average 90% over 3 A2 modules and get a A overall but what would happen if say for example you say FP2, M2 and M3 but didn't score highly enough for either an A or an A*? Could they then swap something like M1 from normal maths to give you an A in further? (of course, this assumes that the swap doesn't effect your maths grade and that the M1 mark is sufficient, and I'm under the impression that FP2 cannot be swapped).

0

reply

Report

#2

(Original post by

1. In M1, why do we assume that the strings are light and inextensible? I've been told that assuming that it's inextensible guarantees common acceleration but I can't see why. As for light, I've seen two different explanations that both make sense to me one is that it being light lets you treat the mass term in F=ma as zero, meaning that the string must be in equilibrium, making tension problems far easier. The other explanation I've seen is that if the string is light, we don't have to worry about it's mass causing anything to accelerate.

**M1Player**)1. In M1, why do we assume that the strings are light and inextensible? I've been told that assuming that it's inextensible guarantees common acceleration but I can't see why. As for light, I've seen two different explanations that both make sense to me one is that it being light lets you treat the mass term in F=ma as zero, meaning that the string must be in equilibrium, making tension problems far easier. The other explanation I've seen is that if the string is light, we don't have to worry about it's mass causing anything to accelerate.

In extensible so that we can assume that length remains constant and that tension is constant through the string

0

reply

Why does the a constant length matter? And what's keeping the tension the same?

0

reply

Report

#4

(Original post by

2. I wanna quickly check the whole thing with modules being swapped between maths and further maths, can modules which are ladled as A2 be swapped with modules that are ladled as AS? I've been told that to get an A* in further, you need to average 90% over 3 A2 modules and get a A overall but what would happen if say for example you say FP2, M2 and M3 but didn't score highly enough for either an A or an A*? Could they then swap something like M1 from normal maths to give you an A in further? (of course, this assumes that the swap doesn't effect your maths grade and that the M1 mark is sufficient, and I'm under the impression that FP2 cannot be swapped).

**M1Player**)2. I wanna quickly check the whole thing with modules being swapped between maths and further maths, can modules which are ladled as A2 be swapped with modules that are ladled as AS? I've been told that to get an A* in further, you need to average 90% over 3 A2 modules and get a A overall but what would happen if say for example you say FP2, M2 and M3 but didn't score highly enough for either an A or an A*? Could they then swap something like M1 from normal maths to give you an A in further? (of course, this assumes that the swap doesn't effect your maths grade and that the M1 mark is sufficient, and I'm under the impression that FP2 cannot be swapped).

FPs have to be in FM

Applications ... A 2 can only be in maths if the related 1 is there as well

After that they are distributed to give the best grade in maths (with the lowest possible score)

Only things with a 2 or higher (not C2) can count as A2 units for the A* in FM

0

reply

Report

#5

(Original post by

Why does the a constant length matter? And what's keeping the tension the same?

**M1Player**)Why does the a constant length matter? And what's keeping the tension the same?

When looking at connected bodies you use the fact that tension is the same at both ends

0

reply

^Yeah... I thought that it might have an energy based explanation, is there a more-M1 style solution?

0

reply

Report

#7

(Original post by

^Yeah... I thought that it might have an energy based explanation, is there a more-M1 style solution?

**M1Player**)^Yeah... I thought that it might have an energy based explanation, is there a more-M1 style solution?

The idea behind all the Mechanics modules is that you're simplifying reality so that you can deal with it using the mathematics you know! If a string is extensible then by definition when you apply a force to it, some of the energy is consumed extending the string rather than just accelerating it. If you go on to study module M3 then you will see how to model extensible strings.

0

reply

^As far as OCR's concerned (and I assume, most M1 course), energy doesn't appear until M2, so I was hoping for an explanation that does not involve energy. I'd already somewhat familiar with spring stuff from the mechanics I've done in physics but I'm just wary in case it appears on an M1 exam.

0

reply

Report

#9

(Original post by

1. In M1, why do we assume that the strings are light and inextensible? I've been told that assuming that it's inextensible guarantees common acceleration but I can't see why. As for light, I've seen two different explanations that both make sense to me one is that it being light lets you treat the mass term in F=ma as zero, meaning that the string must be in equilibrium, making tension problems far easier. The other explanation I've seen is that if the string is light, we don't have to worry about it's mass causing anything to accelerate.

2. I wanna quickly check the whole thing with modules being swapped between maths and further maths, can modules which are ladled as A2 be swapped with modules that are ladled as AS? I've been told that to get an A* in further, you need to average 90% over 3 A2 modules and get a A overall but what would happen if say for example you say FP2, M2 and M3 but didn't score highly enough for either an A or an A*? Could they then swap something like M1 from normal maths to give you an A in further? (of course, this assumes that the swap doesn't effect your maths grade and that the M1 mark is sufficient, and I'm under the impression that FP2 cannot be swapped).

**M1Player**)1. In M1, why do we assume that the strings are light and inextensible? I've been told that assuming that it's inextensible guarantees common acceleration but I can't see why. As for light, I've seen two different explanations that both make sense to me one is that it being light lets you treat the mass term in F=ma as zero, meaning that the string must be in equilibrium, making tension problems far easier. The other explanation I've seen is that if the string is light, we don't have to worry about it's mass causing anything to accelerate.

2. I wanna quickly check the whole thing with modules being swapped between maths and further maths, can modules which are ladled as A2 be swapped with modules that are ladled as AS? I've been told that to get an A* in further, you need to average 90% over 3 A2 modules and get a A overall but what would happen if say for example you say FP2, M2 and M3 but didn't score highly enough for either an A or an A*? Could they then swap something like M1 from normal maths to give you an A in further? (of course, this assumes that the swap doesn't effect your maths grade and that the M1 mark is sufficient, and I'm under the impression that FP2 cannot be swapped).

**inextensible = same acceleration for the two particles.**

Light string means each little bit of string is taken to have zero mass, so m x a = 0 so the forces on the little bit of string must cancel out, so the tension above that little bit of string must equal the tension below it, i.e.

**the tension in the string is the same all the way along the string.**

While we're at it, a smooth pulley means that the tensions on both sides of the pulley are equal.

The bold bits are the answers you need for M1 questions of the type "how have you

**used**the fact that ......

0

reply

Report

#10

(Original post by

^As far as OCR's concerned (and I assume, most M1 course), energy doesn't appear until M2, so I was hoping for an explanation that does not involve energy. I'd already somewhat familiar with spring stuff from the mechanics I've done in physics but I'm just wary in case it appears on an M1 exam.

**M1Player**)^As far as OCR's concerned (and I assume, most M1 course), energy doesn't appear until M2, so I was hoping for an explanation that does not involve energy. I'd already somewhat familiar with spring stuff from the mechanics I've done in physics but I'm just wary in case it appears on an M1 exam.

You don't have the mathematics to deal with energy problems in M1, so you assuume that all strings are inextensible and then you don't have to worry about energy at al!

0

reply

X

Page 1 of 1

Go to first unread

Skip to page:

### Quick Reply

Back

to top

to top