The Student Room Group

This discussion is now closed.

Check out other Related discussions

How do you define - working class, middle class, upper class?

How do you define - working class, middle class, upper class?

Scroll to see replies

I'd go by the 'classic' way as it were,
lower class - manual labour, poor, state sponsored those sort of criteria
Middle Class - White collar workers, home owners, disposable income anyone earning over £35k PA i'd say
Upper Class - I stand by you only reach that when you're the aristocracy you could be a billionaire but unless you come from the right blood or get titled you remain simply rich and not upper class and of course they must be British and maintain the old British traditions such as RP voice, manners and what not :wink:
working class - manual workers, unskilled jobs like cleaner or retail assistant, non-uni educated
middle class - teachers, lawyers, managers in companies, basically mostly uni educated people in white collar jobs or non-uni educated people who make the same kind of salary
upper class - aristocracy, or self made millionaires, or celebrity actors/singers/musicians, entertainment industry executives or footballers etc. basically people who only work out of hobby and dont have to work if they dont want to.
Very difficult I think the class system is flawed. Just because you are working class does not mean you are not rich in a world sense. In fact most of us are top in terms of wealth in a worldly sense as we do not go through absolute poverty, most UK people have a home etc...
I define class by profession, status and upbringing rather than the American notion of wealth (so a penniless duke is still upper-class).

Upper-class: aristocracy and traditional landed gentry.

Upper middle-class: traditionally elite professions (consultants (medicine), barristers, investment bankers, ambassadors, ministers, bishops) and wealthy businessmen.

Middle-class: doctors, accountants, top-end managers, academics, etc.

Lower middle-class: teachers, small business owners, clerical managers, etc.

Working-class: labourers, shop workers, service industry workers, etc.

Under-class: people who refuse to work out of laziness and are generally associated with anti-social behaviour, criminality, etc.

Original post by driftawaay
working class - manual workers, unskilled jobs like cleaner or retail assistant, non-uni educated
middle class - teachers, lawyers, managers in companies, basically mostly uni educated people in white collar jobs or non-uni educated people who make the same kind of salary
upper class - aristocracy, or self made millionaires, or celebrity actors/singers/musicians, entertainment industry executives or footballers etc. basically people who only work out of hobby and dont have to work if they dont want to.


Wayne Rooney is upper-class?
(edited 8 years ago)
Reply 6
Original post by Lady Comstock
Wayne Rooney is upper-class?


May not be but his grandchildren will be, that is if he doesn't blow his money
Original post by Soldieroffortune

Upper Class - I stand by you only reach that when you're the aristocracy you could be a billionaire but unless you come from the right blood or get titled you remain simply rich and not upper class and of course they must be British and maintain the old British traditions such as RP voice, manners and what not :wink:


this is right, and see for example the snobbery directed at Carole Middleton. The British upper class isn't like the American: you are only born into it. David Beckham and Elton John belong to a global jetset, which is something distinct, and in Britain are working class (multi)millionaires.

It's because we don't have mobilty into the upper class, and because the working class is (proportionately) shrinking that in Britian class distinctions are most fine grained within the middle class.

Upper middle - both parents were privately educated, Great-grandfathers include a surgeon, a barrister, and a colonial administrator. A grandparent was born in e.g. China or India. There is 'land' in the family and a 'family college' at Oxford or Cambridge.

Middle middle - Parents in the professions: solicitor, architect, accountant. Grammar school products, one or both of them went to university, though no grandparent did. Read a broadsheet. Holiday in France or Italy. Going to Greece means Athens and not Kos. There are hardbacked books at home. The radio's tuned to R4.

Lower middle - Parents self-employed or in local government, the police or NHS management. Dad has a HND. Focus and a Fiesta on the crazy paving. Gas barbecue.The Mail on Sunday supplement, then off to the garden center. Sunday lunches at pub restaurants. You're the first to go to university: 'you'll be wanting to do a sandwich course for the experience, son'.

Working class - dad drives a bus, manages a shop, or is a sparks but not self-employed. Mum works at Debenhams. Nan and Gramps live within walking distance, it's walking distance even for them. Football on boxing day. Yours are the youngest parents dropping off in freshers' week: early 40s, most people's look ancient. Your mum comes to your graduation dressed as if for a wedding.
Original post by cambio wechsel
.

Thank you :smile:

Don't forget the under class though; the benfit scroungers, never work, drunks/druggies, probably incestuous, parents are only about 10 years older than them basically the filth of society...
Original post by Lady Comstock
Wayne Rooney is upper-class?


Yes, I think it was clear from my post that I regard anyone who is a millionaire as upper class.
Original post by cambio wechsel
this is right, and see for example the snobbery directed at Carole Middleton. The British upper class isn't like the American: you are only born into it. David Beckham and Elton John belong to a global jetset, which is something distinct, and in Britain are working class (multi)millionaires.

It's because we don't have mobilty into the upper class, and because the working class is (proportionately) shrinking that in Britian class distinctions are most fine grained within the middle class.

Upper middle - both parents were privately educated, Great-grandfathers include a surgeon, a barrister, and a colonial administrator. A grandparent was born in e.g. China or India. There is 'land' in the family and a 'family college' at Oxford or Cambridge.

Middle middle - Parents in the professions: solicitor, architect, accountant. Grammar school products, one or both of them went to university, though no grandparent did. Read a broadsheet. Holiday in France or Italy. Going to Greece means Athens and not Kos. There are hardbacked books at home. The radio's tuned to R4.

Lower middle - Parents self-employed or in local government, the police or NHS management. Dad has a HND. Focus and a Fiesta on the crazy paving. Gas barbecue.The Mail on Sunday supplement, then off to the garden center. Sunday lunches at pub restaurants. You're the first to go to university: 'you'll be wanting to do a sandwich course for the experience, son'.

Working class - dad drives a bus, manages a shop, or is a sparks but not self-employed. Mum works at Debenhams. Nan and Gramps live within walking distance, it's walking distance even for them. Football on boxing day. Yours are the youngest parents dropping off in freshers' week: early 40s, most people's look ancient. Your mum comes to your graduation dressed as if for a wedding.


Where would you class someone whose parents are both barristers, both of whom went to state school and one of whom was previously a nurse and raised by a dirt poor auxillary nurse widower with three other children, who is a second university goer on both sides, who went to public school but was raised by a single parent in one of the worst areas of south London and who is not too distantly related to the Marquesses of Londonderry?
Original post by Birkenhead
Where would you class someone whose parents are both barristers, both of whom went to state school and one of whom was previously a nurse and raised by a dirt poor auxillary nurse widower with three other children, who is a second university goer on both sides, who went to public school but was raised by a single parent in one of the worst areas of south London and who is not too distantly related to the Marquesses of Londonderry?


have you been reading Antonia Byatt again?
Original post by Birkenhead
Where would you class someone whose parents are both barristers, both of whom went to state school and one of whom was previously a nurse and raised by a dirt poor auxillary nurse widower with three other children, who is a second university goer on both sides, who went to public school but was raised by a single parent in one of the worst areas of south London and who is not too distantly related to the Marquesses of Londonderry?


Upper-middle when they are a child (parents' professions trumps the more remote considerations) and the class when they are independent adults depends on their own profession.

I think the hierarchy of determining class is: own profession/status -> upbringing (school/university/parents' professions) -> demeanour/behaviour -> income -> wider background (more distant relatives).

For instance, I would consider a government minister upper middle-class, even if they grew up on a council estate with generations of family members having worked as labourers.
Original post by cambio wechsel
have you been reading Antonia Byatt again?


Well, exactly. There are plenty of others
Original post by Birkenhead
Well, exactly. There are plenty of others


Good lord, are there? And I hadn't meant that this is Byatt's background, just that it's only through reading her I meet people who work in jam factories but are related to the viceroy of India; her or - nasty habit - Iris Murdoch.

I'm lower middle class, mind, so it's a comparatively limited world for me.
Original post by cambio wechsel
Good lord, are there? And I hadn't meant that this is Byatt's background, just that it's only through reading her I meet people who work in jam factories but are related to the viceroy of India; her or - nasty habit - Iris Murdoch.


If I wanted to contrive relations with a big cheese I'd go for Birkenhead or Churchill, not an infamous appeaser of the Nazis. Still, believe what you like.

Original post by cambio wechsel
I'm lower middle class, mind, so it's a comparatively limited world for me.


I'd never have had you down as a Mail reader, let alone a perpetrator of crazy paving.
(edited 8 years ago)
Original post by driftawaay
Yes, I think it was clear from my post that I regard anyone who is a millionaire as upper class.


You'd regard that brainless and hairless yob as upper class?He is simply one of the Nouveau riche, classicly speaking he cant be upper class...
Original post by Birkenhead
If I wanted to contrive relations with a big cheese I'd go for Birkenhead or Churchill, not an infamous appeaser of the Nazis. Still, believe what you like. We're all related to Charlemagne.


I genuinely hadn't twigged this as you. I thought you were inventing a corner case to catch me out.

Original post by Birkenhead
I'd never have had you down as a Mail reader, let alone a perpetrator of crazy paving.


I'm very much from the world of loft-conversions, three piece suites, tiramisu and the Sunday Express, yes. My mum and dad have a gas barbecue "it's changed our lives Ken, it has really".
Original post by Soldieroffortune
I'd go by the 'classic' way as it were,
lower class - manual labour, poor, state sponsored those sort of criteria
Middle Class - White collar workers, home owners, disposable income anyone earning over £35k PA i'd say
Upper Class - I stand by you only reach that when you're the aristocracy you could be a billionaire but unless you come from the right blood or get titled you remain simply rich and not upper class and of course they must be British and maintain the old British traditions such as RP voice, manners and what not :wink:


yeah this is so true- the class system is so rigid-it's not like in America where its just to do with how much money you have, its very complex and all do to with being born into the 'right' family and socialising w/ certain people
Original post by driftawaay
working class - manual workers, unskilled jobs like cleaner or retail assistant, non-uni educated
middle class - teachers, lawyers, managers in companies, basically mostly uni educated people in white collar jobs or non-uni educated people who make the same kind of salary
upper class - aristocracy, or self made millionaires, or celebrity actors/singers/musicians, entertainment industry executives or footballers etc. basically people who only work out of hobby and dont have to work if they dont want to.


most footballers are working class id say

Latest

Trending

Trending