Corbyn agrees to share platform with Holocaust denier

Therefore since Jeremy Corbyn has the support of some Jewish people, nothing he does can be considered anti-Semetic?

Because nothing insults all Jewish people?

If Jeremy Corbyn has been anti-Semetic, then so have you.

X

You claim to have relatives who died in the Holocaust. I have relatives who died in the Holocaust. There is no sense in which you have an inherently greater link to that disaster, or right to claim some kind of offence.



Utter nonsense. You are the one who keeps saying "I'm Jewish therefore my opinion against Israel cannot be challenged".

I was criticising Jeremy Corbyn, you were the one who brought up your claimed Jewishness as if to say, "I'm Jewish and I like him therefore he axiomatically could not be a supporter of Holocaust deniers"

If you believe that you are stupid.



Insulting all Jewish people (such as ascribing some sort of negative characteristic to Jewish people) would insult all Jewish people. Insulting someone who happens to be Jewish is not anti-semitic. It's pretty simple, no?



How does that work? Try explaining it.

When you do, you'll read it back and think, "Wait, that doesn't work. I'm an idiot"

So opposing what the kapos did is bad?

No doubt in my mind now that you are a gentile, and huge anti-semite

You claim to have relatives who died in the Holocaust. I have relatives who died in the Holocaust. There is no sense in which you have an inherently greater link to that disaster, or right to claim some kind of offence.



Utter nonsense. You are the one who keeps saying "I'm Jewish therefore my opinion against Israel cannot be challenged".

I was criticising Jeremy Corbyn, you were the one who brought up your claimed Jewishness as if to say, "I'm Jewish and I like him therefore he axiomatically could not be a supporter of Holocaust deniers"

You're talking to the same guy who claimed on here that he personally witnessed "Jewish only roads" when he went to Israel...........even though they don't exist.

I don't believe that, I carried on your logic.

You said that insulting Bornblue could not be anti-Semetic since
"Insulting a Jewish person =/= Insulting all Jewish people"

The logic being that it wasn't anti-Semetic since it didn't insult all Jewish people.

I pointed out that since your defence was that you didn't insult all Jews, then equally Corbyn could use that defence

Do keep up ExitedPup! You effectively called your own logic 'stupid', well done!

If you think that's logic, no wonder you're applying for a university ranked in the 170s. I'll try to simplify my response so it's at your level.

http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4353235,00.html

And that's from Ynet- a Jewish, Israeli mainstream paper.
Nice try.

So now you're making ad homenium attacks on a person's university after having a go at me for it

Oh you're such a hypocrite and an anti-semitic hypocrite at that.

You're talking to the same guy who claimed on here that he personally witnessed "Jewish only roads" when he went to Israel...........even though they don't exist.

If you think that's logic, no wonder you're applying for a university ranked in the 170s. I'll try to simplify my response so it's at your level.

It's not an ad hominem attack, it's a factual observation that provides a good explanation for why his understanding of logic is so absurdly incoherent



You're only making the accusation because you were found out for pretending to be Jewish when you're actually a left-wing gentile. Repeatedly making the accusation that I'm an anti-semite because I pointed out your support for people who associate with Holocaust deniers doesn't work.

You have been anti-Semetic towards Bornblue because you said that he would happily push other Jews into the Gas chambers, that is something that you decided to say because he was Jewish

It was meant to be a really low blow, because it paints him as a quisling, as a 'self-hating Jew'.

And I have never, ever supported Holocaust deniers nor people who 'associate' (whatever the **** that means) with them.

Whenever I bring up the facts I believe supports my point, you never ever actually respond to them. You simply go back to the contentious personal stuff.

The fact you keep failing to address the point about Raed Salah tells us everything we need to know

It was meant to be a really low blow, because it paints him as a quisling, as a 'self-hating Jew' and therefore allows you to try to use that to discredit him in this argument.

Do you think Alvin Rosenfeld is anti-semitic?

That's because you keep inventing claims which are false.