I'm not really replying to anyone in particular, but I wanted to state my opinion on the whole thing after reading a few of the posts. I've followed this whole ordeal since it began.
First, this girl went willingly to meet Toby Studabaker. Whether she knew he was 31 or not... Did she honestly think that a kid her age or even around her age would be able to travel internationally?? She lied to her parents and asked for her passport so that she could get a bus pass, and then went to meet this man at the airport where she then obviously willingly went on a plane with him to another country. She has stated more than once to her parents that she was fine and was not being kept against her will. He made sure she was safe, and returned her unharmed as the articles I have read have stated. Sounds to me like he did nothing harmful to her sexually or otherwise. Sounds like she went willingly and was decietful to many people in this ordeal including him, and her parents.
Now about her age discrepancy. IMO She told him that she was older. Once the man saw her however... there's a huge difference between a 12 year old girl and a 19 year old woman... HUGE... maybe she looked older in her pictures, but not possible to pull off a 7 year adolescent difference. To much goes on physically in those 7 years. So for once seeing this girl, and knowing that she's not 18/19 like she may have said before, and then traveling across country lines. That in itself is a crime and if nothing else he should be prosecuted for his poor judgement in those actions.
As for the child pornography... I dont believe it... I have not seen this reported in but a few articles that I have read. And it's also early in the game... He has not been charged with this, nor has there been any prosecution for it so i think this one we need to wait out until we have more of the truth in this accusation. His not harming the girl physically/sexually does not indicate that he is a child sexual predator.
I've also read a bit about his past. He sounds like an upstanding man. He attended a christian college, and stated he couldn't wait to get out of the army so that he could better serve God. He was honorably discharged from the army and has protected our country against terrorism since Sept. 11 His character is of high value and its unfortunate that something like this would have to taint the image of our country internationally. If any truth comes to the suspicions of sexual assult... kidnapping whatever, its unfortunate that it taints out country as a whole
Any who... those are just some of my opinions.