The Student Room Group

Scroll to see replies

Reply 20

PQ
when do you believe sperm + egg becomes an unborn child?


At conception.

Reply 21

Martin Daugherty
Don't you see that when you have an abortion you impose your morality on the unborn child?

Unborn child is an oxymoron. It can be either a foetus, unborn by definition, or a child, conversely, born by definition.

Reply 22

Juncture
Even if I didn't agree with abortion at all (I agree with it in some circumstances but that's irrelevant to this point) I'd much rather it stayed legal

If it's illegal people will try and get backstreet abortions which aren't done with the proper cleanliness and hygiene in mind as well as other things and aren't very safe and so people die


Should we legalise rape and murder in that case, to make it safe?

Reply 23

Enchanté
I don't agree with abortion whatsoever, I reckon it should be done in certain places and limit the abortion clinics.


When do you think it ought to be done?
Martin Daugherty
At conception.

which point of conception - it's a pretty complex process with no real start or end point?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_fertilisation

When:
The sperm passes through the corona radiata, the outermost cell layer of the egg,
or when:
The sperm breaks through the zona pellucida.
or when:
The cell membranes of the egg and sperm fuse together.
or when:
The female egg, also called a secondary oocyte at this stage, completes its second meiotic division. This results in a mature ovum.
or when:
The sperm's tail and mitochondria degenerate with the formation of the male pronucleus. This is why all mitochondria in humans are of maternal origin.
or when:
The male and female pronuclei fuse to form a new nucleus that is a combination of the genetic material from both the sperm and egg.

Or maybe when the new nucleus cell starts to divide?

Reply 25

Lucia.
Has anyone read Freakonomics?

It's very interesting that higher abortion rates lead to lower crime rates. :smile:


Crime is rife, prison are full, this was not a problem prior to the legalisation of abortion.
Martin Daugherty
Should we legalise rape and murder in that case, to make it safe?

what an odd leap of logic?

A more sensible one would have been to ask whether we should legalise drugs to reduce the harm caused (to society and to individuals) at the moment by their illegality.
Martin Daugherty
Crime is rife, prison are full, this was not a problem prior to the legalisation of abortion.

Your profile states that you are in Ireland where abortion hasn't been legalised.

Is Ireland crime free?

Reply 28

Eevuul
that actually makes sense... doesn't seem unlikely that children who aren't wanted by their parents (or whose parents can't deal with the burden of a child) would turn to crime

I am pro-abortion. sounds a bit heartless, but I personally think that people place too much value on the life of an unborn child... I think the lives of those who mean something to other people and whose death would have a major impact on the lives of others are far more important than the life of an unborn child whose parents don't even want it or would be better off without it


Sounds like classic genocide.

Reply 29

Until you are in a situation where you are pregnant with a child you cannot feasibly keep (for whatever reason), how is it possible to know how you would cope? Many people get pregnant even though they use contraception. Others are raped. Some are just irresponsible and don't think of the consequences. I know people who have had abortions and it has severely affected them. It's not that they didn't want to keep the baby, but that they knew they couldn't in their situation. Had they had the baby, they would not have been able to part with it and put it up for adoption and the heart-wrenching decision of abortion was made.
There are also cases when the foetus has a desease or problems developing. Would you want to have a child that suffers all it's life.
Also, what about the lady pregnant with octuplets who refused to abort any of them, even though she knew they would all die if she didn't? By aborting 4 babies, she could have saved 4. Instead they all died.
I'm not saying any of this is right or wrong. But it would not be practical to ban abortions.

Reply 30

it's interesting that some people who insist that you shouldn't impose your 'morality' (or lack of) on the foetus, becuase it doesn't have a voice, or whatever, are the same people who will drag their children off to church from age 0, and warn them of the 'sins' they are committing if their child ever engages in pre-maritual sex, or homosexuality, completely removing any chance their children may have to infact form their own ideas of 'morality'.

Reply 31

o-e-s-j
1. shouldn't this be in have your say?

2. <flamebait> this forum is seems to dominated by intelligent agnostics/atheists so your not likely to find many people against abortion. </flamebait>

3. my opinion:: abortion is clearly a good thing, why on earth would anyone want a baby to be born when its not wanted?


A) intelligent atheists who believe morality is the domain of logic? give me a break. i`m not into religion but to call those kind of people intelligent is an insult to the species. We must sterilise the black people, they are reproducing too quickly for their own good... its kindness to sterilise...its goodness...

B) killing an unborn baby is not "CLEARLY a good thing". Witness the depths of your delusion. It should be made on a case by case basis. To me it seems a very sterile and soulless practice. Its not really natural. Theres this whole "quick! if we kill it now, it doesn`t count as murder" air about it...

C) Even if a child will be "unwanted", adoption would be better than death surely? Tell you what, why not let the child be born and ask it in 10 years time whether it would have preferred to have been killed in the womb. Besides I think once you`ve given birth to a child theres natural tendency to want to keep it.

D) You get pregnant for a reason. Theres enough contraception out there to sink armadas of titanics. Its generally the rule of life that you reap what you sow. I think people should learn to deal with it rather than trying to rationalise a way out of their own mistakes. Of course its different when rape is involved or something but when used as some form of after-contraception, surely most people would be against abortion? :confused: Unless we slipped into the twilight zone and I missed it.

Reply 32

Louise_1988
Unborn child is an oxymoron. It can be either a foetus, unborn by definition, or a child, conversely, born by definition.


Precisely.

Reply 33

Louise_1988
it's interesting that some people who insist that you shouldn't impose your 'morality' (or lack of) on the foetus, becuase it doesn't have a voice, or whatever, are the same people who will drag their children off to church from age 0, and warn them of the 'sins' they are committing if their child ever engages in pre-maritual sex, or homosexuality, completely removing any chance their children may have to infact form their own ideas of 'morality'.


Some people, but not all. Morality is not just a question for Christians.

Reply 34

PQ
which point of conception - it's a pretty complex process with no real start or end point?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_fertilisation

When:
The sperm passes through the corona radiata, the outermost cell layer of the egg,
or when:
The sperm breaks through the zona pellucida.
or when:
The cell membranes of the egg and sperm fuse together.
or when:
The female egg, also called a secondary oocyte at this stage, completes its second meiotic division. This results in a mature ovum.
or when:
The sperm's tail and mitochondria degenerate with the formation of the male pronucleus. This is why all mitochondria in humans are of maternal origin.
or when:
The male and female pronuclei fuse to form a new nucleus that is a combination of the genetic material from both the sperm and egg.

Or maybe when the new nucleus cell starts to divide?


That's nice.

Doesn't change anything though.

Reply 35

PQ
what an odd leap of logic?

A more sensible one would have been to ask whether we should legalise drugs to reduce the harm caused (to society and to individuals) at the moment by their illegality.



The odd leap of logic comes from yourself insofar as making the assumption that killing people outside of the womb is a greater crime than killing those inside.

Reply 36

I don't think abortion is worng, I think everyone should have a choice as to whether they have a baby or not, but abortion isn't something that I would do.
However, I don't agree with people who use it as a form of contraception

Reply 37

Martin Daugherty
But you think it is OK to put the unborn at the obvious risk of abortion, and to impose your morals upon them too?


Life begins at conception? It's just an arbitrary line isn't it?

If you believe that, then you're almost also saying that people can't wear condoms.

Anyway, I'd like to point out that women shouldn't be condemned for having an abortion as if it is an act of "murder". It's a very difficult decision for anyone to make. Although I agree that such a decision shouldn't be made lightly. I don't think people should use it as contraception; as I've said only in exceptional circumstances should it be used.

ah this is such a sensitive issue.

Reply 38

PQ
Your profile states that you are in Ireland where abortion hasn't been legalised.

Is Ireland crime free?


Odd leap of logic.

I have not claimed that not making abortion legal correlates to no crime.

Reply 39

SiAz
when used as some form of after-contraception, surely most people would be against abortion? :confused: Unless we slipped into the twilight zone and I missed it.

So, do you view the morning after pill in the same way? If it works, the effects are the same as abortion. The only difference is that you don't know for definate if you are pregnant or not.

Just ban sex altogether. People can procreate by artificial insemination after a rigorous screening procedure!!!!!:biggrin:

How The Student Room is moderated

To keep The Student Room safe for everyone, we moderate posts that are added to the site.