The Student Room Group

This discussion is now closed.

Check out other Related discussions

Is Paedophilla always wrong? Should it be legalised?

Paedophillia is prevalent in the bible and occurs in Middle Eastern countries. Also we've become accepting of all sorts of bizarre sexual orientations- homosexuality, asexuality, necrophillia and beastiality. The fact these are all accepted as the norm these days in society raises a quietly controversial question- should our views on Paedophillia change?

Scroll to see replies

Reply 1
Original post by BugzyMalone
Paedophillia is prevalent in the bible and occurs in Middle Eastern countries. Also we've become accepting of all sorts of bizarre sexual orientations- homosexuality, asexuality, necrophillia and beastiality. The fact these are all accepted as the norm these days in society raises a quietly controversial question- should our views on Paedophillia change?


Being gay is Bizarre?

How?

And we don't accept necrophilia pedophilia and bestiality, at least not in the West
Reply 2
Original post by BugzyMalone
should our views on Paedophillia change?


Yes, it should be treated more as a mental illness.

No, it should'nt be legalised.
Reply 3
I didn't know people had become accepting of necrophilia?

What a relief.
They should be pitied, unless they act on it. And then they should be dismemebered.
Pedophilia is legal
Original post by Reue
Yes, it should be treated more as a mental illness.

No, it should'nt be legalised.


I would say the sexuality should be treated as a mental illness but the act of molesting a child(or buying porn that propagates molestation of children) is unforgivable, as an adult you are responsible for controlling your body and so the punishment for it should stay the same.
Paedophilia is ok.
Child abuse is not.

Peadophilia is as natural as homosexuality. Yes, I said it.

/Thread.
(edited 8 years ago)
Original post by BugzyMalone
Paedophillia is prevalent in the bible and occurs in Middle Eastern countries. Also we've become accepting of all sorts of bizarre sexual orientations- homosexuality, asexuality, necrophillia and beastiality. The fact these are all accepted as the norm these days in society raises a quietly controversial question- should our views on Paedophillia change?


Homosexuality is legal in some places because it is too controversial to debate the origins.
Asexuality isn't enough an issue where it wasn't accepted, to have to be accepted, so no.
Necrophilia is obviously sick for probably more reasons than anything else. You'd have to be really insane to debate that it isn't.
Bestiality is seen as animal abuse and was too deemed acceptable ages ago, but I'm not sure it's illegal. It needs to be.

Pedophilia is wrong because it is sexual abuse, or engaging in sexual activity or molestation or exposure to someone who can't defend themselves. It is also seen as an abuse of authority. If someone came up to you when you were a kid and touched you or tried to have sex with you, you'd probably be scared and confused. It's child welfare. Are you saying eradicate child welfare for the sole wispy purpose of being nice?
Reply 9
Original post by josh75
I would say the sexuality should be treated as a mental illness but the act of molesting a child(or buying porn that propagates molestation of children) is unforgivable, as an adult you are responsible for controlling your body and so the punishment for it should stay the same.


I agree. Being a paedophile doesn't make you a molester in the same way that being straight doesn't make you a rapist and so those who act on it should (rightly so) be treated criminally.
I don't think paedophilia is illegal. Do we have a thought police here in Britain.
Original post by Keyhofi
Paedophilia is ok.
Child abuse is not.

Peadophilia is as natural as homosexuality. Yes, I said it.

/Thread.


Since when was pedophilia reduced to the mere attraction. If I am a bibliophile, it means I read books a lot because I like them a lot. "Phile" as a suffix means when someone enjoys it and partakes in it as a hobby. It's not just one thing/attraction and "end of."
It's absolutely vile, and anybody who thinks different must have a few issues themselves.

The Ian Watkins case is something that I will never be able to get out of my head, I read the report on it and I wish I could erase it from my mind. Absolutely terrible, I cried when I read about what he done to those poor little babies. How can anybody physically or mentally hurt someone so little and innocent... I just can't even begin to understand. This thread annoys me hugely.
Reply 13
Simply having the thoughts is not illegal, so it wasn't that to which I was referring.
(edited 8 years ago)
Original post by Cherie Amour
Homosexuality is legal in some places because it is too controversial to debate the origins.
Asexuality isn't enough an issue where it wasn't accepted, to have to be accepted, so no.
Necrophilia is obviously sick for probably more reasons than anything else. You'd have to be really insane to debate that it isn't.
Bestiality is seen as animal abuse and was too deemed acceptable ages ago, but I'm not sure it's illegal. It needs to be.

Pedophilia is wrong because it is sexual abuse, or engaging in sexual activity or molestation or exposure to someone who can't defend themselves. It is also seen as an abuse of authority. If someone came up to you when you were a kid and touched you or tried to have sex with you, you'd probably be scared and confused. It's child welfare. Are you saying eradicate child welfare for the sole wispy purpose of being nice?


The question was should it be legal, not should it be right.

Homosexuality, Asexuality, Necrophilia (some aspects) and Pedophilia are all legal in most of the civilised world.
Original post by Cherie Amour
Since when was pedophilia reduced to the mere attraction. If I am a bibliophile, it means I read books a lot because I like them a lot. "Phile" as a suffix means when someone enjoys it and partakes in it as a hobby. It's not just one thing/attraction and "end of."


Paedophilia is just an attraction(/thoughts). Like homosexuality is just an attraction(/thoughts). There is a difference between experiencing these feelings and acting on them. You can be a homosexual without ever having a same-sex partner, and you can be a paedophile without ever being near a child.
(edited 8 years ago)
Yes, lets legalise sexual abuse of children. Plonker.
Original post by bassbabe
Yes, lets legalise sexual abuse of children. Plonker.


Pedophilia isn't the sexual abuse of children and this whole question is flawed because pedophilia is already legal so you're as much a plonker as OP
Original post by elliemayxo
It's absolutely vile, and anybody who thinks different must have a few issues themselves.

But, as NYU2012 explained above, paedophilia itself (meaning 'sexual feelings towards children') doesn't harm anyone.
Original post by Docjones1
The question was should it be legal, not should it be right.

Homosexuality, Asexuality, Necrophilia (some aspects) and Pedophilia are all legal in most of the civilised world.


What? Normally what is made illegal is something deemed wrong.

Original post by Keyhofi
Paedophilia is just an attraction. Like homosexuality is just an attraction. There is a difference between experiencing these feelings and acting on them. You can be a homosexual without ever having a same-sex partner, and you can be a paedophile without ever being near a child.


Understand what "phile" is. You're defining the social use, not actual meaning.

Latest

Trending

Trending