Don't get me wrong - i live just outside Bristol and regularly visit the city of Bath. It's a great place and one of the most attractive cities in the UK (in my opinion). After liking the city so much, the university was just a bit of a let down.
The accommodation i saw was just damn ugly - it was down very narrow and dark corridors - the rooms were small and grotty and there was little light - the pod ensuits were also awful. Perhaps i saw the worst of it but why they would take a tour of perspective students and their parents to the worst accommodation is beyond me.
I had always thought that the university would be like the city but that's simply not the case - the university was very concrete and unattractive - it probably isn't the worst but it just didn't impress. I went with a few friends who also applied to Bath and none of us were particularly impressed by the university. The centre campus where the steps are to the lake and students union/cafes was very confined and unappealing. I don't think it helped that when i visited they were doing a lot of building work.
I just had high expectations for Bath and felt very let down by the place and definitely wouldn't have liked to spend 3 years there from first impressions.
Like i said, its not the worst but it's just nothing like the city of Bath.
Manchester accommodation was a lot better. I went on open days to Bristol, St Andrews, Bath, Warwick, Lancaster and Nottingham and the interviews at Oxford and apart from Oxford and St Andrews, Manchester by far had the best accommodation. Because i was staying with a friend she was able to take me around all the different accommodation buildings and i was able to see all her friends rooms and the facilities available. Every place was very impressive from the modern of Richmond Park to the Grandeur of the all female 'oxford' type hall.
I stayed there for 3 nights and was able to get a real taste of university life. Going out with students up there was a great laugh. Everyone was very friendly in the hall i was staying in and even on buses and out and about all the students were sociable. This could however just have been down to luck. Perhaps it would have been different with different people in the halls or if i had met different people, but from i what i experienced it was great.
The one thing i would say is that it is a little intimidating - due to the huge numbers of students in that area of Manchester - they are just everywhere - the buses are full and everywhere you go is packed with students. I guess smaller places would have more of a friendly community feel to them as it would be impossible to ever get to know even the smallest percentage of students in Manchester. personally i like that as it means you can always meet new people and you can get away and just blend if in needed. A small campus where everyone knows you such as bath may get a bit claustrophobic.
With regards to whether i would have taken the offer up from Bath if i had gotten one, i couldn't say. I was set on going to bath just because it was Bath - close to home for me, a good name university and in a nice city. I might have just accepted the offer before really visiting other places - ican't say what i would have done. What i can say is that it would have been a big mistake if i had done that. The rejection forced me to consider my alternatives for the first time and i'm so glad things have worked out the way they did. After visiting my other options i know that Manchester is where i'll have the most fun and best university experience.
Having said all of that, different people like and want different things.