The Student Room Group

Just need honest advice!

I've known a girl as friends for about 3 years, and we dated for about a year, before she finished with me about 2 months ago. Everything was great, except we were both under a lot of strain with exams at the time we broke up, and the stress affected our relationship. She said she still wanted to be friends and nothing more, and that it could really work out. I wasn't so sure.

Since then, she asked me to meet up as friends with her, so I went over to watch a DVD. One thing led to another, and we ended up sleeping together. She suggested getting back together to which I agreed. Then she rang me later in the evening, saying that she hated me because she told me before she didn't want to get back with her, and I abused the situation. I apologised, and left it at that.

The next week, she apologises, and says she'd like to try friends by going out for lunch. We go, and it's great, we talk like we used to. She says that 'it's so great that you want to be just friends', I reply 'well, that's not really true, and you know it', but we'll leave it at that. We muck around, and she ends up kissing me. I say I'm confused, so does she, and we both kinda suggest that we are just friends, and if stuff like this happens, then it happens, but that we shouldn't be angry at each other for it, she admits she's still attracted to me, but couldn't see herself getting back with me due to the hurt of the break up.

So after that, we still talk on the phone quite a bit, but as of yet, haven't seen each other yet. Was meant to see her at the weekend, but she cancelled saying she had to much exam revision (which is true as I know she has). I suggested taking her for a drink near to hers for an hour or so this week. She rang me and said that she couldn't, as really had to get revising and had already had one day off this weekend, she said she'd see me on Friday. I said that's fine, even though I was a bit disappointed.

This whole thing is driving me mad though! In some ways, I'm wondering whether it's best if I don't have anything more to do with her! I think she's seeing someone else at the moment, which is fair enough, but she's not saying anything! In these situations, is it best to cut off all contact, or be friends whenever she wants to? I just want a solution to all this confusion. I don't think she knows what she wants, and I'm stuck!

Any suggestions?

Scroll to see replies

Reply 1
Just drives me mental! :s-smilie:
In a way.... you're kind of in a similar situation to me.... my post is slightly further down this page..... you're obviously both really flirty with each other... but she won't talk to you about how she really feels... and you haven't a clue where you stand! I can't offer much help.... but I understand how fustrasted you must be feeling!
Reply 3
Why do you feel obliged to organise things to do with her?

Back off mate. You're just friends now; you're not going out anymore.
Nix don't you ever organise to meet up with friends? I don't think there is anything wrong with his organising to meet her as friends.... strikes me as a bit odd that you seem to think that just because they are 'just friends' they aren't allowed to talk or meet up!
Reply 5
Anonymous
Nix don't you ever organise to meet up with friends? I don't think there is anything wrong with his organising to meet her as friends.... strikes me as a bit odd that you seem to think that just because they are 'just friends' they aren't allowed to talk or meet up!


Of course I do. It's part of being a good friend with someone. You are however, missing the point. The OP appears to be going above and beyond that which is just 'casual'. He needs to back off a bit.
Nix is spot on, to the OP you need to back off a bit, clearly she isn't really sure what she wants.
Reply 7
And as the OP, I agree with that!!! I did try and arrange things in a fairly casual way, but I totally see your point!
Reply 8
And when you keep hanging around with her your probably just confusing her further into making the wrong decision. Perhaps she's starting to feel bad as you mkae such an effort she finds it hard to just keep it at friends. There's no problem with arranging things every now and then with friends but maybe just talk to her casually NOT go out of your way , e.g. a hi on msn every now and then , you get the idea. I think she'll then have the time she needs to sort out what SHE needs in her head. Good luck :smile:
Reply 9
Thanks for that - as the OP it did make me think!
Reply 10
Anonymous
I've known a girl as friends for about 3 years, and we dated for about a year, before she finished with me about 2 months ago. Everything was great, except we were both under a lot of strain with exams at the time we broke up, and the stress affected our relationship. She said she still wanted to be friends and nothing more, and that it could really work out. I wasn't so sure.

Since then, she asked me to meet up as friends with her, so I went over to watch a DVD. One thing led to another, and we ended up sleeping together. She suggested getting back together to which I agreed. Then she rang me later in the evening, saying that she hated me because she told me before she didn't want to get back with her, and I abused the situation. I apologised, and left it at that.

The next week, she apologises, and says she'd like to try friends by going out for lunch. We go, and it's great, we talk like we used to. She says that 'it's so great that you want to be just friends', I reply 'well, that's not really true, and you know it', but we'll leave it at that. We muck around, and she ends up kissing me. I say I'm confused, so does she, and we both kinda suggest that we are just friends, and if stuff like this happens, then it happens, but that we shouldn't be angry at each other for it, she admits she's still attracted to me, but couldn't see herself getting back with me due to the hurt of the break up.

So after that, we still talk on the phone quite a bit, but as of yet, haven't seen each other yet. Was meant to see her at the weekend, but she cancelled saying she had to much exam revision (which is true as I know she has). I suggested taking her for a drink near to hers for an hour or so this week. She rang me and said that she couldn't, as really had to get revising and had already had one day off this weekend, she said she'd see me on Friday. I said that's fine, even though I was a bit disappointed.

This whole thing is driving me mad though! In some ways, I'm wondering whether it's best if I don't have anything more to do with her! I think she's seeing someone else at the moment, which is fair enough, but she's not saying anything! In these situations, is it best to cut off all contact, or be friends whenever she wants to? I just want a solution to all this confusion. I don't think she knows what she wants, and I'm stuck!

Any suggestions?


Ok, so her excuse for breaking up was crap. She's currently unsure if she wants to go out with you or not. Possibly just giving being single a trial.

Stop sucking up to her so much. She tells you off for "abusing the situation"? What the **** is that? I would've had a go at her for trying to pull that **** on me, not say sorry about it.

"Oh, I want to have a relationship, but I'll sit here like your dog and pretend to be friends for you". She's got it all as she wants there, why is she going to let it change? She can decide when she wants to date you and when she wants to just be friends. If she doesn't want to date you outright, stop clinging on and find someone else. Ditch her.

Or at least stop phoning, texting and meeting her until she makes her mind up. Get on with your own life.
Reply 11
Just leave it and see what happens :biggrin:
Reply 12
Thanks to all for the advice!
Being friends after a good relationship takes discipline. If you don't both know what you want, and don't resist temptation, it can ruin your friendship.

Back off, give her space and let her get on with her life. But don't let it seem like you have just disappeared. She may take it as you saying you don't care, which could 'force her hand' one way or the other. Just call her, tell her that you want her to be happy, and that you are giving her some space so that she can find out what she wants from you.
Reply 14
Sounds to me as she's playing mind games with you....
Reply 15
Schmokie Dragon
Being friends after a good relationship takes discipline. If you don't both know what you want, and don't resist temptation, it can ruin your friendship.

Back off, give her space and let her get on with her life. But don't let it seem like you have just disappeared. She may take it as you saying you don't care, which could 'force her hand' one way or the other. Just call her, tell her that you want her to be happy, and that you are giving her some space so that she can find out what she wants from you.


Both your advice and YODA's has been great, so thank you! :biggrin: You're all right, I just couldn't see it! :biggrin: :redface:
Reply 16
My advice is to just have nothing to do with her - how could you be in such a relationship with someone doing so many mind games :confused:
Reply 17
I think you both need to take a bit of a break to decide what you really want. It is not fair on either of you to be getting mixed signals. Sometimes, as hard as it is, it is just not possible to stay friends with the ex.
Good luck
Reply 18
Schmokie Dragon
Being friends after a good relationship takes discipline. If you don't both know what you want, and don't resist temptation, it can ruin your friendship.

Back off, give her space and let her get on with her life. But don't let it seem like you have just disappeared. She may take it as you saying you don't care, which could 'force her hand' one way or the other. Just call her, tell her that you want her to be happy, and that you are giving her some space so that she can find out what she wants from you.


She rang me out of the blue to talk. I said that I did just want her to be happy, and that I think she needs space apart from me at the moment to know what she wants. She said OK.

Right thing to do?
Reply 19
I think so, at least you gave her time to realise what she wants! Hope it all works out! :wink: