The Student Room Group
Reply 1
I don't get it. That looks Cartesian to me, provided that the Sex function is well-defined. :rolleyes:
Reply 2
James Gurung
I don't get it. That looks Cartesian to me, provided that the Sex function is well-defined. :rolleyes:
Well, it's usually 1-1 and onto, at any rate...
Reply 3
DFranklin
Well, it's usually 1-1 and onto, at any rate...

Lol! I haven't heard that one before. :biggrin:
Reply 4
ooops i meant cartesian to intrinsic and yea there are limits... its pi over 3 and pi over 2
Reply 5
I haven't done this for ages, but here's my attempt...

If y=ln(secx)y=\ln(\sec x) then dydx=tan(x)\frac{\mathrm{d}y}{\mathrm{d}x}=\tan(x).

But in intrinsic coordinates, we have dydx=tan(ψ)\frac{\mathrm{d}y}{\mathrm{d}x}=\tan(\psi)

Therefore I guess you can put x=ψx=\psi.

Now dxds=cos(ψ)=cos(x)\frac{\mathrm{d}x}{\mathrm{d}s}=\cos(\psi)=\cos(x)

so dsdx=sec(x)\frac{\mathrm{d}s}{\mathrm{d}x}=\sec(x).

Thus s=ln(sec(ψ)+tan(ψ))s=\ln(\sec(\psi)+\tan(\psi)).


That's probably wrong. My method seems a bit dodgy. Tbh I need to revise this stuff.
Reply 6
You're forgetting the C.

I did this with the definition of S=1+(dydx)2 S = \sqrt{1+\left(\frac{dy}{dx}\right)^2}

Got a different answer hmm.

Why are there limits? Surely if you're being asked to convert cartesian into intrinsic, limits wouldnt come into play with this?
Reply 7
Yeah you're right. I really can't remember any of this stuff.
Reply 8
would you say dy/dx is tan(w) and if so isnt it always tan(w)?? because by defintion dy/dx = tan(w) this is the bit that confuses me.
Reply 9
Yes but because d/dx(ln secx) = tanx

dy/dx = tan x

dy/dx = tan w

therefore w= x
so if it was a different equiation would dy/dx not = w
dy/dx doesnt equal w it equals tan w and it is infact tan x as well.

dy/dx = tanx - because the function when differentiated is tanx

dy/dx = tanw - As you know by definition of an intrinsic equation

So in this special case x = w

If it was a different function then this would not be the case. You'd then have to find a relationship between x = w.