Which uni?

I'm confused on what do to - I have received offers from my choices but have discounted two. York is the best academically, but I didn't like it as much, so my choices are Nottingham and Birmingham. I have an unconditional for Birmingham, but liked Nottingham about equally. Has anyone any ideas? thank-you!

Have you compared everything about the two? Not just course, but campus, facilities and locations?

Yes, I'm still confused! I will review after offer holder days, I think.