x Turn on thread page Beta
 You are Here: Home >< Maths

# Confidence interval help needed watch

1. Let θ denote the true ability of a student in a certain subject, representing the probability of astudent answering correctly an arbitrary question and let X1, . . . , Xn be the marks to n questions the student answered, taking values either 0 or 1. We model them as n i.i.d. Bernoulli(θ) randomvariables. Then, we approximate a student’s ability by its ML estimate.

a) We can approximate the distribution of

(θ(X) - θ) / ((θ(X)(1−θ(X)))/n)0.5

(Where θ(X) is the Maximum likelihood estimate)

by a standard gaussian N(0,1) distribution, under distribution P0. Using this result, construct the 95 percent confidence interval for θ.

b) How big should n be so that we can estimate the true ability within 0.01 marks, with probabilityat least 95%? Justify your answer.

I have no idea where to start here. Why are we approximating that scary looking distribution in the first place, and what does it mean by 'under distribution P0 ? How do we start to construct an interval?
2. (Original post by pineapplechemist)
Let θ denote the true ability of a student in a certain subject, representing the probability of astudent answering correctly an arbitrary question and let X1, . . . , Xn be the marks to n questions the student answered, taking values either 0 or 1. We model them as n i.i.d. Bernoulli(θ) randomvariables. Then, we approximate a student’s ability by its ML estimate.

a) We can approximate the distribution of

(θ(X) - θ) / ((θ(X)(1−θ(X)))/n)0.5

(Where θ(X) is the Maximum likelihood estimate)

by a standard gaussian N(0,1) distribution, under distribution P0. Using this result, construct the 95 percent confidence interval for θ.

b) How big should n be so that we can estimate the true ability within 0.01 marks, with probabilityat least 95%? Justify your answer.

I have no idea where to start here. Why are we approximating that scary looking distribution in the first place, and what does it mean by 'under distribution P0 ? How do we start to construct an interval?
What it is saying here is that, if is the maximum likelihood estimator of , then

is approximately distributed as a standard normal variable. I've changed your notation of to the more common . The point here is that is your estimate of and

is an estimate of it's standard error. You can now use these facts to construct the 95% confidence interval in the usual way, that is plus or minus 1.96 times that standard error.

The terminology "under distribution P0" is odd, and appears to be superfluous.
3. (Original post by Gregorius)
What it is saying here is that, if is the maximum likelihood estimator of , then

is approximately distributed as a standard normal variable. I've changed your notation of to the more common . The point here is that is your estimate of and

is an estimate of it's standard error. You can now use these facts to construct the 95% confidence interval in the usual way, that is plus or minus 1.96 times that standard error.

The terminology "under distribution P0" is odd, and appears to be superfluous.
Ah thank you, it's much more familiar now! I didn't realise that it was the standard error :P
4. (Original post by Gregorius)
What it is saying here is that, if is the maximum likelihood estimator of , then

is approximately distributed as a standard normal variable. I've changed your notation of to the more common . The point here is that is your estimate of and

is an estimate of it's standard error. You can now use these facts to construct the 95% confidence interval in the usual way, that is plus or minus 1.96 times that standard error.

The terminology "under distribution P0" is odd, and appears to be superfluous.
So, is my interval the estimator +/- 1.96 ? (Sorry for large text, I copied and pasted). Do I need to do anything else?
5. (Original post by pineapplechemist)
So, is my interval the estimator +/- 1.96 ? (Sorry for large text, I copied and pasted). Do I need to do anything else?
That's it.
6. (Original post by Gregorius)
That's it.
Thanks. They didn't actually teach us how to do it. For the second part of the question, is it similar? Do I need to rearrange the interval for n?
7. (Original post by pineapplechemist)
Thanks. They didn't actually teach us how to do it. For the second part of the question, is it similar? Do I need to rearrange the interval for n?
Yes, you have to choose n so that the confidence interval has width 0.01.
8. (Original post by Gregorius)
Yes, you have to choose n so that the confidence interval has width 0.01.
My methods therefore is upper interval - lower interval <= 0.01. I rearranged for n and got 153664(theta)(1-theta)<= n. It doesn't seem right to have it in terms of my estimator, is it ok?
9. (Original post by pineapplechemist)
My methods therefore is upper interval - lower interval <= 0.01. I rearranged for n and got 153664(theta)(1-theta)<= n. It doesn't seem right to have it in terms of my estimator, is it ok?
If you are not actually given any information that allows you to calculate an actual value of then you need to think about what the "worst" value of could be, from the point of view of the width of the confidence interval. As a hint, consider the graph of the function f(x)=x(1-x).
10. (Original post by Gregorius)
If you are not actually given any information that allows you to calculate an actual value of then you need to think about what the "worst" value of could be, from the point of view of the width of the confidence interval. As a hint, consider the graph of the function f(x)=x(1-x).
Ah ok, so we take the estimator to equal 0.5 right, which maximises that function? This would make the confidence interval the widest it could be. Therefore if we get that interval within 0.01 of the true value then all other intervals at least within 0.01 of the true value. Am I thinking along the correct lines here?

Thanks for your help by the way, really appreciate it. Finding this module very hard!

edit: So I get n needs to be at least 38416. Seems huge!

TSR Support Team

We have a brilliant team of more than 60 Support Team members looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.

This forum is supported by:
Updated: February 18, 2016
Today on TSR

### Negatives of studying at Oxbridge

What are the downsides?

Poll
Useful resources

### Maths Forum posting guidelines

Not sure where to post? Read the updated guidelines here

### How to use LaTex

Writing equations the easy way

### Study habits of A* students

Top tips from students who have already aced their exams