The Student Room Group

Failure.

Hello.

Everyone knows that Medical School is tough, and indeed, it may be one of the hardest things, academically, you'll ever have to encounter.
Is this a just reputation?

Saying that, how many people fail?
Do people get thrown out of medical school, if yes, why?
What is the drop out rate like, and what are the reasons for dropping out?

Experiences & thoughts would be helpful

:smile:

Scroll to see replies

Reply 1

I'm only an ickle firstie so probably am not the best person to comment, but so far I've found that some of it is tough conceptually, but it's mainly difficult in terms of sheer volume. At Cambridge, you get chucked out for failing Tripos, but if you fail 2nd MB you can resit once, and if you fail resits you're out. I think a couple of people a year fail Tripos, a number fail 2nd MB but pass second time around, and a few fail 2nd MB on both occassions. I've heard of a couple of people dropping out so far, mainly because they've either realised that medicine isn't for them, or they don't like the university or are having personal problems. I'm not sure how drop-out rates for medicine compare to other subjects though, but in general the drop-out rate here isn't too high.

Reply 2

Classic, Theodore.
Everyone knows that Medical School is tough, and indeed, it may be one of the hardest things, academically, you'll ever have to encounter.
Is this a just reputation?

1. Saying that, how many people fail?
2. Do people get thrown out of medical school, if yes, why?
3. What is the drop out rate like, and what are the reasons for dropping out?
Hahahahaha. 'Everyone' is wrong. It's well acknoledged by those who wish to that it's not academically hard at all. Challenging in other ways? Maybe, but that's a different debate.

1. No more than a handful each year. Generally those that don't want to pass.
2. Yes. Ultimately, they get thrown out cos they don't want to stay. Here, unless you're spectacularly stupid, you can fail one year, fail the resits for that year, resit and fail the year again, resit and fail the resits again before you're thrown out.
3. Drop out rate is variable. There are three classic drop out points; the first term when people discover that uni life is not for them, the third year when people discover that clinical medicine is not for them and after finals when people decided that they'd rather be actors or in a band than doctors. However, there's some discussion as to whether this is changing, particularly as the demographics change.

Reply 3

Renal
It's well acknowledged by those who wish to that it's not academically hard at all. Challenging in other ways? Maybe, but that's a different debate.


Well, what is the challenge of medical school if it isn't the academic side?

Reply 4

Classic, Theodore.
Well, what is the challenge of medical school if it isn't the academic side?
and you say you have an offer? OMG.

Practically half of my year failed my recent in course assessment. But I doubt anything will happen about it. (by fail, I mean they got less than 50% right)

TBH it's easier than A Levels so far. And I just got an email saying that that most recent ICA was the hardest module in the degree and i found it fine... and no i don't have 10A*...

Reply 5

Saffie
and you say you have an offer? OMG.


What do you mean... ?

Reply 6

Classic, Theodore.
What do you mean... ?
I mean...

how the hell have you got an offer for medicine when you cannot see anything else challenging about medical school apart from the academic side.

to be blunt.

Reply 7

To be honest, I really can't.
Academic side = exams, revision, long hours of hard work.
What else is there to medical school bar clinical training?
It isn't as though you'll be tested on your ability to sail a boat :s-smilie:

Reply 8

emotionally...

in a 'watching patients hurt/die/lives being torn apart/empathy' way...

or just, people dying from your med school, in my case :frown:

Reply 9

Saffie
or just, people dying from your med school, in my case :frown:
Happens everywhere unfortunately. :frown:

But you're precisely right Saffie, the emotional toll of medical school is huge, far higher than in most other degrees (I can't think of any bar nursing that come close). The emotional toll of the job is even harder.

Oh, and the hours are pretty ****ty too - I found A levels a challenge but my sixth form never wanted my in '7 til 8'.

p.s. Saf, be blunt more often love, suits you. :wink:

Reply 10

Saffie
emotionally...
in a 'watching patients hurt/die/lives being torn apart/empathy' way...
or just, people dying from your med school, in my case :frown:


Oh yes, well that might be difficult.
I'd forgotten about that.

Do you think that would cause people to drop out?

Reply 11

Classic, Theodore.
Do you think that would cause people to drop out?
Probably.

EDIT: Actually, definately, I've known of plenty of doctors who just couldn't hack telling person after person that they were going to die.

Reply 12

Classic, Theodore.
Do you think that would cause people to drop out?
pleeeeease stop asking stupid questions......

And of course i'm right Renal, I'm always right :biggrin:

Reply 13

Saffie
pleeeeease stop asking stupid questions...


It's not a stupid question.
And you don't have to answer it.

Reply 14

Classic, Theodore.
It's not a stupid question.
And you don't have to answer it.
of course it's a stupid question, but no, you dont consider the emotional aspects of medicine, do you.

Reply 15

Classic, Theodore.
Well, what is the challenge of medical school if it isn't the academic side?


It's pretty shocking/strange that you've not thought about this before applying to study medicine:s-smilie: Were you not asked any questions along these lines at interviews?

Reply 16

Ignoring the bickering...

Saying that, how many people fail? Variable. For our 2nd MB exams, most of the 1st year ones have a 10%ish failure rate but you have one resit, which most people pass. In 2nd year the failure rates for some subjects are closer to 30-40%, and some people don't pass the resit. But you'd have to try really hard to fail both times, given that resits are after the summer holidays so you have effectively 3 months extra revision time. I only know a couple of people who've actually left Cambridge - most have transferred onto other courses (usually NatSci)
Do people get thrown out of medical school, if yes, why? Very rarely - you'd have to commit some serious disciplinary infringement, or just not do any work at all/not show up for anything.
What is the drop out rate like, and what are the reasons for dropping out? As has already been described, but it's especially low for Cambridge because they're quite obsessive about keeping you here. A fair few transfer out to other subjects, but I can only think of 2 who have totally left.

Reply 17

Johnny C.
It's pretty shocking/strange that you've not thought about this before applying to study medicine:s-smilie: Were you not asked any questions along these lines at interviews?


Yes, I've thought of it before.
For whatever reason, I don't consider it a major issue for me, personally.

Reply 18

Helenia
Ignoring the bickering...

Saying that, how many people fail? Variable. For our 2nd MB exams, most of the 1st year ones have a 10%ish failure rate but you have one resit, which most people pass. In 2nd year the failure rates for some subjects are closer to 30-40%, and some people don't pass the resit. But you'd have to try really hard to fail both times, given that resits are after the summer holidays so you have effectively 3 months extra revision time. I only know a couple of people who've actually left Cambridge - most have transferred onto other courses (usually NatSci)
Do people get thrown out of medical school, if yes, why? Very rarely - you'd have to commit some serious disciplinary infringement, or just not do any work at all/not show up for anything.
What is the drop out rate like, and what are the reasons for dropping out? As has already been described, but it's especially low for Cambridge because they're quite obsessive about keeping you here. A fair few transfer out to other subjects, but I can only think of 2 who have totally left.


Thanks for the thoughts :smile:

Reply 19

Classic, Theodore.
Yes, I've thought of it before.
For whatever reason, I don't consider it a major issue for me, personally.

I hate to sound like a patronising know-it-all, but believe me, you will find things which you struggle with, whether academically or emotionally. That's not to say you'll fail as a result, but to expect everything to go marvellously and that you'll mop fevered brows, share intimate empathic moments, hang around for hours doing nothing in particular without at some point having a tough time with it, is very naive.