A question asks: in a group of 60 girls and 40 boys, it is found that the probability of a person being left handed is 0.18. The probability of a girl being left handed is 0.1. What is the probability of a boy being right handed?
I got this wrong and in the solution I'm not seeing what exactly the difference of being a girl and left handed P(AuB) = 0.1 and being left handed given one is a girl P(AB)*
Could somebody please explain the difference?
*P(AuB) = P(A) * P(AB)
therefore, P(AB) = 0.1 / 0.6 = 1/6.
I can't intuit what exactly is being said here, when looking at u vs 
x
Turn on thread page Beta

Mathstatician
 Follow
 0 followers
 2 badges
 Send a private message to Mathstatician
 Thread Starter
Offline2ReputationRep: Follow
 1
 22032016 19:45
Last edited by Mathstatician; 22032016 at 19:48. 
Mathstatician
 Follow
 0 followers
 2 badges
 Send a private message to Mathstatician
 Thread Starter
Offline2ReputationRep: Follow
 2
 22032016 20:05
I think I just worked it out.
A girl who is left handed is different to the probability of being left handed given she’s a girl.
P(AB) is dependant on the probability of being a girl first (.6) while P(AuB) assumes she is a girl (so is probability of being left instead of right handed in subgroup Girls)
Is this correct?Last edited by Mathstatician; 22032016 at 20:06. 
 Follow
 3
 22032016 20:15
Do you need to calculate it this way? Intuitively there are 18 lefthanded people in the group, 6 of which are girls. This means that there are 12 lefthanded boys, which means there are 28 righthanded boys. 28 / 40 = 7 / 10 = 70% chance of a boy being righthanded.

Mathstatician
 Follow
 0 followers
 2 badges
 Send a private message to Mathstatician
 Thread Starter
Offline2ReputationRep: Follow
 4
 22032016 20:37
(Original post by eniet)
Do you need to calculate it this way? Intuitively there are 18 lefthanded people in the group, 6 of which are girls. This means that there are 12 lefthanded boys, which means there are 28 righthanded boys. 28 / 40 = 7 / 10 = 70% chance of a boy being righthanded. 
 Follow
 5
 22032016 20:53
(Original post by Mathstatician)
A question asks: in a group of 60 girls and 40 boys, it is found that the probability of a person being left handed is 0.18. The probability of a girl being left handed is 0.1. What is the probability of a boy being right handed?
I got this wrong and in the solution I'm not seeing what exactly the difference of being a girl and left handed P(AuB) = 0.1 and being left handed given one is a girl P(AB)*
Could somebody please explain the difference?
*P(AuB) = P(A) * P(AB)
therefore, P(AB) = 0.1 / 0.6 = 1/6.
I can't intuit what exactly is being said here, when looking at u vs 
is the probability of occurring given that has occurred.
You seem to be confusing for . The latter means "and", and
For example, if you roll two dice, with being the event that you roll a and being the event you roll a then but .
Finally .Last edited by joostan; 22032016 at 20:55. 
Mathstatician
 Follow
 0 followers
 2 badges
 Send a private message to Mathstatician
 Thread Starter
Offline2ReputationRep: Follow
 6
 22032016 22:31
(Original post by joostan)
is the probability of either or occuring.
is the probability of occurring given that has occurred.
You seem to be confusing for . The latter means "and", and
For example, if you roll two dice, with being the event that you roll a and being the event you roll a then but .
Finally .
I think I realise now that in the question asked P(AnB) is P(Girl) * P(LeftGirl) which is different to P(BA) or P(LeftGirl) in that the former is the probability of both events happening while the latter is saying if A happens then the probability of B happening is (x). Is that right? 
 Follow
 7
 22032016 23:18
(Original post by Mathstatician)
I've not used latex before and I apologise for not using it in my post. This answer was very useful thank you.
I think I realise now that in the question asked P(AnB) is P(Girl) * P(LeftGirl) which is different to P(BA) or P(LeftGirl) in that the former is the probability of both events happening while the latter is saying if A happens then the probability of B happening is (x). Is that right?
Furthermore I would like to comment that my previous post is merely meant to explain notation and the method suggested by eniet is the way I'd go about it  the answer you've given/been given, of must surely be incorrect.Last edited by joostan; 22032016 at 23:20. 
Mathstatician
 Follow
 0 followers
 2 badges
 Send a private message to Mathstatician
 Thread Starter
Offline2ReputationRep: Follow
 8
 22032016 23:33
in a group of 60 girls and 40 boys, it is found that the probability of a person being left handed is 0.18. The probability of a girl being left handed is 0.1. What is the probability of a boy being right handed?
P(G) = 0.6
P(B) = 0.4
P(L) = 0.18
P(GnL) = 0.1

Solving for the girls:
P(GnL) = P(G) * P(GL)
Therefore, P(GL) = 0.1 / 0.6 = 1/6
And P(GR) = 5/6

Solving for the boys:
P(L) = P(GnL) + P(BnL)
Therefore, P(L) = P(GnL) + P(B) + P(BL)
So 0.18 = 0.1 + 0.4 + P(BL)
0.08/0.4 = 1/5 = P(BL)
And P(BR) = 4/5

Finally solving for what the question asks for:
P(BnR) = P(B) * P(BR)
P(BnR) = 0.4 * 4/5
P(BnR) = 8/25
Is this incorrect?Last edited by Mathstatician; 22032016 at 23:40. 
 Follow
 9
 22032016 23:45
(Original post by Mathstatician)
Are you sure? Here's how I figure it is correct, given my current understanding:
Given:
P(G) = 0.6
P(B) = 0.4
P(L) = 0.18
P(GnL) = 0.1

Solving for the girls:
P(GnL) = P(G) * P(GL)
Therefore, P(GL) = 0.1 / 0.6 = 1/6
And P(GR) = 5/6

Solving for the boys:
P(L) = P(GnL) + P(BnL)
Therefore, P(L) = P(GnL) + P(B) + P(BL)
So 0.18 = 0.1 + 0.4 + P(BL)
0.08/0.4 = 1/5 = P(BL)
And P(BR) = 4/5

Finally solving for what the question asks for:
P(BnR) = P(B) * P(BR)
P(BnR) = 0.4 * 4/5
P(BnR) = 8/25
Is this incorrect?
I've actually got to get up early tomorrow, so I've gotta scoot, try and get Zacken or someone to help you. 
Mathstatician
 Follow
 0 followers
 2 badges
 Send a private message to Mathstatician
 Thread Starter
Offline2ReputationRep: Follow
 10
 22032016 23:48
(Original post by joostan)
I've not looked thoroughly at this, but you seem to have muddled some pluses and multiplications, moreover, how did you get and .
I've actually got to get up early tomorrow, so I've gotta scoot, try and get Zacken or someone to help you.
I'm only a GCSE student. Maybe I have completely misunderstood. I appreciate your help thus far. Will wait on somebody else. Thank you. 
Gregorius
 Follow
 20 followers
 13 badges
 Send a private message to Gregorius
Offline13ReputationRep: Follow
 11
 23032016 07:43
(Original post by Mathstatician)
Are you sure? Here's how I figure it is correct, given my current understanding:
Given:
P(G) = 0.6
P(B) = 0.4
P(L) = 0.18
P(GnL) = 0.1
The solution joostan gave is correct. 
ByronicHero
 Follow
 182 followers
 20 badges
 Send a private message to ByronicHero
 PS Reviewer
Offline20ReputationRep:PS Reviewer Follow
 12
 23032016 10:58
You can also see it covered by Exam Solutions: http://www.examsolutions.net/mathsr...examples1.php

Mathstatician
 Follow
 0 followers
 2 badges
 Send a private message to Mathstatician
 Thread Starter
Offline2ReputationRep: Follow
 13
 23032016 13:43
(Original post by Gregorius)
The problems set in at the bolded step. The question states that "the probability of a girl being left handed is 0.1". In other words, if you choose a girl from the group of 100 students, the probability of her being left handed is 0.1. This is precisely P(Left handed  individual is a girl) (= P(L  G) ) and not P(individual is left handed and individual is a girl) (= <a rel="nofollow" rel="nofollow" href="javascript:void(0)"><img src="http://www.thestudentroom.co.uk/latexrender/pictures/50/50e7c1e074549840fb77d3a36abd0d6b .png" width="79" height="21" style="border: 0px; margin: 0px; padding: 0px; verticalalign: 5px;" alt="P(L \cap G)" title="P(L \cap G)" onclick="newWindow=window.open(' http://www.thestudentroom.co.uk/latexrender/latexcode.php?code=P%28L+%5Ccap+ G%29','latexCode','toolbar=no,lo cation=no,scrollbars=yes,resizab le=yes,status=no,width=460,heigh t=320,left=200,top=100';" /></a>.The solution @joostan gave is correct.(Original post by ByronicHero)
You can also see it covered by Exam Solutions: http://www.examsolutions.net/mathsr...examples1.phpLast edited by Mathstatician; 23032016 at 13:48. 
 Follow
 14
 23032016 14:07
(Original post by Mathstatician)
He (the guy in exam solutions) gets the same answer as me. Are we both wrong? 
Mathstatician
 Follow
 0 followers
 2 badges
 Send a private message to Mathstatician
 Thread Starter
Offline2ReputationRep: Follow
 15
 23032016 14:20
(Original post by joostan)
Having had a look at the video, I think the issue is that the question is very poorly worded, and as Gregorius said, by the probability of a girl being left handed he has taken that to mean the probability that a girl is selected from the group and that said girl is left handed to be 0.1, rather than the more sensible inference in my opinion that this is the probability of being left handed, given you are a girl.
Thanks a lot everybody for your input. I think we should consider the matter resolved under: Poor Question.
Reply
Submit reply
Turn on thread page Beta
TSR Support Team
We have a brilliant team of more than 60 Support Team members looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.
This forum is supported by:
 SherlockHolmes
 Notnek
 charco
 Mr M
 TSR Moderator
 Nirgilis
 usycool1
 Changing Skies
 James A
 rayquaza17
 RDKGames
 randdom
 davros
 Gingerbread101
 Kvothe the Arcane
 TeeEff
 The Empire Odyssey
 Protostar
 TheConfusedMedic
 nisha.sri
 Reality Check
 claireestelle
 Doonesbury
 furryface12
 Amefish
 harryleavey
 Lemur14
 brainzistheword
 Rexar
 Sonechka
 LeCroissant
 EstelOfTheEyrie
 CoffeeAndPolitics
 an_atheist
 Moltenmo
 Labrador99
 EmilySarah00
Updated: March 23, 2016
Share this discussion:
Tweet