The Student Room Group

The real victims of the attacks are Islam and the Muslim community

Now my thoughts are with those who died and their families but the long term impacts will be felt elsewhere.

People will attack Islam and make out it promotes killing, mass genocide, intolerance, and everything bad.

People will claim Muslims are responsible when that is the opposite. These terrorists are by convention not Muslim and it is technically impossible for a Muslim to kill anyone as they are effectively not Muslim. Racists and xenophobes can't see this though. They are frauds calling themselves Muslim.

When will people start addressing the adverse effect these attacks will have on Islam and the Muslim community?
(edited 8 years ago)

Scroll to see replies

dozens of civilians die and OP thinks muslims are the victims


gg
Original post by Shia Kafir
dozens of civilians die and OP thinks muslims are the victims


gg


I said my thoughts are with them and their families :/
Well a Muslim is this but a real Muslim is that. A victim is this but a real victim is that
"My thoughts are with them and their families."

"Muslims are the primary victims."

Pick one OP. You're like a child unable to pick one toy over another.
Original post by kieran12321LFC
Well a Muslim is this but a real Muslim is that. A victim is this but a real victim is that


What are you going on about? A real Muslim is not this (this being the actions of these people). They have nothing to do with Islam or Muslims. I challenge you to even try to make a connection
Original post by Arsenal96123
What are you going on about? A real Muslim is not this (this being the actions of these people). They have nothing to do with Islam or Muslims. I challenge you to even try to make a connection


You may want to Google 'No True Scotsman'
Original post by NotAPedoReturns
"My thoughts are with them and their families."

"Muslims are the primary victims."

Pick one OP. You're like a child unable to pick one toy over another.


But my thoughts are with them, but in the long term the real (and intended) victims are Muslim (and therefore Islam). Pinning violence on Islam over this is a childish claim and stupid but will be echoed across the world
Original post by Arsenal96123
What are you going on about? A real Muslim is not this (this being the actions of these people). They have nothing to do with Islam or Muslims. I challenge you to even try to make a connection


What's the difference between a Muslim and a real Muslim
Don't understand why people think that the case of both parties being victims is incompatible.

There are direct and indirect victims as a result of this situation.
Original post by Arsenal96123
in the long term the real (and intended) victims are Muslim (and therefore Islam).

please explain the bit in bold.


islam is a vile ideology that has to be challenged at every opportunity and ultimately defeated, just like nazism.
Original post by Arsenal96123
it is technically impossible for a Muslim to kill anyone as they are effectively not Muslim.


Was Mohammed not a Muslim?
Original post by kieran12321LFC
What's the difference between a Muslim and a real Muslim


There is only a real Muslim and these men don't constitute as Muslim. It's funny how you try to pin this on Muslims, but in another way it is racist and not. The likes of Trump, UKIP, the French national front ect. are more to blame considering their racism and xenophobia is pushing people to do this
Original post by Arsenal96123
Now my thoughts are with those who died and their families but the long term impacts will be felt elsewhere.
When will people start addressing the adverse effect these attacks will have on Islam and the Muslim community?


What a disgusting interpretation you hold. The real, primary victims are those that lost their lives and the family members of the deceased. How dare you say that those uninjured, or those without having lost their brothers, sisters or mothers, are the primary victims?

The long term impacts will be felt with the son or daughter that grows up without their mother, with the father that attends his daughters funeral, with the brother that will never see his sister again, with the widow that fights back tears everyday remembering how their partner's life was ripped from them by a group of despicable, inhuman beings.

No. Muslims are NOT the real victims of the attacks. How dare you even state that daft, daft idea.

The Islamic community may suffer, but they are not the primary victims, you utter idiot.
Reply 14
The real victims are the victims and their families. Such a stupid phrase.
Original post by Arsenal96123
There is only a real Muslim and these men don't constitute as Muslim. It's funny how you try to pin this on Muslims, but in another way it is racist and not. The likes of Trump, UKIP, the French national front ect. are more to blame considering their racism and xenophobia is pushing people to do this


I doubt that ISIS thought to themselves one day "UKIP got a couple of million votes in the British General Election, we can't be having that now can we"
2/10.
Original post by Arsenal96123
There is only a real Muslim and these men don't constitute as Muslim. It's funny how you try to pin this on Muslims, but in another way it is racist and not. The likes of Trump, UKIP, the French national front ect. are more to blame considering their racism and xenophobia is pushing people to do this

there is too much nonsense in this for me to deal with at this time :sigh:
Reply 18
The real victims are the idiots above for being so gullible and believing a troll
Original post by celloel
What a disgusting interpretation you hold. The real, primary victims are those that lost their lives and the family members of the deceased. How dare you say that those uninjured, or those without having lost their brothers, sisters or mothers, are the primary victims?

The long term impacts will be felt with the son or daughter that grows up without their mother, with the father that attends his daughters funeral, with the brother that will never see his sister again, with the widow that fights back tears everyday remembering how their partner's life was ripped from them by a group of despicable, inhuman beings.

No. Muslims are NOT the real victims of the attacks. How dare you even state that daft, daft idea.

The Islamic community may suffer, but they are not the primary victims, you utter idiot.


It's small minded to only think of short term impacts over long term impacts. My thoughts are with those who died and their families, it's wrong that they died and utterly sad but the point of this attack had deeper motives.

Quick Reply

Latest

Trending

Trending