The Student Room Group

Getting dissertation published - a few questions

Hi,

I am working on getting my dissertation published, and this involves a little bit of rewording of my work.

As I am doing this, I have the following questions:

-My dissertation has a word limit (as does every), and this word limit stopped me from providing as much insight into my project as I would have liked. Is it a bad thing to say in my writeup that the word count stopped me from including x or y in the report?

-Wouldn't it look bad to say there are a lot of things I could not implement or write about? Also, would it look if I said that I could not get 30 or so questionnaire results?

Lastly, would these things jeopardise my marks for my dissertation? Because if it does a lot then it'd be difficult to get my disso published, especially if my work is not worth an A.
Reply 1
If you really want to do this, then you'll have to be prepared to putting a lot of work into editing that which you've already got. In my mind, this might include adding new sections, stuff that you'd otherwise have liked to include, and perhaps returned to data collection in order to increase your sample size.
Reply 2
Wise One
If you really want to do this, then you'll have to be prepared to putting a lot of work into editing that which you've already got. In my mind, this might include adding new sections, stuff that you'd otherwise have liked to include, and perhaps returned to data collection in order to increase your sample size.


Yea exactly. This isn't a problem as I can find the time to do all this no problem. But what worries me now is that doing all these improvements has made me realise that so much has been left out of my original dissertation due to the good ol' word count limit, that I feel my marks for what I submitted would decrease because of this - then again my supervisor didn't actually point out any of the areas of concern which are in my head (for example, small things like I put in questionnaire results but didn't say who I asked - well I did in the rationale section at the beginning, but should have done again).
Reply 3
-Blade-
Yea exactly. This isn't a problem as I can find the time to do all this no problem. But what worries me now is that doing all these improvements has made me realise that so much has been left out of my original dissertation due to the good ol' word count limit, that I feel my marks for what I submitted would decrease because of this - then again my supervisor didn't actually point out any of the areas of concern which are in my head (for example, small things like I put in questionnaire results but didn't say who I asked - well I did in the rationale section at the beginning, but should have done again).


Oh, I see.

Well, don't you lose marks if you go too far over the word limit? Ultimately, it's a trade off, and sometimes you've got know when to stop and prune your work.
Reply 4
Yea you do lose marks if you go over the word limit. You have 10% natural leway both ways but anything over or below that 10% results in some form of penalty.
Reply 5
I never think about publishing essays that I have written for my degree until I've had marks and feedback - as you said, if it's not worth an A or First, it's not publishable anyway (even if it does get a First, it still doesn't mean it should be published unless you get a very high mark). Also, the feedback helps with editing, as an expert's second opinion will save you from any potentially embarrassing errors or weaknesses.

I take it you want to publish your dissertation in a journal? If so, they usually have word limits too, but it probably won't be the same as your university word limit, and so you would have to rewrite it to make it fit their requirements. You cant just say 'well, I would have written more but I would have gone over my limit' - they wouldn't take it seriously.
Reply 6
the_alba
I never think about publishing essays that I have written for my degree until I've had marks and feedback - as you said, if it's not worth an A or First, it's not publishable anyway (even if it does get a First, it still doesn't mean it should be published unless you get a very high mark). Also, the feedback helps with editing, as an expert's second opinion will save you from any potentially embarrassing errors or weaknesses.

I take it you want to publish your dissertation in a journal? If so, they usually have word limits too, but it probably won't be the same as your university word limit, and so you would have to rewrite it to make it fit their requirements. You cant just say 'well, I would have written more but I would have gone over my limit' - they wouldn't take it seriously.


Exactly. My supervisor always mentioned the publishing angle (due in part as I had decent technical knowledge), and said my work was fine etc (didn't say what's its worth as he cant). The only problem he had was I didn't ask like 50 people for questionnaire results, again due to my word limit. So if I get the work published, this will again be something not includeable.
Reply 7
-Blade-
Exactly. My supervisor always mentioned the publishing angle (due in part as I had decent technical knowledge), and said my work was fine etc (didn't say what's its worth as he cant). The only problem he had was I didn't ask like 50 people for questionnaire results, again due to my word limit. So if I get the work published, this will again be something not includeable.


What?

If you want to get this published, rather than whining about all the stuff you *could* have done, surely you should get back out there and get more results?

:confused:
Reply 8
Wise One
What?

If you want to get this published, rather than whining about all the stuff you *could* have done, surely you should get back out there and get more results?

:confused:

Agreed. I doubt you would manage to get it published unless you can collect enough valid data to make a solid paper. The results from my dissertation are 'publishable', but any self-respecting journal would only accept it if I first go back and spend another 3-4 months in the lab to tie-up all the loose ends that I didn't have time to do during uni.
Just graduated with Master in Law in Commercial Law, and I worked 2 years on my dissertation. Looking at PhD next in possibly the subject I covered my dissertation.

How would I go about getting my dissertation published as so Mann different websites with varying degrees of information.

Some help would be appreciated thank you.

Quick Reply