ooo, i found another one i actually attempted...rare for me lol
''Hamlets character is repulsive, based on self-dislike and a spirit of disintegration''
''The audience is encouraged to like Hamlet''
What evidence is there in the play to support both these views?
how do you respond to shakespeares presentation of Hamlet?
Shakespeare presents Hamlet in many different lights, drawing upon his sensibility and judgement of character. Several instances within the play, commited and planned by Hamlet himself suggests he's a character or repulsion and has a spirit of disintegration.
In act 3 scene 1, Hamlet's behaviour towards Ophelia, his alledged lover, depicts a ghastly picture of tribulation and inclemency. His outrageously offensive insults; ''Get thee to a nunnery'' and ''breeder of sinners'' supports this negative view of Hamlet fully. His insults don't stop at Ophelia though, his mother also becomes a victim of his poisionous words and cruel behaviour. His absolute, blunt and unforgiving frame of mind towards his mother supports a character that intends to inflict pain. ''Rank sweat of an enseamed bed, stew'd in corruption'' and ''incestuous sheets'', these insults utilise sibilince, that echo Hamlets anger, and metonomy.
Hamlet can be seen to be a barbaric madman, after all, he slayed an innoncent Polonius showing no remorse or guilt after. He compares the murder with his mothers relationship with the King ''a bloody deed-almost as bad..as kill a king and marry his brother'' which makes the murder more shocking. A repulsive side to Hamlet can be seen further as he passes up the opportunity to kill Claudius in secret ''Now might i do it, now he's praying'', instead opts for a cruel, public damnation of the King. He will stop at nothing to avenge his father's death. And this is reitterated when he murders Rosencrantz and Guildernstern by regretlessly forging a commission for their death. A callous trick by no means fueled by evil.
However a different approach to Hamlet can be seen; the intellectual hero, a likeable trait in Hamlet that shapes his relationship with the audience.
''Sweet Hamlet'' is endowed with a much wider appeal than other shakespearean tragic heroes. Firstly his rather odd humour, coupled with his questioning and direct accusing and his character as a penetrating observer expands his appeal. For example, during a conversation with Polonius Hamlet remarks ''You are a fishmonger'' to which an understandly baffled Polonius answers ''Not I my lord''. This suggests to the audience he is willing to challenge those of authority-a brave and rebellious trait in the Dane.
He manages to capture the audience through his clever planning and scheming, ''i perchance herafter shall think meet to put antic disposition on''. Through the eyes on the audience this isnt necessarily an act of deception but more a heartfelt attempt to consolidate his father's ''foul, and most unnatural murder'' and seek revenge. The audience's sympathy for Hamlet always precipitates a likness for him. These tricks of his illustrates he's as clever as his opponents. ''The plays the thing wherein i'll catch the conscience of the king'' conveys a cunning personality with coyness.
Shakespeare presents Hamlet as a man of justice. Hamlet, in act 3, passes up the opportunity to slay Claudius. His procrastination shows him as doing something right-a stark conrast to the repulsive approach to Hamlet.
I agree with the view that the audience is encouraged to like Hamlet. The eyes of the hero influences our seeing and his point of view will always win the audiences assent. He is portayed with an aptitiude for guile and humour which I like in Hamlet. I believe the audience's faith in Hamlet's judgment always prevails.
i got 15/20 for this. hope it may be of some help