You are Here: Home >< Maths

# S2 January 2015 IAL Q1) and Q7) watch

1. 1) For 1(b), Why isn't it P(X=1)? Also, I understand it is 2 days to the mean is doubled, but couldn't using X~Po(1.6) also include exactly 2 days? So why is this correct for less than 2 days?

2) For 1(c), please could someone explain this step by step?

3) For 7), where does Var(Y)=(4n/25) come from?

Probability is my worst topic and this is really bugging me.

Thanks for any help.
Attached Images

2. (Original post by PhyM23)
1) For 1(b), Why isn't it P(X=1)?
X=1 is the probability that only one car was caught in the first 48 hours. There could be any number >= 1, and it still satisfies the criterion of catching a car within 48 hours.

Also, I understand it is 2 days to the mean is doubled, but couldn't using X~Po(1.6) also include exactly 2 days? So why is this correct for less than 2 days?
The parameter lambda is a continuous function (multiple) of the number of days.
What would lambda be if the distribution was for 2 days minus 1 hour?
Or two days minus 1 minute? Or minus 1 second?, Etc.

Also, although the Poisson is a discrete distribution, it's modelling a continous time period. What's the probability of a car arriving at exactly 2 days? Zero!

Don't feel I've really dealt with that bit properly, but hope it helps.

2) For 1(c), please could someone explain this step by step?
Conditional probabilty.

P(1 caught one day 1 AND 3 caught on day 2 | 4 caught over 2 days.)

The first two parts (red) refer to a single day period - hence lambda = 0.8.
Last past (green) refers to a 2 day period - hence lambda = 1.6.

Then standard conditional probability.

= P(1 caught one day 1 AND 3 caught on day 2 ) / P( 4 caught over 2 days.)

The two days are independent, so

= P(1 caught one day 1) P( 3 caught on day 2 ) / P( 4 caught over 2 days.)

3) For 7), where does Var(Y)=(4n/25) come from?

Probability is my worst topic and this is really bugging me.

Thanks for any help.
The binomial, which you are approximating, has a variance of npq, or np(1-p)
Hence n x (1/5) x (4/5) = 4n/25.
3. (Original post by ghostwalker)
X=1 is the probability that only one car was caught in the first 48 hours. There could be any number >= 1, and it still satisfies the criterion of catching a car within 48 hours.

The parameter lambda is a continuous function (multiple) of the number of days.
What would lambda be if the distribution was for 2 days minus 1 hour?
Or two days minus 1 minute? Or minus 1 second?, Etc.

Also, although the Poisson is a discrete distribution, it's modelling a continous time period. What's the probability of a car arriving at exactly 2 days? Zero!

Don't feel I've really dealt with that bit properly, but hope it helps.

Conditional probabilty.

P(1 caught one day 1 AND 3 caught on day 2 | 4 caught over 2 days.)

The first two parts (red) refer to a single day period - hence lambda = 0.8.
Last past (green) refers to a 2 day period - hence lambda = 1.6.

Then standard conditional probability.

= P(1 caught one day 1 AND 3 caught on day 2 ) / P( 4 caught over 2 days.)

The two days are independent, so

= P(1 caught one day 1) P( 3 caught on day 2 ) / P( 4 caught over 2 days.)

The binomial, which you are approximating, has a variance of npq, or np(1-p)
Hence n x (1/5) x (4/5) = 4n/25.
Thank you very much for such a detailed reply.

1) This makes sense and your explanation of the second part is exactly what I was looking for.

2) This makes more sense, but why isn't P(4 caught over 2 days) in the numerator too?

3) Ah yes I should have spotted that
4. (Original post by PhyM23)
2) This makes more sense, but why isn't P(4 caught over 2 days) in the numerator too?
Look up conditional probability in the S1 section of your formula booklet:

5. (Original post by Zacken)
Look up conditional probability in the S1 section of your formula booklet:

That's what's confusing me.

Let P(1 caught on day 1) = P(A)
P(3 caught on day 2) = P(B)
P(4 caught over 2 days) = P(C)

P(A and B|C) = P(A and B and C) / P(C)

Why isn't it this?
6. (Original post by PhyM23)
That's what's confusing me.

Let P(1 caught on day 1) = P(A)
P(3 caught on day 2) = P(B)
P(4 caught over 2 days) = P(C)

P(A and B|C) = P(A and B and C) / P(C)

Why isn't it this?
Ah, I see what you mean.

It's just that A and B and C is (1 caught on day 1 and 3 caught on day 2 and 4 caught over 2 days).

But (1 caught on day 1 and 3 caught on day 2) is already (4 caught over 2 days). So .

Kind of like

Edit: see below, ghostwalker explained it better.
7. (Original post by PhyM23)
That's what's confusing me.

Let P(1 caught on day 1) = P(A)
P(3 caught on day 2) = P(B)
P(4 caught over 2 days) = P(C)

P(A and B|C) = P(A and B and C) / P(C)

Why isn't it this?
You're quite right. I missed a step out.

P(A and B|C) = P(A and B and C) / P(C)

The event "A and B" (i.e. 1 on day 1, and 3 on day 2), implies 4 over 2 days, i.e. C.

So, the event "A and B" is a subset of event "C".

Hence P(A and B and C) = P(A and B).

Edit: ninja'd
8. (Original post by Zacken)
Ah, I see what you mean.

It's just that A and B and C is (1 caught on day 1 and 3 caught on day 2 and 4 caught over 2 days).

But (1 caught on day 1 and 3 caught on day 2) is already (4 caught over 2 days). So .

Kind of like

Edit: see below, ghostwalker explained it better.
(Original post by ghostwalker)
You're quite right. I missed a step out.

P(A and B|C) = P(A and B and C) / P(C)

The event "A and B" (i.e. 1 on day 1, and 3 on day 2), implies 4 over 2 days, i.e. C.

So, the event "A and B" is a subset of event "C".

Hence P(A and B and C) = P(A and B).

Edit: ninja'd
Haha

This is exactly what I was looking for; thank you both for your help

TSR Support Team

We have a brilliant team of more than 60 Support Team members looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.

This forum is supported by:
Updated: May 21, 2016
Today on TSR

### Three reasons you may feel demotivated right now

...and how to stay positive

### Can I get A*s if I start revising now?

Discussions on TSR

• Latest
Poll
Useful resources

### Maths Forum posting guidelines

Not sure where to post? Read the updated guidelines here

### How to use LaTex

Writing equations the easy way

### Study habits of A* students

Top tips from students who have already aced their exams

## Groups associated with this forum:

View associated groups
Discussions on TSR

• Latest

The Student Room, Get Revising and Marked by Teachers are trading names of The Student Room Group Ltd.

Register Number: 04666380 (England and Wales), VAT No. 806 8067 22 Registered Office: International House, Queens Road, Brighton, BN1 3XE