x Turn on thread page Beta
 You are Here: Home >< Physics

# geometric similarity watch

1. in this question , Lm / Lp = 1/ 6 ? or Lp / Lm = 1/6 ? Lp = length of prototype , Lm = Length of model

i really have no idea... can someone help please?
2. (Original post by wilson dang)
in this question , Lm / Lp = 1/ 6 ? or Lp / Lm = 1/6 ? Lp = length of prototype , Lm = Length of model

i really have no idea... can someone help please?
Lm/Lp = 1/6
3. (Original post by natninja)
Lm/Lp = 1/6
can you explain why are you so sure that Lm/Lp = 1/6 ????
4. (Original post by wilson dang)
can you explain why are you so sure that Lm/Lp = 1/6 ????
because the model is obviously going to be smaller
5. (Original post by natninja)
because the model is obviously going to be smaller
Do you mean the model can be only smaller, and can't be larger than prototype??

Sent from my C6502 using Tapatalk
6. (Original post by wilson dang)
Do you mean the model can be only smaller, and can't be larger than prototype??

Sent from my C6502 using Tapatalk
Yes. The idea is to have a smaller model because it's cheaper, easier to make and fits in a smaller wind tunnel. There is no reason why the model would be larger - if you could build a larger model, you'd just build one the correct size.
7. (Original post by natninja)
Yes. The idea is to have a smaller model because it's cheaper, easier to make and fits in a smaller wind tunnel. There is no reason why the model would be larger - if you could build a larger model, you'd just build one the correct size.
I also encounter the same question which the ratio is in terms of a:b , where a is larger than b ,
Let's say a is 5, b is 1 , does it also mean Lp/Lm is 5???? Since you said that the model must be smaller than prototype?

Sent from my C6502 using Tapatalk
8. (Original post by natninja)
Yes. The idea is to have a smaller model because it's cheaper, easier to make and fits in a smaller wind tunnel. There is no reason why the model would be larger - if you could build a larger model, you'd just build one the correct size.
I also encounter the same question which the ratio is in terms of a:b , where a is larger than b ,Let's say a is 5, b is 1 , does it also mean Lp/Lm is 5???? Since you said that the model must be smaller than prototype?
9. (Original post by wilson dang)
I also encounter the same question which the ratio is in terms of a:b , where a is larger than b ,
Let's say a is 5, b is 1 , does it also mean Lp/Lm is 5???? Since you said that the model must be smaller than prototype?

Sent from my C6502 using Tapatalk
Can you think of a sensible reason for building a model bigger than the prototype?
10. (Original post by natninja)
Can you think of a sensible reason for building a model bigger than the prototype?
No, but, I saw the question like this, I doubt that is that similar to the previous case, which the model is smaller??

Sent from my C6502 using Tapatalk
11. (Original post by natninja)
Can you think of a sensible reason for building a model bigger than the prototype?
when the scale ration is 6: 1 , does it mean the Lm / Lp = 6 , which model is 6 times larger than P , or Lp/ Lm = 6 , which means prototype is 6 times bigger than model ????
12. (Original post by wilson dang)
when the scale ration is 6: 1 , does it mean the Lm / Lp = 6 , which model is 6 times larger than P , or Lp/ Lm = 6 , which means prototype is 6 times bigger than model ????
It requires you to apply a small amount of common sense. I don't see any reasonable reasons to make a model bigger than the thing so the model is clearly the smaller of the two.

TSR Support Team

We have a brilliant team of more than 60 Support Team members looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.

This forum is supported by:
Updated: May 26, 2016
Today on TSR

### Four things top students are doing

Over the Easter break

### Her parents made her dump me

Poll

The Student Room, Get Revising and Marked by Teachers are trading names of The Student Room Group Ltd.

Register Number: 04666380 (England and Wales), VAT No. 806 8067 22 Registered Office: International House, Queens Road, Brighton, BN1 3XE