Go to first unread
Back
to top
Means-tested loans for students with divorced parents
Watch this thread
Announcements
bullseye1
Badges:
6
Rep:
?
You'll earn badges for being active around the site. Rep gems come when your posts are rated by other community members.
#1
Hi, when applying for student loans on the student loans website, if your parents are divorced or separated, do you/they have to provide financial information for both parents?If you live with say, just your dad, do you just provide income details for him, not for your mother?If so, does this give students the chance to potentially score much higher maintenance loans than students with married parents? It is entirely possible that the parent of a student who doesn't reside with them with could earn a high amount each year and give a proportion of their earnings to the other parent for child support, therefore a student with divorced parents wouldn't be in need of a higher loan any more than a student with parents who are together. In other words, this seems kind of unfair? Correct me if i'm wrong, I don't actually know how it works!If it is all correct, haven't the student loans company found a way to rule out playing the system by asking full financial details for how much the parent they don't reside with contributes to them? I know a few people with divorced parents who boast about the huge loans they get that they don't really need, and it seems unfair for people with parents who are together but cannot depend entirely on their parents financially and need bigger loans.
0
reply
claireestelle
Badges:
22
Rep:
?
You'll earn badges for being active around the site. Rep gems come when your posts are rated by other community members.
#2
Report
#2
(Original post by bullseye1)
Hi, when applying for student loans on the student loans website, if your parents are divorced or separated, do you/they have to provide financial information for both parents?If you live with say, just your dad, do you just provide income details for him, not for your mother?If so, does this give students the chance to potentially score much higher maintenance loans than students with married parents? It is entirely possible that the parent of a student who doesn't reside with them with could earn a high amount each year and give a proportion of their earnings to the other parent for child support, therefore a student with divorced parents wouldn't be in need of a higher loan any more than a student with parents who are together. In other words, this seems kind of unfair? Correct me if i'm wrong, I don't actually know how it works!If it is all correct, haven't the student loans company found a way to rule out playing the system by asking full financial details for how much the parent they don't reside with contributes to them? I know a few people with divorced parents who boast about the huge loans they get that they don't really need, and it seems unfair for people with parents who are together but cannot depend entirely on their parents financially and need bigger loans.
Hi, when applying for student loans on the student loans website, if your parents are divorced or separated, do you/they have to provide financial information for both parents?If you live with say, just your dad, do you just provide income details for him, not for your mother?If so, does this give students the chance to potentially score much higher maintenance loans than students with married parents? It is entirely possible that the parent of a student who doesn't reside with them with could earn a high amount each year and give a proportion of their earnings to the other parent for child support, therefore a student with divorced parents wouldn't be in need of a higher loan any more than a student with parents who are together. In other words, this seems kind of unfair? Correct me if i'm wrong, I don't actually know how it works!If it is all correct, haven't the student loans company found a way to rule out playing the system by asking full financial details for how much the parent they don't reside with contributes to them? I know a few people with divorced parents who boast about the huge loans they get that they don't really need, and it seems unfair for people with parents who are together but cannot depend entirely on their parents financially and need bigger loans.
0
reply
bullseye1
Badges:
6
Rep:
?
You'll earn badges for being active around the site. Rep gems come when your posts are rated by other community members.
#3
(Original post by claireestelle)
They will just ask for the parent you live with and proof that they are divorced, however child support is included in a parents income and therefore they should be declaring it.
They will just ask for the parent you live with and proof that they are divorced, however child support is included in a parents income and therefore they should be declaring it.
Also I know people should declare child support, but I'm pretty many won't if they can get away with it, just to get bigger loans. Is there a way student finance England cracks down on people doing this, because in the past i've know of people who've done this and not been found out and received huge loans when both parents, though separated, gave them plenty of financial support. It seems like if the parent you live with is on low income, then a student could get a huge loans even if their other parents provided them with lots of money in the form of child support, which is very unfair and just dishonest!
0
reply
bullseye1
Badges:
6
Rep:
?
You'll earn badges for being active around the site. Rep gems come when your posts are rated by other community members.
#4
(Original post by alkaline.)
Thought this said memes n was interested for a sec
Thought this said memes n was interested for a sec
0
reply
claireestelle
Badges:
22
Rep:
?
You'll earn badges for being active around the site. Rep gems come when your posts are rated by other community members.
#5
Report
#5
(Original post by bullseye1)
I see, so 'child support' is the money the other parent not residing with them is giving their other parent to support them?
Also I know people should declare child support, but I'm pretty many won't if they can get away with it, just to get bigger loans. Is there a way student finance England cracks down on people doing this, because in the past i've know of people who've done this and not been found out and received huge loans when both parents, though separated, gave them plenty of financial support. It seems like if the parent you live with is on low income, then a student could get a huge loans even if their other parents provided them with lots of money in the form of child support, which is very unfair and just dishonest!
I see, so 'child support' is the money the other parent not residing with them is giving their other parent to support them?
Also I know people should declare child support, but I'm pretty many won't if they can get away with it, just to get bigger loans. Is there a way student finance England cracks down on people doing this, because in the past i've know of people who've done this and not been found out and received huge loans when both parents, though separated, gave them plenty of financial support. It seems like if the parent you live with is on low income, then a student could get a huge loans even if their other parents provided them with lots of money in the form of child support, which is very unfair and just dishonest!
0
reply
bullseye1
Badges:
6
Rep:
?
You'll earn badges for being active around the site. Rep gems come when your posts are rated by other community members.
#6
(Original post by claireestelle)
Yes it is. I m unsure as to how evidence is asked for of child support though. Although now with the english system no longer having grants, the system is only loans so they'd just end up owing more money if they did get it. I suppose in some situations parents separate and they give no money towards a child, and unfortunately its impossible for them to make the system completely fair reallu.
Yes it is. I m unsure as to how evidence is asked for of child support though. Although now with the english system no longer having grants, the system is only loans so they'd just end up owing more money if they did get it. I suppose in some situations parents separate and they give no money towards a child, and unfortunately its impossible for them to make the system completely fair reallu.
0
reply
claireestelle
Badges:
22
Rep:
?
You'll earn badges for being active around the site. Rep gems come when your posts are rated by other community members.
#7
Report
#7
(Original post by bullseye1)
I see, and yeah what you said about loans is true, but the government's logic is flawed as this is the case with everyone, everyone has to pay back loans, so why are they means-tested in the first place? If they're paid back, why restrict the amount students are entitled to - again very unfair! And yeah that's a good point, I just thought that considering the government is usually so stingy about student loans, they'd find a way to stop people being dishonest about their parents income to get bigger loans off them.
I see, and yeah what you said about loans is true, but the government's logic is flawed as this is the case with everyone, everyone has to pay back loans, so why are they means-tested in the first place? If they're paid back, why restrict the amount students are entitled to - again very unfair! And yeah that's a good point, I just thought that considering the government is usually so stingy about student loans, they'd find a way to stop people being dishonest about their parents income to get bigger loans off them.
0
reply
sr90
Badges:
19
Rep:
?
You'll earn badges for being active around the site. Rep gems come when your posts are rated by other community members.
#8
Report
#8
And what about all those people who aren't lucky enough to have a divorced parent assisting financially, or even be in contact with them? Not everyone is trying to rinse the system you know. My dad was earning a six figure salary (and probably still is) but disappeared without trace and never gave my mum a penny.
You can never make the student loan system completely fair. Someone will always lose out.
You can never make the student loan system completely fair. Someone will always lose out.
0
reply
mliela
Badges:
14
Rep:
?
You'll earn badges for being active around the site. Rep gems come when your posts are rated by other community members.
#9
Report
#9
(Original post by sr90)
And what about all those people who aren't lucky enough to have a divorced parent assisting financially, or even be in contact with them? Not everyone is trying to rinse the system you know. My dad was earning a six figure salary (and probably still is) but disappeared without trace and never gave my mum a penny.
You can never make the student loan system completely fair. Someone will always lose out.
And what about all those people who aren't lucky enough to have a divorced parent assisting financially, or even be in contact with them? Not everyone is trying to rinse the system you know. My dad was earning a six figure salary (and probably still is) but disappeared without trace and never gave my mum a penny.
You can never make the student loan system completely fair. Someone will always lose out.
But it would be unfair to use both parents if the student isn't in contact with both. And it'd take to much time and be too intrusive to prove this further.
Posted from TSR Mobile
0
reply
Natashadesigner
Badges:
5
Rep:
?
You'll earn badges for being active around the site. Rep gems come when your posts are rated by other community members.
#10
Report
#10
i don't think child support is requested, only taxable income. that was the case with my application anyway
0
reply
bullseye1
Badges:
6
Rep:
?
You'll earn badges for being active around the site. Rep gems come when your posts are rated by other community members.
#11
(Original post by sr90)
And what about all those people who aren't lucky enough to have a divorced parent assisting financially, or even be in contact with them? Not everyone is trying to rinse the system you know. My dad was earning a six figure salary (and probably still is) but disappeared without trace and never gave my mum a penny.
You can never make the student loan system completely fair. Someone will always lose out.
And what about all those people who aren't lucky enough to have a divorced parent assisting financially, or even be in contact with them? Not everyone is trying to rinse the system you know. My dad was earning a six figure salary (and probably still is) but disappeared without trace and never gave my mum a penny.
You can never make the student loan system completely fair. Someone will always lose out.
0
reply
bullseye1
Badges:
6
Rep:
?
You'll earn badges for being active around the site. Rep gems come when your posts are rated by other community members.
#12
(Original post by claireestelle)
The government's logic is flawed on lots of things I m afraid.
The government's logic is flawed on lots of things I m afraid.
The government doesn't want to hand out loans because they know many people will not pay them back by age 30 and they'll be cleared and have got a proportion of their higher education free from the government - by letting people lie about their parent's incomes, these are more loan repayments they won't get back - makes no sense to me.
0
reply
bullseye1
Badges:
6
Rep:
?
You'll earn badges for being active around the site. Rep gems come when your posts are rated by other community members.
#13
(Original post by Natashadesigner)
i don't think child support is requested, only taxable income. that was the case with my application anyway
i don't think child support is requested, only taxable income. that was the case with my application anyway
0
reply
Natashadesigner
Badges:
5
Rep:
?
You'll earn badges for being active around the site. Rep gems come when your posts are rated by other community members.
#14
Report
#14
(Original post by bullseye1)
Well there we go - makes it even easier for people to score bigger loans, even if both parents invest plenty of money into them and they're in the exact same financial situation as a person with married parents who can't get a big enough loan.
Well there we go - makes it even easier for people to score bigger loans, even if both parents invest plenty of money into them and they're in the exact same financial situation as a person with married parents who can't get a big enough loan.
0
reply
mliela
Badges:
14
Rep:
?
You'll earn badges for being active around the site. Rep gems come when your posts are rated by other community members.
#15
Report
#15
(Original post by bullseye1)
I realise that, but it's surprising to see that they're flawed on something that disadvantages them - if they are so reluctant to hand out loans to students, why not find a way to crack down on people with divorced parents who are knowingly, in a way, cheating the system so they can get bigger loans than others with divorced parents who are honest?
The government doesn't want to hand out loans because they know many people will not pay them back by age 30 and they'll be cleared and have got a proportion of their higher education free from the government - by letting people lie about their parent's incomes, these are more loan repayments they won't get back - makes no sense to me.
I realise that, but it's surprising to see that they're flawed on something that disadvantages them - if they are so reluctant to hand out loans to students, why not find a way to crack down on people with divorced parents who are knowingly, in a way, cheating the system so they can get bigger loans than others with divorced parents who are honest?
The government doesn't want to hand out loans because they know many people will not pay them back by age 30 and they'll be cleared and have got a proportion of their higher education free from the government - by letting people lie about their parent's incomes, these are more loan repayments they won't get back - makes no sense to me.
Also it's not written of by age thirty. It's written off after thirty years.
Posted from TSR Mobile
0
reply
bullseye1
Badges:
6
Rep:
?
You'll earn badges for being active around the site. Rep gems come when your posts are rated by other community members.
#16
(Original post by Natashadesigner)
yep definitely agree for wealthy divorced parents! However right now I haven't benefitted from it at all even though the guidelines said I would be eligible. Going to call tomorrow to double check after reading this
yep definitely agree for wealthy divorced parents! However right now I haven't benefitted from it at all even though the guidelines said I would be eligible. Going to call tomorrow to double check after reading this
0
reply
bullseye1
Badges:
6
Rep:
?
You'll earn badges for being active around the site. Rep gems come when your posts are rated by other community members.
#17
(Original post by mliela)
They can't be bothered. Do you know how many man hours it would take to go through and sort that kind of stuff. Every individual situation is different and the government doesn't want to spend time and money catering to individuals. It would also make the system more invasive. They would need a lot more proof and more details which people don't always want to give. We just have to accept that there will never be a perfect system.
Also it's not written of by age thirty. It's written off after thirty years.
Posted from TSR Mobile
They can't be bothered. Do you know how many man hours it would take to go through and sort that kind of stuff. Every individual situation is different and the government doesn't want to spend time and money catering to individuals. It would also make the system more invasive. They would need a lot more proof and more details which people don't always want to give. We just have to accept that there will never be a perfect system.
Also it's not written of by age thirty. It's written off after thirty years.
Posted from TSR Mobile
0
reply
mliela
Badges:
14
Rep:
?
You'll earn badges for being active around the site. Rep gems come when your posts are rated by other community members.
#18
Report
#18
(Original post by bullseye1)
I'm pretty sure the time and money it would take would take to put a legal thing in place to declare child support would not outweigh the thousands of pounds given to people with divorced parents who lie or do not disclose how much child support they receive from their other parent. People may not want to give details, but there are plenty of details which they don't want to give that they already have to legally. And yeah that's wrong, but my point still stands - many will not ever repay their loans back.
I'm pretty sure the time and money it would take would take to put a legal thing in place to declare child support would not outweigh the thousands of pounds given to people with divorced parents who lie or do not disclose how much child support they receive from their other parent. People may not want to give details, but there are plenty of details which they don't want to give that they already have to legally. And yeah that's wrong, but my point still stands - many will not ever repay their loans back.
Posted from TSR Mobile
0
reply
bullseye1
Badges:
6
Rep:
?
You'll earn badges for being active around the site. Rep gems come when your posts are rated by other community members.
#19
(Original post by mliela)
You're forgetting that the money will potentially be paid back as its a loan. It would need a larger workforce and a more complicated system which is too much effort for the government. You have to be realistic. The whole system and process would be extremely long and take too much time. This also doesn't affect as many people as you think it does. Also it's just a fact of life. There will always be people that are highly disadvantaged due to a certain system and those that can use it to their benefit.
Posted from TSR Mobile
You're forgetting that the money will potentially be paid back as its a loan. It would need a larger workforce and a more complicated system which is too much effort for the government. You have to be realistic. The whole system and process would be extremely long and take too much time. This also doesn't affect as many people as you think it does. Also it's just a fact of life. There will always be people that are highly disadvantaged due to a certain system and those that can use it to their benefit.
Posted from TSR Mobile
0
reply
mliela
Badges:
14
Rep:
?
You'll earn badges for being active around the site. Rep gems come when your posts are rated by other community members.
#20
Report
#20
(Original post by bullseye1)
All I'm saying is that they don't need to change the system, they need to enforce it. People easily get around it to get huge loans that they shouldn't be entitled to by being dishonest - why even have a system if part of it isn't implemented. It isn't a fact of life, many 'systems' work properly to avoid this sort of thing, this one doesn't.
All I'm saying is that they don't need to change the system, they need to enforce it. People easily get around it to get huge loans that they shouldn't be entitled to by being dishonest - why even have a system if part of it isn't implemented. It isn't a fact of life, many 'systems' work properly to avoid this sort of thing, this one doesn't.
0
reply
X
Quick Reply
