x Turn on thread page Beta
 You are Here: Home

# Rate/ order question (a2) watch

1. The question asked you to find the order with respect to H+;

The concentration of H+ (mol dm-3) and rates are;

Experiment 1- 0.005. / rate- 5.75x10^-6
Experiment 2- 0.005. / rate- 1.15x10^-5
Experiment 3- 0.010. / rate- 2.30x10^-5

I said that H+ was 2nd order because if you double the concentration from 0.005 to 0.010, the rate quadruples from 5.75x10^-6 to 2.30x10^-5?

However the mark scheme says that H+ is zero order so I'm just really confused atm.

The paper is Ocr Jan 2010/ the old spec!

2. (Original post by Lularose83)
The question asked you to find the order with respect to H+;

The concentration of H+ (mol dm-3) and rates are;

Experiment 1- 0.005. / rate- 5.75x10^-6
Experiment 2- 0.005. / rate- 1.15x10^-5
Experiment 3- 0.010. / rate- 2.30x10^-5

I said that H+ was 2nd order because if you double the concentration from 0.005 to 0.010, the rate quadruples from 5.75x10^-6 to 2.30x10^-5?

However the mark scheme says that H+ is zero order so I'm just really confused atm.

The paper is Ocr Jan 2010/ the old spec!

You also need to take into account the data from the other components of the reaction. You have not included these in the question.
3. (Original post by charco)
You also need to take into account the data from the other components of the reaction. You have not included these in the question.
Ok,
When I- concentration quadruples from 0.010 to 0.040, the rate also quadruples. So would the answer be that as I- is first order, it has caused the rate to quadruple rather than the H+ being involved?

But I still can't see how you would deduce that H+ is zero order!
4. (Original post by Lularose83)
Ok,
When I- concentration quadruples from 0.010 to 0.040, the rate also quadruples. So would the answer be that as I- is first order, it has caused the rate to quadruple rather than the H+ being involved?

But I still can't see how you would deduce that H+ is zero order!
You can only compare the hydrogen ion concentration in experiments where the concentrations of ALL the other components stay the same...

... or else you must compensate in the rate value for the effect of changing another concentration (more difficult).
5. Hey have you got a pic or screenshot of the whole question?
6. (Original post by Lularose83)
Ok,
When I- concentration quadruples from 0.010 to 0.040, the rate also quadruples. So would the answer be that as I- is first order, it has caused the rate to quadruple rather than the H+ being involved?

But I still can't see how you would deduce that H+ is zero order!
In the second and third experiment numbers that you listed above, I am guessing that the concentration of iodine also changed (and I'm guessing the order with respect to iodine was first order), so that means that the rate changed due to the change in iodine concentration rather than the change in hydrogen ion concentration. Therefore, you can conclude that the hydrogen ion concentration has no effect on initla rate of reaction --> Order with respect to H+ = 0.
7. (Original post by Don Pedro K.)
In the second and third experiment numbers that you listed above, I am guessing that the concentration of iodine also changed (and I'm guessing the order with respect to iodine was first order), so that means that the rate changed due to the change in iodine concentration rather than the change in hydrogen ion concentration. Therefore, you can conclude that the hydrogen ion concentration has no effect on initla rate of reaction --> Order with respect to H+ = 0.
That makes sense, but how would you work out which one caused the rate to change when both concentrations increased?
8. (Original post by Lularose83)
That makes sense, but how would you work out which one caused the rate to change when both concentrations increased?
Because if you know that one has an order of reaction as 1, then you can see if the rate changes because of that concentration change and not the one you're trying to work out.

TSR Support Team

We have a brilliant team of more than 60 Support Team members looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.

This forum is supported by:
Updated: June 5, 2016
Today on TSR

### Boyfriend slept with someone else

...we were on a break

### Mum says she'll curse me if I don't go to uni

Poll

The Student Room, Get Revising and Marked by Teachers are trading names of The Student Room Group Ltd.

Register Number: 04666380 (England and Wales), VAT No. 806 8067 22 Registered Office: International House, Queens Road, Brighton, BN1 3XE