The Student Room Group

I have "oneitis"

Yes, unfortunately, oneitis has infected me - for those that don't know, it's basically having a hang up on one girl when you've been rejected. Anyway, allow me to explain (sorry for the walls of text):

I'm 19 btw. I met this girl at Uni, she was taken at first, then she became "available", knew I liked her, and we struck up somewhat of a rappor. Our mutual friend told me that she liked me, and so I asked her about it one night before the end of Easter term. She said she wasn't sure as she was still "broken" from the relationship with her ex and needed to think over Easter. We talked a lot over Easter but I let her think about the situation and didn't ask her about it.

About a week back after Easter, I asked if we'd gotten anywhere and I was (to my actual surprise) rejected. It was quite crushing as I really thought she was the girl, and this was the only time a girl had even looked at me twice, so to get so damn close and get rejected was quite crushing. She gave me various reasons - she'd end up taking me for granted etc, and I honestly don't believe she was just fobbing me off (she said she did find me attractive when I questioned whether she just wasn't attracted to me). She also said she didn't want anything too comitted right now as her last relationship ended in a botched semi-engagement.

So she's currently having a casual thing with this guy she met, which of course made me feel kinda bad and a little self-loathesome as I for a while constantly pondered whether she went with him because he was better looking, and had a lot of money but I stayed these thoughts as I saw her as better than that.

Present day: it's 2 months later and I still don't feel as though I've moved on much. We still talk a lot and there's no way I want to cut her out of my life because she's a great person and one of the few girls I've really truly connected with. In the last week or two I've kinda tried to move out of the "puppy dog" phase and I've been a bit more argumentative and stuff which has helped, although there's just one thing that keeps bugging me, and I know people might jump to conclusions.

Basically, we're VERY honest with one another, more honest than I am with anyone else, and so we've had a number of discussions about sex. It came into conversation that she's had sex with her current boyfriend, and this is what really bugs me for some reason. Every time I think about them together in that way it makes me red in the face and quite depressed. Now, I know that makes it sound like I'm just into her for her looks and sex and stuff, but I assure you that's not true. Sure, I think about her in that way, but, I value her personality far more, as she has what few women I've met have. Maybe the thought of me getting so close to being with her and then just having the shocking crush is still something I'm recovering from, but the thought of being that guy, in a physical and emotional sense, I mean, to be replaced by a guy she tells me she's not even that happy with, is a massive frustration.

Conclusion: I need to laid, but I want it to be with someone I care about without any of the above complications. This girl meant (and still does) everything to me, and basically I'm asking how I can bury these feelings and just like her as a friend? I won't cut her out of my life and basically I just want to stop feeling sad when I think of her and I not being together, and moreso (as I find it kinda strange) when I think of her being intimate with this guy.

Thanks, and sorry for the wall of text.
Reply 1
Anonymous
Yes, unfortunately, oneitis has infected me - for those that don't know, it's basically having a hang up on one girl when you've been rejected. Anyway, allow me to explain (sorry for the walls of text):

I'm 19 btw. I met this girl at Uni, she was taken at first, then she became "available", knew I liked her, and we struck up somewhat of a rappor. Our mutual friend told me that she liked me, and so I asked her about it one night before the end of Easter term. She said she wasn't sure as she was still "broken" from the relationship with her ex and needed to think over Easter. We talked a lot over Easter but I let her think about the situation and didn't ask her about it.

About a week back after Easter, I asked if we'd gotten anywhere and I was (to my actual surprise) rejected. It was quite crushing as I really thought she was the girl, and this was the only time a girl had even looked at me twice, so to get so damn close and get rejected was quite crushing. She gave me various reasons - she'd end up taking me for granted etc, and I honestly don't believe she was just fobbing me off (she said she did find me attractive when I questioned whether she just wasn't attracted to me). She also said she didn't want anything too comitted right now as her last relationship ended in a botched semi-engagement.

So she's currently having a casual thing with this guy she met, which of course made me feel kinda bad and a little self-loathesome as I for a while constantly pondered whether she went with him because he was better looking, and had a lot of money but I stayed these thoughts as I saw her as better than that.

Present day: it's 2 months later and I still don't feel as though I've moved on much. We still talk a lot and there's no way I want to cut her out of my life because she's a great person and one of the few girls I've really truly connected with. In the last week or two I've kinda tried to move out of the "puppy dog" phase and I've been a bit more argumentative and stuff which has helped, although there's just one thing that keeps bugging me, and I know people might jump to conclusions.

Basically, we're VERY honest with one another, more honest than I am with anyone else, and so we've had a number of discussions about sex. It came into conversation that she's had sex with her current boyfriend, and this is what really bugs me for some reason. Every time I think about them together in that way it makes me red in the face and quite depressed. Now, I know that makes it sound like I'm just into her for her looks and sex and stuff, but I assure you that's not true. Sure, I think about her in that way, but, I value her personality far more, as she has what few women I've met have. Maybe the thought of me getting so close to being with her and then just having the shocking crush is still something I'm recovering from, but the thought of being that guy, in a physical and emotional sense, I mean, to be replaced by a guy she tells me she's not even that happy with, is a massive frustration.

Conclusion: I need to laid, but I want it to be with someone I care about without any of the above complications. This girl meant (and still does) everything to me, and basically I'm asking how I can bury these feelings and just like her as a friend? I won't cut her out of my life and basically I just want to stop feeling sad when I think of her and I not being together, and moreso (as I find it kinda strange) when I think of her being intimate with this guy.

Thanks, and sorry for the wall of text.


I was in a similar situation a while back, but in her case - it was going perfectly, until she left the country due to her being an exchange student. haha, great!

From what you have written, it sounds as though she just sees you as a 'friend' and thats it. I think part of the reason for that is because you waited too long and opened up to her far too quickly. Observe the way her current bf acts and compare it to the way you have acted. He obviously did something different which is why she got into a relationship with him quickly. From what you say, 'attraction' does not seem to be an issue between you and her. So there is your answer.

Most of my friends that are girls will never never ever hit off with a good male friend, unless drunk, they always end up going out with guys no one knows about because they don't want to ruin their friendship with guys they are friends with.

I would just try and move on, the more you think about what could have been will just depress you. So don't go down that road, just meet different people, be laid back and relax. The way I delt with my case, is that even though she does email me from time to time - I know nothing will ever happen with her because she is back home and probably with some other dude.
mate you just got to cut her out of your life for abit...maybe start seeing another girl, most girls are so insecure that when she sees you with another woman, she will want to be with you (as you say there is still attraction there) because she will know that your wanted goods!

She aint going to get with someone that nobody wants
Reply 3
I have been in a very similar situation in some ways.

I liked a guy for a very long time. We'd known each other for about 2 and a half years and I absolutely adored him. A year and a half after I'd met him he suddenly started talking about his girlfriend and it tore me apart inside... but I knew that I had to let him do whatever made him happy.
He never knew how I felt and he went off to the army and I never saw him again... except once for an hour when he came back due to illness. I still think about him sometimes.

I've found it very hard to get over him but it is possible.

On the other hand, this girl is still around so there's still a chance. Maybe she doesn't see you in that way or maybe she's just after the guy's money. I'm not sure about that one but either way you need to step back. If you interfere then she's likely not to be happy about it. If you can wait for her, then do, but if not I'd try finding someone else. Hard as it is, we sometimes have to do it.
Reply 4
been there.

walk away from it now.
The problem is that I don't want to walk away from her as a friend. I guess taking a healthy step back may be a good idea.
Reply 6
Step back as far as you can or you will have your heart well and truly broken. I honestly believe she is giving you the brush off in the nicest way. I'm sorry :smile:
Reply 7
Anonymous
The problem is that I don't want to walk away from her as a friend. I guess taking a healthy step back may be a good idea.


Yeah, was going to suggest what the others have said. But mate seriously if it is affecting you this bad YOU will NEVER truely move on. :wink:

If anything, you will want her more now because she is pretty much unobtainable at the moment.

Cut her out your life if you want a peace of mind. Otherwise, your 'oneitis' will never properly heal. What is the point being friends with her mate, think about it? On one hand you are friends with her, then on the other hand you want to be with her. Soon you will probably moan about how she chooses others guys ahead of you (even though they treat her like a jerk) - is it worth it mentally? Be true to yourself - do you really want a friendship?
technik
been there.

walk away from it now.

:ditto:

Far too emotionally dangerous. **** it, just tell her how you feel and keep away from her. I'm normally not a fan of this sort of stuff, but sometimes it's just necessary.
Reply 9
Sorry that this isn't that helpful, but OP, may I applaud you for such a nicely-written post. You often don't see that many of those around here.

Can you be friends with this girl but also make sure you spend plenty of time with other people? Maybe even other girls, just as friends? Going into other relationships on a sort of rebound isn't good but if you can take a step back (a small one) from this girl and kind of "replace" her with other female company (I know it wouldn't be the same, but I feel it would be a consolation of sorts) then it may help you to move on a bit.
I can say with some truth that once I'm back at Uni and in the presence of girls (as I have no female friends at home), it'll aid the healing process, and just talking to them will help my self-esteem and stuff. I'd just love to, you know, meet a girl for a drink or something with no intention of anything further happening, just for sociableness, but I don't know any girls like that really. I had a bad experience with a girl 3 years ago and it kinda crushed my spirit, and I'm pretty nervous around women anyway. But I'm really going to try, as I don't think I can bring myself to sever this girl away. She's a great friend and I just can't believe I'll meet a female who's been as good a friend to me as she has. The thought of walking away just disgusts me.
Jelkin
Can you be friends with this girl but also make sure you spend plenty of time with other people? Maybe even other girls, just as friends? Going into other relationships on a sort of rebound isn't good but if you can take a step back (a small one) from this girl and kind of "replace" her with other female company (I know it wouldn't be the same, but I feel it would be a consolation of sorts) then it may help you to move on a bit.

:ditto: Fully seconded!

Jess is so right. Replacement is the way forward - it allows the OP to make lots of fab new friends, without suffering from infatuatee withdrawal. Plus, relationships with the newbies could well blossom into more than this girl ever was to him.
And alas, this is why I can't wait to get back to Uni - I start my second year and lotsa first year girls show up. And I mean that in no perverted/taking advantage way, I hasten to add.