Hi, I need help! I've got a history homework due tomorrow and I don't know what to write. Could anyone help me out? The essay needs to be roughly a page long.
The question is: Why do Source C and D have different views about the conditions of workhouses?
Questions to answer:
What is the message that each source is trying to say?
Why do they have different messages?
What are its strengths and weaknesses of each source?
Which view of the workhouse do you think is most likely to be true ?
What was the menu today, Tuesday? Roast mutton and potatoes, with bread. The young men and women each had four and a half ounces of meat, twelve ounces of potatoes, and four ounces of bread. For breakfast the ration was four ounces of bread, one pint and a half of porridge or one pint of cocoa; and for supper it will be six ounces of bread and one pint and a half of broth.
Now we reach the aged married couples' quarters- ten little rooms and a general room at the end for meals. Admirable is the only word for it. The brightly painted walls, the pictures, the furniture, the photographs and knick-knacks belonging to the inmates, who are allowed to bring in such property and arrange it as they choose. If an old couple must spend their last days in the workhouse, one could wish them no brighter or healthier quarters.
TW Wilkinson, a professional writer. Taken from his article called London's Homes for the Homeless from the non-fiction book entitled Living London (1902)
I am writing with regard to the enquiries as to the sanitary conditions of the Cardiff Union Workhouse. The atmosphere of some of the apartments which are occupied by the invalid inmates, day and night, have become impregnated with malefic miasma, that many inmates have become diseased. Here they are living in squalid filthy lodgings and are no further away from destitution and squalor than where they previously came from.
The paupers mortality has been affected to a great extent, especially the children. It would be very desirable to reduce the number of children here or indeed remove them entirely from the Workhouse, especially as the vast majority of deaths in this workhouse are of children.
James Lewis, Doctor to the Cardiff Workhouse, writing a letter to the Poor Law Inspector, who was conducting a government enquiry into the conditions in the country's Workhouses. (1849)
I'll be very grateful if anyone could help me out as soon as possible. Thank you!
History Source Essay Watch
- Thread Starter
- 22-01-2017 10:26
- 22-01-2017 10:39
Summarise the points they are making.
Think about Author, Date that kind of thing.
Talk about how reliable they are and this will help you decide which is more likely to be truthful.
For example, the first source could be more reliable as it is a non-fiction, with the sole purpose to inform, whereas the second source is a letter, which means the information is biased, however it is more personal - you could argue this makes it more truthful.