Circle: x^2 + y^2 = 1. Some point P has coordinates (x, y) where y/x = tan theta, and so x = cos theta, y = sin theta, and use Pythagoras. Standard proof.
(I'll be impressed if anyone bothers reading through this properly!!)
I would be really surprised as well. What is the point in going in for really complicate proofs when really simple ones exist. I would go for a simple right-angled triangle labelled O, A and H. Then apply pythagoras theorem, followed by dividing each term by H^2.
I would be really surprised as well. What is the point in going in for really complicate proofs when really simple ones exist. I would go for a simple right-angled triangle labelled O, A and H. Then apply pythagoras theorem, followed by dividing each term by H^2.
It depends on how you define sin and cos. In a real analysis course, it'll be defined by its power series. But it's not obvious that the power series definition and the angles in a triangle definition are the same. I went from the power series. There are many hidden assumptions in the shorter proofs. Some of them rely on things you don't see until you've done about 4 months at university. My proof only needed about 4 weeks!
Besides. The thread did ask for as many different proofs as possible.