Help with physics GCSE - LensesWatch

Thread starter 1 year ago
#1
I have a question that I can't get my head around. I have been reading and I found out that the reason magnifying glasses appear inverted to us is because the object is further away from the principal focus, and is therefore diminished and real - simple enough. However, magnifying glasses use convex lenses and so do our eyes, so why is it that we don't see far away objects as upside down. Also, for convex lenses, aren't images closer to the focal length supposed to be the right way up (so inverted to us)? I have the same question for cameras - why is it that magnifying glasses work differently in this sense? I'm sure there's a simple answer to this and I'll kick myself when I find out what it is. Thanks to anyone who can help!
0
1 year ago
#2
Hi,

Let us get things clear in our minds: 1. you are referring to a magnifying lens appearring inverted (NO, it is the IMAGE PRODUCED BY THE LENS that matters NOT the lens itself) 2. You mention a magnifying lens producing a diminished image - surely that is a self-contradiction.

Let me take through the optics of it all step by step.

Firstly, a magnifying lens is a convex or converging lens (its power is in plus dioptres [inversely related to its radius of curvature) i.e. it is thicker in the middle thin at the edges, therefore convex; it makes light rays converge i.e. bend towards its axis (= midline).

A diverging lens diverges rays = bends them (refracts) outwards away from the axis, and is thicker at the edges, thinner in the centre. (see pic below).

The image in diagram I (convex = magnifying lens), is inverted (A is on top in the object, and A' is below in the image) AND the image is on opposite side of the lens as the object, so can be seen where it is = real.

In diagram II, (concave = minifying lens), the image is on the same side of the lens as the object (= virtual image), is smaller (minifying) and is upright (A is above [object] AND A' is above [image]).

In the human eye, the crystalline lens (very convex [power = +60 dioptres! average magnifying lens in physics = 4-6 D]; almost like a marble!!) is of course a convex (magnifying) lens - the IMAGE ON THE RETINA is INVERTED yes, but we learn to re-invert it in neonatal life (when we are very young babies) [in fact, newborns see upside down in the first few hours/days].

In a camera the situation is very complex because this instrument [like many others - telescope, keratomter, slit lamp biomicroscope] uses a copound lens i.e. several lenses fused together inclusive of plus and minus ones. Since you seem to be a student with an inquiring mind, I will briefly mention to you the equation you need to work out the power of such lenses:

Attachment 639554639558Attachment 639554639558

FE = equivalent power; F1 =power of first lens; F2 = power ofsecond lens; d = distance between optical centres of the 2 lenses.

From FE and object details, you can work out size, position of image.
Very good Q btw!

M (Science tutor)
2
Thread starter 1 year ago
#3
(Original post by macpatelgh)
Hi,

Let us get things clear in our minds: 1. you are referring to a magnifying lens appearring inverted (NO, it is the IMAGE PRODUCED BY THE LENS that matters NOT the lens itself) 2. You mention a magnifying lens producing a diminished image - surely that is a self-contradiction.

Let me take through the optics of it all step by step.

Firstly, a magnifying lens is a convex or converging lens (its power is in plus dioptres [inversely related to its radius of curvature) i.e. it is thicker in the middle thin at the edges, therefore convex; it makes light rays converge i.e. bend towards its axis (= midline).

A diverging lens diverges rays = bends them (refracts) outwards away from the axis, and is thicker at the edges, thinner in the centre. (see pic below).

The image in diagram I (convex = magnifying lens), is inverted (A is on top in the object, and A' is below in the image) AND the image is on opposite side of the lens as the object, so can be seen where it is = real.

In diagram II, (concave = minifying lens), the image is on the same side of the lens as the object (= virtual image), is smaller (minifying) and is upright (A is above [object] AND A' is above [image]).

In the human eye, the crystalline lens (very convex [power = +60 dioptres! average magnifying lens in physics = 4-6 D]; almost like a marble!!) is of course a convex (magnifying) lens - the IMAGE ON THE RETINA is INVERTED yes, but we learn to re-invert it in neonatal life (when we are very young babies) [in fact, newborns see upside down in the first few hours/days].

In a camera the situation is very complex because this instrument [like many others - telescope, keratomter, slit lamp biomicroscope] uses a copound lens i.e. several lenses fused together inclusive of plus and minus ones. Since you seem to be a student with an inquiring mind, I will briefly mention to you the equation you need to work out the power of such lenses:

Attachment 639554639558Attachment 639554639558

FE = equivalent power; F1 =power of first lens; F2 = power ofsecond lens; d = distance between optical centres of the 2 lenses.

From FE and object details, you can work out size, position of image.
Very good Q btw!

M (Science tutor)
Thanks so much for your answer - it really helped! I'm just confused about 1 thing. If an image further than the focal length is inverted because the light rays cross on the retina (which, as you mentioned, is reversed by the brain), then why is it that objects that are closer than 1 focal length (I read it is around 1.7 cm for the eye) to the eye are not inverted for us? Also, when textbooks say an image is inverted, it appears as the right way up to us, right?

Thanks so much again!
0
X

new posts

Latest
My Feed

Oops, nobody has postedin the last few hours.

Why not re-start the conversation?

see more

See more of what you like onThe Student Room

You can personalise what you see on TSR. Tell us a little about yourself to get started.

University open days

• University of Roehampton
Department of Life Sciences; Department of Psychology Undergraduate
Thu, 21 Feb '19
• Edge Hill University
Thu, 21 Feb '19
• St George's, University of London
Thu, 21 Feb '19

Poll

Join the discussion

Yes (1)
1.49%
No (66)
98.51%