The Student Room Group

Help me solve this Combination maths problem

This is an IGCSE additional mathematics permutation combination problem which I can't understand. Can somebody explain how this is done? My teacher says the question is incomplete.

Question
---------------------------------------------------------
A box contains sweets of 6 different flavours. There are at least 2 sweets of each flavour. A girl selects 3 sweets from the box. Given that these 3 sweets are not all of the same flavour, calculate the number of different ways she can select her 3 sweets.

Answer
--------------------------------------------------------
3 Different = 6C2 = 20
2 of 1 kind + 1 = 6 * 5 = 30

Total = 2- + 30 = 50

Reply 1

Original post
by Paing Thet
This is an IGCSE additional mathematics permutation combination problem which I can't understand. Can somebody explain how this is done? My teacher says the question is incomplete.

Question
---------------------------------------------------------
A box contains sweets of 6 different flavours. There are at least 2 sweets of each flavour. A girl selects 3 sweets from the box. Given that these 3 sweets are not all of the same flavour, calculate the number of different ways she can select her 3 sweets.

Answer
--------------------------------------------------------
3 Different = 6C2 = 20
2 of 1 kind + 1 = 6 * 5 = 30

Total = 2- + 30 = 50


The question is complete, but there is a typo in the answer you've put.

Since the three chosen sweets are not all of the same flavour, either she has chosen 3 different flavours, or she has chosen 2 different flavours.

If 3 different, then she is choosing 3 from 6, and we have 6C3 = 20.

If there are two different flavours, then there is one of one flavour and two of a different flavour.
The one has 6 choices of flavours and once chosen the two have five choices, making 6x5=30 possibilities.

Hence 50 ways in total.

Reply 2

Original post
by ghostwalker
The question is complete, but there is a typo in the answer you've put.

Since the three chosen sweets are not all of the same flavour, either she has chosen 3 different flavours, or she has chosen 2 different flavours.

If 3 different, then she is choosing 3 from 6, and we have 6C3 = 20.

If there are two different flavours, then there is one of one flavour and two of a different flavour.
The one has 6 choices of flavours and once chosen the two have five choices, making 6x5=30 possibilities.

Hence 50 ways in total.


Wow, I understand it now. Thanks

Reply 3

When I choose 3 different flavours , why can't it be 6x5x4?

Reply 4

Original post
by Mathew Pang
When I choose 3 different flavours , why can't it be 6x5x4?


You'd have over counted as choosing sweets {1,3,6} would be the same as {6,3,1}. You're counting them as different.
For a given arrangement like {1,3,6}, there are 3*2 ways of arranging it, so you'd have to divide your number by 6 (which is 20 different ways as above.).

Reply 5

Original post
by mqb2766
You'd have over counted as choosing sweets {1,3,6} would be the same as {6,3,1}. You're counting them as different.
For a given arrangement like {1,3,6}, there are 3*2 ways of arranging it, so you'd have to divide your number by 6 (which is 20 different ways as above.).

But how come choose two flavor is 6x5 , but choose three favor is not 6x5x4? If want to ensure it will not repeat, then I guess choose two favor will be (6x5)/2

Reply 6

Original post
by Mathew Pang
But how come choose two flavor is 6x5 , but choose three favor is not 6x5x4? If want to ensure it will not repeat, then I guess choose two favor will be (6x5)/2


There are a few ways of explaining it, but assume you choose two different flavours, there are
6*5 / 2
ways of doing this (order not important, divide by 2). There are two possible ways of choosing the 3rd flavour (must be either flavour 1 or flavour 2). Twos cancel, hence
6*5

Reply 7

Original post
by Paing Thet
This is an IGCSE additional mathematics permutation combination problem which I can't understand. Can somebody explain how this is done? My teacher says the question is incomplete.
Question
---------------------------------------------------------
A box contains sweets of 6 different flavours. There are at least 2 sweets of each flavour. A girl selects 3 sweets from the box. Given that these 3 sweets are not all of the same flavour, calculate the number of different ways she can select her 3 sweets.
Answer
--------------------------------------------------------
3 Different = 6C2 = 20
2 of 1 kind + 1 = 6 * 5 = 30
Total = 2- + 30 = 50

Most of these comments got it right with the 6C3 part, but for the part where you do 2 of 1 kind and 1 of another kind, you could theoretically use permutations. This is because the different ways are 6P2 as you have 112, 223, 334, etc. Technically, you have 6 numbers (1,2,3,4,5,6) and 2 spots as the number is repeated. You have 112 and 211, which is quite similar to 12 and 21. 6P2 is 30, so the answer is 30 + the 20 at the start, which is 50

Quick Reply

How The Student Room is moderated

To keep The Student Room safe for everyone, we moderate posts that are added to the site.