Go to first unread
Back
to top
Are many people jealous of home educated children?
Watch
Announcements
As a person who was home educated for most of my secondary school age, but later studied at college, I have experienced the sharp end of prejudice towards home educated children in adult life. Some adults go round with the attitude that home educated children do not learn social skills and others believe that it's impossible for children to get a proper solid academic education unless they attend school. There are also those who think that home educated children are just dossers or slackers that don't get out of bed until midday. Employers aren't always sympathetic towards home educated children even if they later attended higher education.
Do you think that such people with prejudices towards home educated children are jealous at heart and wish that they were home educated themselves rather than attended school?
Do you think that such people with prejudices towards home educated children are jealous at heart and wish that they were home educated themselves rather than attended school?
0
reply
Report
#3
I'm more surprised you feel you have experienced prejudice. I have spent exactly 0% of my life being jealous of such children. Each to their own and I'm glad I attended school. Maybe people are a lot less interested than you think.
0
reply
Report
#4
Why would I be jealous of a child with no social skills-and probably overbearing parents? 
1
reply
Report
#5
I've only ever had people at college being merely surprised and curious that I was home educated till GCSEs - not prejudice exactly, but I have been told that I've 'missed out' on not being at school. I would say they're not jealous as such, more sympathetic/mild mocking than anything else.
0
reply
Report
#6
(Original post by glad-he-ate-her)
Nah home education is boring, i accidentally called my teacher mum once
Nah home education is boring, i accidentally called my teacher mum once
0
reply
Report
#7
(Original post by Arran90)
As a person who was home educated for most of my secondary school age, but later studied at college, I have experienced the sharp end of prejudice towards home educated children in adult life. Some adults go round with the attitude that home educated children do not learn social skills and others believe that it's impossible for children to get a proper solid academic education unless they attend school. There are also those who think that home educated children are just dossers or slackers that don't get out of bed until midday. Employers aren't always sympathetic towards home educated children even if they later attended higher education.
Do you think that such people with prejudices towards home educated children are jealous at heart and wish that they were home educated themselves rather than attended school?
As a person who was home educated for most of my secondary school age, but later studied at college, I have experienced the sharp end of prejudice towards home educated children in adult life. Some adults go round with the attitude that home educated children do not learn social skills and others believe that it's impossible for children to get a proper solid academic education unless they attend school. There are also those who think that home educated children are just dossers or slackers that don't get out of bed until midday. Employers aren't always sympathetic towards home educated children even if they later attended higher education.
Do you think that such people with prejudices towards home educated children are jealous at heart and wish that they were home educated themselves rather than attended school?
Home education isn't the norm, and anything that is out of the norm will attract different attitudes from people depending what they know. If someone asked me out of curiosity about mine and my grandson's experience, I would be happy to explain to them.
0
reply
Report
#8
(Original post by Nirvana1989-1994)
Why would I be jealous of a child with no social skills-and probably overbearing parents?
Why would I be jealous of a child with no social skills-and probably overbearing parents?
0
reply
Report
#9
(Original post by Seamus123)
How many home educated children do you know? Not many, I'm sure. Schools don't always meet the needs of children. My 7 children all went to school, but when I got custody of my grandson, with his accompanying issues with development, physical disabilities and other issues, I home educated him in his best interests. When he got to secondary age, he had the choice of remaining home educated or going to secondary school. He choose to continue to be home educated. He had no problems with social skills, and the college thought very highly of him and he gets on exceptionally well with his peers.
How many home educated children do you know? Not many, I'm sure. Schools don't always meet the needs of children. My 7 children all went to school, but when I got custody of my grandson, with his accompanying issues with development, physical disabilities and other issues, I home educated him in his best interests. When he got to secondary age, he had the choice of remaining home educated or going to secondary school. He choose to continue to be home educated. He had no problems with social skills, and the college thought very highly of him and he gets on exceptionally well with his peers.
Plus, it was a joking post.
0
reply
Report
#10
(Original post by Arran90)
As a person who was home educated for most of my secondary school age, but later studied at college, I have experienced the sharp end of prejudice towards home educated children in adult life. Some adults go round with the attitude that home educated children do not learn social skills and others believe that it's impossible for children to get a proper solid academic education unless they attend school. There are also those who think that home educated children are just dossers or slackers that don't get out of bed until midday. Employers aren't always sympathetic towards home educated children even if they later attended higher education.
Do you think that such people with prejudices towards home educated children are jealous at heart and wish that they were home educated themselves rather than attended school?
As a person who was home educated for most of my secondary school age, but later studied at college, I have experienced the sharp end of prejudice towards home educated children in adult life. Some adults go round with the attitude that home educated children do not learn social skills and others believe that it's impossible for children to get a proper solid academic education unless they attend school. There are also those who think that home educated children are just dossers or slackers that don't get out of bed until midday. Employers aren't always sympathetic towards home educated children even if they later attended higher education.
Do you think that such people with prejudices towards home educated children are jealous at heart and wish that they were home educated themselves rather than attended school?
1
reply
There is anecdotal evidence that children who are unhappy at school - especially the social side or as a result of bullying and disrespect from teachers and children - become depressed adults. This is regardless of how well they did academically or what GCSE grades they achieved.
0
reply
(Original post by JohnGreek)
Having prejudice does not mean that that prejudice is automatically fuelled by envy. I personally felt a lot of pity for the two kids I knew who were pulled out of school to be homeschooled by their parents.
Having prejudice does not mean that that prejudice is automatically fuelled by envy. I personally felt a lot of pity for the two kids I knew who were pulled out of school to be homeschooled by their parents.
Some children are home educated because of their parent's ideology - such as religion or libertarian ideology - but they may be happy and successful if they attended school. Other children are home educated because of problems and difficulties they faced at school or they were unhappy at school.
I was in the second category but found that a significant proportion of local home educated children were in the first category, usually libertarian.
The public face of the home education community in Britain are libertarians which can make it difficult for families who home educate for different reasons.
0
reply
Report
#14
Yea problem is is with schools they can be just a stomping ground for richer people. Hence getting rid of grammar schools, mixing actually makes it better in every way even if you were heading for 100 in all your exams in a grammar.
0
reply
Report
#15
(Original post by Seamus123)
How many home educated children do you know? Not many, I'm sure. Schools don't always meet the needs of children. My 7 children all went to school, but when I got custody of my grandson, with his accompanying issues with development, physical disabilities and other issues, I home educated him in his best interests. When he got to secondary age, he had the choice of remaining home educated or going to secondary school. He choose to continue to be home educated. He had no problems with social skills, and the college thought very highly of him and he gets on exceptionally well with his peers.
How many home educated children do you know? Not many, I'm sure. Schools don't always meet the needs of children. My 7 children all went to school, but when I got custody of my grandson, with his accompanying issues with development, physical disabilities and other issues, I home educated him in his best interests. When he got to secondary age, he had the choice of remaining home educated or going to secondary school. He choose to continue to be home educated. He had no problems with social skills, and the college thought very highly of him and he gets on exceptionally well with his peers.
Going back to the thread, what I don't agree with is the parents forcing their children to be home educated, in the post by Seamus, the son wanted to be home educated which is in his best interests meaning he is more enthusiastic. However, in my opinion, it should be the students choice on whether they want to be home educated or not.
1
reply
In my experience of things electrical and mechanical engineers are VERY behind the curve when it comes to home education. Many of them that I have met were completely unaware that home education is legal and a few are even astounded that home education is legal.
Home educated children don't seem to go into traditional science and engineering careers although some go into computing, IT, and mathematics or accountancy careers.
Home educated children don't seem to go into traditional science and engineering careers although some go into computing, IT, and mathematics or accountancy careers.
0
reply
Report
#17
I agree. Grandson is doing IT and Media at college. We didn't do much of that when I was home educating him, but he was educated by the whole family, and not just me. My youngest son is a senior software engineer for a large company and he has encouraged him a lot.
0
reply
Something to take into account is that computing, software development, and IT careers do not build on a traditional secondary school education. They are technically open to anybody who can master primary school level English and mathematics. There are plenty of people who have successful computing careers that failed badly at or dropped out of secondary school. In contrast, traditional science and engineering careers build on the knowledge of secondary school level mathematics and science. This probably explains why very few people from the electrical and mechanical engineering communities are home educated and they all succeeded in mathematics and science / physics at school.
0
reply
Report
#19
School is basically soft prison. The only reason we have it is for state indoctrination/programming. What could be more natural than the parents educating the child?
0
reply
Report
#20
I have only known a couple, who then went to secondary school. No idea what happened to both of them. One I had sympathy for because I thought her dad was a strange man.
0
reply
X
Quick Reply
