And you think UKIP shares that culture?(Original post by Banneduser)
I am a management consultant, professional investor, father of two young children a and resident of Surrey who is interested in philosophy, ideas and challenging orthodoxies.
My culture is represented by the pioneering spirit and consciousness that built the west, our spirit and essence and questioning the left wing ideas and ideals of always seeking the other rather than the self that is present in the west today.
Posted from TSR Mobile
x Turn on thread page Beta
Conservatism is the New Counterculture™ watch
- 22-07-2017 17:23
- 23-07-2017 20:33
(Original post by User10001)
- 23-07-2017 23:18
We might have a Conservative government but liberals and the left have been winning the culture wars. Look at entertainment and media and you can see who has been winning. There is a new conservative counterculture now.
i) Firstly, the idea of "culture wars" is something of a conservative invention. Also, it's a framing that more or less makes it essentially impossible for the conservative side to ever 'win' a culture war. Because the moment it becomes a "war", you have reached the point whether there are two equal sides, or thereabouts, at which point the liberals/reformers/whatever you want to call them have already won the argument that their way is just as valid as the conservative way. Conservatives can only 'win', by preventing the issue from getting far enough to become a "culture war" in the first place.
Take gay marriage in the US as an illustrative example. Before it was legalised in any state, and even after the first one or two states, it could be seen as a passing fad, or a particular quirk unique to one or two states. It hadn't really reached "war" point yet. Once it got beyond that, however, conservatives started to really get bothered about it, but by then it was too late - the precedent that gay marriage was just as valid as straight marriage had essentially been set by then.
ii) Conservatism, in the classical sense of Edmund Burke or even William Buckley, is characterised by heavy caution and scepticism towards change, particularly radical change. It is as pro-establishment and pro-status quo an ideology as it is possible to have. In this sense, "conservative counterculture" is inherently an oxymoron.
iii) But let's forget that for a moment, as of course "conservatism" in the US and to a lesser extent the UK is no longer the classical conservatism outlined above, but a more concrete ideology/movement organised around more specific goals, rather than simple preservation and conservation of what is.
Let's also, for the sake of argument, accept the claims of that ideology that liberals/progressives/lefties/whoever have been completely victorious in all cultural issues for the past few decades, to the point where their initial counterculture is now the dominant culture.
But even if this is the case, it doesn't suddenly make the old, overthrown culture now becomes "counterculture", just as the French Revolution did not make absolute monarchy and feudalism "revolutionary". Rather, they became reactionary.Which, for the most part, is what American "conservatives" can be aptly described as.Tagged:Last edited by anarchism101; 23-07-2017 at 23:21.
- 23-07-2017 23:55
- 24-07-2017 00:00
(Original post by Castro Saint)
- 24-07-2017 01:46
You are living in a country governed by "The Conservative Party"
+ the BBC is not as left leaning as you make it out to be either. At all.
As a fairly moderate conservative on most counts i must admit that even i have sympathy for the alt-right and many of their positions.
(Original post by Quantex)
- 24-07-2017 01:55
No it is not.
However there are some on the modern right who have borrowed heavily from SJWs. They see themselves as special snowflakes (broflakes?). They love playing the victim. They like their identity politics. They are easily offended. Etc. You see it all the time when they prattle on about feminists/cultural Marxists/whatever victimising them because they are white males. It is even more comical when they start blaming others for their own lack of sexual success.
Then there is their love of conspiracy theories and selective cherry picking to fit the world they've constructed while sitting in their mother's basements.
Really they just need to grow a pair of balls and start taking vitamin D supplements.
- 24-07-2017 01:58
"Conservativism is the new counterculture"
Do you class Rees-Mogg appreciation cults as a counterculture?