Book to compare to The Great Gatsby

3

Basically for English Literature A2 our class were told we were to study The Colour Purple and The Secret Life of Bees and then analyse / compare them in an essay for our coursework. However, I feel like although I like the books I am not interested in them enough to form a decent essay. So I suggested to my teacher that I analyse The Great Gatsby along with another book and alongs that book is post-2000 and classed as a novel and not teen fiction I will be allowed so I desperately need some ideas!!

Reply 1

EstelOfTheEyrie

19

Original post

by MadCow_

Basically for English Literature A2 our class were told we were to study The Colour Purple and The Secret Life of Bees and then analyse / compare them in an essay for our coursework. However, I feel like although I like the books I am not interested in them enough to form a decent essay. So I suggested to my teacher that I analyse The Great Gatsby along with another book and alongs that book is post-2000 and classed as a novel and not teen fiction I will be allowed so I desperately need some ideas!!

Have you had a think about what themes you might want to compare with Gatsby? As this can give some indiction for other novels.

Reply 2

Neddie001

15

Think about books that in the same genre/time period aka the American Dream period and then pick on that tackles similar themes (probs greed, the naivety of youth, money and New America and its unrealistic optimism I am guessing here) but in different ways. This comparison would allow for a better essay

Reply 3

ArcticPenguin

4

For my A2 exam we studied Gatsby alongside The Grapes of Wrath- it's interesting to compare and contrast The Great Depression and The Boom from a contextual viewpoint. However, The Grapes of Wrath is a VERY tedious read and so I don't recommend it for that reason, I found it quite boring! Books that were suggested for wider reading by OCR to compare and contrast with Gatsby were Native Son and A Farewell to Arms to name a couple. I think comparing a 1920's novel with a 1930's one would make an interesting essay for both you, research wise, and the reader! I don't know what other novels Steinbeck has produced, he may be a good author to use (just don't do Of Mice and Men, for obvious reasons)! :smile:

Reply 4

connormc199

15

Original post

by MadCow_

Basically for English Literature A2 our class were told we were to study The Colour Purple and The Secret Life of Bees and then analyse / compare them in an essay for our coursework. However, I feel like although I like the books I am not interested in them enough to form a decent essay. So I suggested to my teacher that I analyse The Great Gatsby along with another book and alongs that book is post-2000 and classed as a novel and not teen fiction I will be allowed so I desperately need some ideas!!

CCEA exam board? If so i'm considering doing the exact same! I'm facing the same dilemma :frown:

The only strict requirement is that one of the texts MUST have been written/published AFTER THE YEAR 2000

Reply 5

MadCow_

OP

3

Original post

by connormc199

CCEA exam board? If so i'm considering doing the exact same! I'm facing the same dilemma :frown:

The only strict requirement is that one of the texts MUST have been written/published AFTER THE YEAR 2000

WJEC exam board but that's the sam requirement as mine, one has to be pre 2000 and the other HAS to be after 2000! Think I've settled on doing Atonement alongside the Great Gatsby using links of perception and emotion for the essay, hope that's some help to you!!

Reply 6

connormc199

15

Aw sweet! What theme are you doing?
Gatsby was listed under American Culture in our Spec and i didnt want to dystopian so i need to find an alternative book to compare to gatsby! Glad you found a text that was feasible, my struggle continues :P

Reply 7

MadCow_

OP

3

Probably perception including like class and how people's own emotions and experiences influence how they interpret certain events (like the drama with Gatsby, Daisy and Tom compared to Brionys lies in Atonement) was only planning on mentioning the American culture for the context marks but not heavily but aw hope you find a book soon!

Reply 8

LeapingLucy

19

Original post

by MadCow_

WJEC exam board but that's the sam requirement as mine, one has to be pre 2000 and the other HAS to be after 2000! Think I've settled on doing Atonement alongside the Great Gatsby using links of perception and emotion for the essay, hope that's some help to you!!

That's a great idea to use Atonement - there are great similarities. You've also got the link in there of certain characters (Tom, Daisy, Briony) destroying the lives of those around them (Myrtle, Gatsby, Cecilia, Robbie), out of jealousy or just boredom.

I love this line:
''They were careless people, Tom and Daisy- they smashed up things and creatures and then retreated back into their money or their vast carelessness or whatever it was that kept them together, and let other people clean up the mess they had made.''

I suppose the difference is that Briony ultimately has a conscience and tries to fix the damage she's caused, whereas Tom and Daisy disappear, and Daisy doesn't even come to Gatsby's funeral.

(edited 8 years ago)

Reply 9

math42

20

Daisy Miller.

Reply 10

CityOfTroy

2

This thread actually helped me choose my books for my own Eng Lit A-Level Coursework! Thanks~

Reply 11

CityOfTroy

2

Original post

by MadCow_

WJEC exam board but that's the sam requirement as mine, one has to be pre 2000 and the other HAS to be after 2000! Think I've settled on doing Atonement alongside the Great Gatsby using links of perception and emotion for the essay, hope that's some help to you!!

Hey, how did it go? I want to do the same!

Reply 12

littlenicky61

2

Old thread but as there’s recent activity will comment - my daughter did Great Gatsby and Death of a Salesman for the coursework essay which worked really well

Reply 13

Ameliejasmine

10

Original post

by MadCow_

Basically for English Literature A2 our class were told we were to study The Colour Purple and The Secret Life of Bees and then analyse / compare them in an essay for our coursework. However, I feel like although I like the books I am not interested in them enough to form a decent essay. So I suggested to my teacher that I analyse The Great Gatsby along with another book and alongs that book is post-2000 and classed as a novel and not teen fiction I will be allowed so I desperately need some ideas!!

You could do something about the American dream with 'The Grapes of Wrath', 'The Catcher in the Rye' or 'Another Country' (James Baldwin). You could also look at the role of the go-between in relationships - comparing Gatsby with 'Emma'

Book to compare to The Great Gatsby

Quick Reply

Related discussions

Articles for you

How The Student Room is moderated