(Original post by kikas)
To be honest I think it´sa little of both: he wanted to be associated with voldie, because he was the "biggest" wizard, but then he realised that he shoulnd't assiciated with him!...that it's just my tought!
Maybe he just did that to prove that he could be more "powerful", you know, because he wasn't as good as his friends...but then again, he brethraid then...he got then killed! Do you think he did that for pure revenge? And if it was, why would he do it for revenge...I mean, what did sirius or lupin or james do to deserv what peter did?
x
Turn on thread page Beta
-
- Follow
- 2141
- 15-10-2003 18:57
-
- Follow
- 2142
- 15-10-2003 19:29
(Original post by kikas)
Maybe he just did that to prove that he could be more "powerful", you know, because he wasn't as good as his friends...but then again, he brethraid then...he got then killed! Do you think he did that for pure revenge? And if it was, why would he do it for revenge...I mean, what did sirius or lupin or james do to deserv what peter did?
I think Harry ultimately will let his heart lead him. I know it's a golden lining thing, but he keeps showing that side of himself that wants to protect and be a hero (just like Lily wanted to protect Snape from James). -
- Follow
- 2143
- 15-10-2003 20:08
I say it all the time but I htink there is something special about being "A Potter" - and thats how Peter was able to betray them- he was looking at the "thing" not his friends- I doubt he was enchanted- from all the descriptions it seems like he's always stuck onto people who are more powerful than he is- long before he joined the Death Eaters-
kikas I'm sooo sorry you haven't gotten book 5 yet! Supposedly rumor has it book six hits here Nov 2004, but I tend to think thats a little bit of wishful thinking- they'll save the super sales for the Christmas season- my guess is late Nov 2004- whenever it is will be evenly between Movie 3 and Movie 4- -
Xenon
- Follow
- 2 followers
- 1 badge
- Send a private message to Xenon
- Thread Starter
Offline1ReputationRep:- Follow
- 2144
- 15-10-2003 20:25
Hey Kikas. Have you already got book 5, even if it hasn't come out there yet? Because there must be loads of spoilers here, so I hope that you have already read it.
Also, to be twins, I think that sometimes you can look pretty different, as not all twins are identical. I hope that either Peunia or Dumbledore decide to show Harry the letter which Dumblydore sent to Petunia. Hopefully that would give quite a lot of information.
I reckon that Wormtail was a coward, but I agree that maybe he wanted to join Voldie to prove that he could actually do something for himself, and that he wasn't just a tagalong. -
- Follow
- 2145
- 15-10-2003 20:45
(Original post by Xenon)
Hey Kikas. Have you already got book 5, even if it hasn't come out there yet? Because there must be loads of spoilers here, so I hope that you have already read it.
Also, to be twins, I think that sometimes you can look pretty different, as not all twins are identical. I hope that either Peunia or Dumbledore decide to show Harry the letter which Dumblydore sent to Petunia. Hopefully that would give quite a lot of information.
I reckon that Wormtail was a coward, but I agree that maybe he wanted to join Voldie to prove that he could actually do something for himself, and that he wasn't just a tagalong. -
- Follow
- 2146
- 15-10-2003 20:55
I have a question...
What is the difference between the British version and the American version? Besides the cover. -
loftx
- Follow
- 1 follower
- 0 badges
- Send a private message to loftx
- Visit loftx's homepage!
Offline0ReputationRep:- Follow
- 2147
- 15-10-2003 21:28
-
- Follow
- 2148
- 15-10-2003 21:29
wow-look at this HP thread!!
-
- Follow
- 2149
- 15-10-2003 21:41
(Original post by Brooklyn)
I say it all the time but I htink there is something special about being "A Potter" - and thats how Peter was able to betray them- he was looking at the "thing" not his friends- I doubt he was enchanted- from all the descriptions it seems like he's always stuck onto people who are more powerful than he is- long before he joined the Death Eaters-
kikas I'm sooo sorry you haven't gotten book 5 yet! Supposedly rumor has it book six hits here Nov 2004, but I tend to think thats a little bit of wishful thinking- they'll save the super sales for the Christmas season- my guess is late Nov 2004- whenever it is will be evenly between Movie 3 and Movie 4-
Hey...I agree, but if peter tought thay way then is notting but a liar...good how I hate him...don't you think he was better of dead...I just wishe harry dind't let him go...I mean harry couldn't kill him, even afther he found out what peter did to his parent's...but before he was about to kill sirius for the same reason(bethraing his parent's)!
He would kill sirius but I just don't get it why didn't he have so much anger about peter??'
well...ok....not dead, but at least in prision... maybe in the next book peter will go to jail...
Now I remenber, was sirius name clear...clean??
Oh, and Brooklyn I've already read the book, but it had to be in english...but I understund a lot of things...the problem was only with the details!!lol...but thank's for your preoccupation...now I'm just waiting for the book in portuguese so I can read it again, but this time understand everything!!! -
- Follow
- 2150
- 15-10-2003 21:42
(Original post by kikas)
Hey...I agree, but if peter tought thay way then is notting but a liar...good how I hate him...don't you think he was better of dead...I just wishe harry dind't let him go...I mean harry couldn't kill him, even afther he found out what peter did to his parent's...but before he was about to kill sirius for the same reason(bethraing his parent's)!
He would kill sirius but I just don't get it why didn't he have so much anger about peter??'
well...ok....not dead, but at least in prision... maybe in the next book peter will go to jail...
Now I remenber, was sirius name clear...clean??
Oh, and Brooklyn I've already read the book, but it had to be in english...but I understund a lot of things...the problem was only with the details!!lol...but thank's for your preoccupation...now I'm just waiting for the book in portuguese so I can read it again, but this time understand everything!!! -
- Follow
- 2151
- 15-10-2003 21:49
(Original post by Xenon)
Hey Kikas. Have you already got book 5, even if it hasn't come out there yet? Because there must be loads of spoilers here, so I hope that you have already read it.
Also, to be twins, I think that sometimes you can look pretty different, as not all twins are identical. I hope that either Peunia or Dumbledore decide to show Harry the letter which Dumblydore sent to Petunia. Hopefully that would give quite a lot of information.
I reckon that Wormtail was a coward, but I agree that maybe he wanted to join Voldie to prove that he could actually do something for himself, and that he wasn't just a tagalong.
I have some family(you can say that...long time friends), living in england...and e few moths ago I implore then to get me the book...and they did...it took me the all of the summer vacations...but it was wortgh...As you see, it takes a realy long time to read the book in my langue...the book was at sale in june...there in england (I think)...here it's only coming out in 2 weeks...that's why I asked for my friends back in england to bring me the book...I couldn't wait that long!!!!
Isn't petunia older than lily???? -
- Follow
- 2152
- 15-10-2003 21:51
(Original post by Peter The Great)
And that's a game.The marlins won it. Sorry SF.
-
- Follow
- 2153
- 15-10-2003 21:52
Another year!!! Oh my good...We have to wait onther year to read the book...snif, snif...that's a realy long time.
But if I think about it...it's better then 2 years!!! -
- Follow
- 2154
- 15-10-2003 21:52
(Original post by Unregistered)
hahahah sucks for Cubs fans!!! -
- Follow
- 2155
- 15-10-2003 21:53
(Original post by kikas)
I have some family(you can say that...long time friends), living in england...and e few moths ago I implore then to get me the book...and they did...it took me the all of the summer vacations...but it was wortgh...As you see, it takes a realy long time to read the book in my langue...the book was at sale in june...there in england (I think)...here it's only coming out in 2 weeks...that's why I asked for my friends back in england to bring me the book...I couldn't wait that long!!!!
Isn't petunia older than lily???? -
- Follow
- 2156
- 15-10-2003 22:03
(Original post by leroylina)
there´s a lot about petunia we don´t know and it is a little weird that she kept harry. maybe she didn´t hate lily as much as we think or she felt obligated to kept harry because all the horrible things dhe did to lily.
maybe she couldn´t bring herself to leave harry in an orphanage because she knew that harry would´ve been in mortal danger. -
- Follow
- 2157
- 15-10-2003 22:06
(Original post by kikas)
A squib ins't someone who know's about wizard world!!
well if it his, than petunia is a squib, she has to know a lot of things of the "other" world...specialy afther to took harry! now a days, she probably konws something...
when she got the letter from dumbledore 15 yeard ago, dumbledore must of have told her something about his world...then she is a squib, right???
I hope you all understund!!!
***
Wonder how petunia really knew about azkaban, i mean it's not likely she would want to even talk about it, yet she mentions it infront of vernan. -
- Follow
- 2158
- 15-10-2003 22:08
(Original post by kcoverst)
Do you think then that Peter was spellbound by Voldie and when he realized what he had done he tried to hide. That was when Sirius found him. Or do you think he knew what he was doing and just wanted to be with associated with the most powerful wizard there was at the time? -
- Follow
- 2159
- 15-10-2003 22:10
(Original post by CR3)
on a further note..would you mind starting your own Critizism of Harry Potter thread...instead of wasting space on this *cough* record breaking*cough* thread
CR -
- Follow
- 2160
- 15-10-2003 22:14
(Original post by SiriusFan)
No, a squib kniows aboutt he magic world. Look at mrs. fig! she saw the dementors, and filch is a squib, and he works there.
Wonder how petunia really knew about azkaban, i mean it's not likely she would want to even talk about it, yet she mentions it infront of vernan.
I think Petunia knows a lot more then she "shows"!!! But she never want's to talk about the wizars world...hum..I would like to know about that!
there is a lot to explian about that...
In the past she must've said something about the wizard world to vernon, because, remenber when they don't want to talk about that...if they don't wont to talk, it's because they do know something (hope you undertstand...it's a little confused).
About lily being headgirl...don't know-sorry!
Turn on thread page Beta
Related discussions:
- Doctor Who - Discussion Thread III (no untagged future ...
- The Harry Potter Society III
- Game of Thrones- Tv Show- Absolutely no future book spoiler ...
- Game of Thrones- Tv Show- Absolutely no future book spoiler ...
- 15 August 2013 A-Level results: Discussion thread - results ...
- Suggest me a good book to read
- Suggest me a good book to read
- Count to 100 before a Mod, Supermod or Admin posts thread ...
- What Book Are You Reading Now? Mk II
- What Book Are You Reading Now? Mk II
TSR Support Team
We have a brilliant team of more than 60 Support Team members looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.
This forum is supported by:
Updated: January 4, 2007
Share this discussion:
Tweet