Turn on thread page Beta
    • Thread Starter
    Offline

    11
    ReputationRep:
    36) An electronic circuit contains three light bulbs, X, Y and Z, which are each either on or off at
    any particular time. It is known that if bulb X is off or bulb Y is on, then bulb Z is on.
    Which one of these statements necessarily follows from this?

    A If bulb Z is on, then bulb X is off or bulb Y is on.
    B If bulb Z is on, then bulb X is on and bulb Y is off.
    C If bulb Z is on, then bulb X is on or bulb Y is on.
    D If bulb Z is off, then bulb X is off and bulb Y is off.
    E If bulb Z is off, then bulb X is on OR bulb Y is off.
    F If bulb Z is off, then bulb X is on and bulb Y is on.

    The answer is E yet I feel that the 'OR' needs to be an 'AND'
    Why is E correct?
    •  Official Rep
    Offline

    11
    ReputationRep:
     Official Rep
    (Original post by dontrevisefail)
    36) An electronic circuit contains three light bulbs, X, Y and Z, which are each either on or off at
    any particular time. It is known that if bulb X is off or bulb Y is on, then bulb Z is on.
    Which one of these statements necessarily follows from this?

    A If bulb Z is on, then bulb X is off or bulb Y is on.
    B If bulb Z is on, then bulb X is on and bulb Y is off.
    C If bulb Z is on, then bulb X is on or bulb Y is on.
    D If bulb Z is off, then bulb X is off and bulb Y is off.
    E If bulb Z is off, then bulb X is on OR bulb Y is off.
    F If bulb Z is off, then bulb X is on and bulb Y is on.

    The answer is E yet I feel that the 'OR' needs to be an 'AND'
    Why is E correct?
    Hi dontrevisefail


    Wow this is hurting my head! haha

    I feel that E is correct with 'or' not 'and' as in the statement is doesn't explicitly say that when bulb x is off y is also on, just that when one of them is, bulb z is on.

    Initially I was drawn to A being the correct answer, but I guess that it is just the original statement in a different order, and as the new statement must 'follow from this' it would make sense that is it E as the state of bulb Z has changed from on to off.

    Does this make sense? It did in my head, haha!

    Matt - NTU PG TSR Rep
    • Thread Starter
    Offline

    11
    ReputationRep:
    (Original post by Postgraduate study at NTU)
    Hi dontrevisefail


    Wow this is hurting my head! haha

    I feel that E is correct with 'or' not 'and' as in the statement is doesn't explicitly say that when bulb x is off y is also on, just that when one of them is, bulb z is on.

    Initially I was drawn to A being the correct answer, but I guess that it is just the original statement in a different order, and as the new statement must 'follow from this' it would make sense that is it E as the state of bulb Z has changed from on to off.

    Does this make sense? It did in my head, haha!

    Matt - NTU PG TSR Rep
    Thanks Matt
    •  Official Rep
    Offline

    11
    ReputationRep:
     Official Rep
    (Original post by dontrevisefail)
    Thanks Matt
    Not a problem dontrevisefail!

    What's this for if you don't mind me asking?

    Matt
    • Thread Starter
    Offline

    11
    ReputationRep:
    It's for the Cambridge economics entrance exam(ECAA)
    Online

    18
    ReputationRep:
    (Original post by dontrevisefail)
    36) An electronic circuit contains three light bulbs, X, Y and Z, which are each either on or off at
    any particular time. It is known that if bulb X is off or bulb Y is on, then bulb Z is on.
    Which one of these statements necessarily follows from this?

    A If bulb Z is on, then bulb X is off or bulb Y is on.
    B If bulb Z is on, then bulb X is on and bulb Y is off.
    C If bulb Z is on, then bulb X is on or bulb Y is on.
    D If bulb Z is off, then bulb X is off and bulb Y is off.
    E If bulb Z is off, then bulb X is on OR bulb Y is off.
    F If bulb Z is off, then bulb X is on and bulb Y is on.

    The answer is E yet I feel that the 'OR' needs to be an 'AND'
    Why is E correct?
    When you have a statement "if P then Q", then there's a logically equivalent statement called the contrapositive: "If (not Q), then (not P)".

    Here, the contrapositive is "If {bulb Z is off}, then {bulb X is on and bulb Y is off}. " (which I believe is what you deduced).

    So this statement does logically follow from what they give you, however it isn't on the list of options.

    but: {bulb X is on and bulb Y is off} certainly does imply {bulb X is on or bulb Y is off}.

    So the statement also implies E. E is a weaker condition than what could be deduced, but it still holds.
    • Thread Starter
    Offline

    11
    ReputationRep:
    Thanks DFranklin, I get it now. How could I practice these?
    (Original post by DFranklin)
    When you have a statement "if P then Q", then there's a logically equivalent statement called the contrapositive: "If (not Q), then (not P)".

    Here, the contrapositive is "If {bulb Z is off}, then {bulb X is on and bulb Y is off}. " (which I believe is what you deduced).

    So this statement does logically follow from what they give you, however it isn't on the list of options.

    but: {bulb X is on and bulb Y is off} certainly does imply {bulb X is on or bulb Y is off}.

    So the statement also implies E. E is a weaker condition than what could be deduced, but it still holds.
 
 
 
Poll
“Yanny” or “Laurel”
Help with your A-levels

All the essentials

The adventure begins mug

Student life: what to expect

What it's really like going to uni

Rosette

Essay expert

Learn to write like a pro with our ultimate essay guide.

Uni match

Uni match

Our tool will help you find the perfect course for you

Study planner

Create a study plan

Get your head around what you need to do and when with the study planner tool.

Study planner

Resources by subject

Everything from mind maps to class notes.

Hands typing

Degrees without fees

Discover more about degree-level apprenticeships.

A student doing homework

Study tips from A* students

Students who got top grades in their A-levels share their secrets

Study help links and info

Can you help? Study help unanswered threadsRules and posting guidelines

Groups associated with this forum:

View associated groups

The Student Room, Get Revising and Marked by Teachers are trading names of The Student Room Group Ltd.

Register Number: 04666380 (England and Wales), VAT No. 806 8067 22 Registered Office: International House, Queens Road, Brighton, BN1 3XE

Write a reply...
Reply
Hide
Reputation gems: You get these gems as you gain rep from other members for making good contributions and giving helpful advice.