- Forums
###### Isaac physics help - latent heat.

Watch

6 years ago

Hi,

I’ve been stuck on this question for a bit now.

A mass of 0.35kg ice at -15∘C is lowered into an insulated beaker containing water at 59∘C

. What is the minimum mass of water at this temperature needed in the beaker to achieve a final temperature of 0.0∘C?

From previous parts of the question I worked out that it required 10657.5J to heat the ice to 0 degrees, it then required an additional 117250J to melt the ice.

I think I need to use Q=mc delta T with the smallest value of Q that I can but I’m not sure what value of Q I need as I tried 10657.5 and got a mass of 0.043kg but it said that although that results in 0degrees it isn’t the smallest mass.

Any help would be much appreciated

I’ve been stuck on this question for a bit now.

A mass of 0.35kg ice at -15∘C is lowered into an insulated beaker containing water at 59∘C

. What is the minimum mass of water at this temperature needed in the beaker to achieve a final temperature of 0.0∘C?

From previous parts of the question I worked out that it required 10657.5J to heat the ice to 0 degrees, it then required an additional 117250J to melt the ice.

I think I need to use Q=mc delta T with the smallest value of Q that I can but I’m not sure what value of Q I need as I tried 10657.5 and got a mass of 0.043kg but it said that although that results in 0degrees it isn’t the smallest mass.

Any help would be much appreciated

Original post by Snoozinghamster

Hi,

I’ve been stuck on this question for a bit now.

A mass of 0.35kg ice at -15∘C is lowered into an insulated beaker containing water at 59∘C

. What is the minimum mass of water at this temperature needed in the beaker to achieve a final temperature of 0.0∘C?

From previous parts of the question I worked out that it required 10657.5J to heat the ice to 0 degrees, it then required an additional 117250J to melt the ice.

I think I need to use Q=mc delta T with the smallest value of Q that I can but I’m not sure what value of Q I need as I tried 10657.5 and got a mass of 0.043kg but it said that although that results in 0degrees it isn’t the smallest mass.

Any help would be much appreciated

I’ve been stuck on this question for a bit now.

A mass of 0.35kg ice at -15∘C is lowered into an insulated beaker containing water at 59∘C

. What is the minimum mass of water at this temperature needed in the beaker to achieve a final temperature of 0.0∘C?

From previous parts of the question I worked out that it required 10657.5J to heat the ice to 0 degrees, it then required an additional 117250J to melt the ice.

I think I need to use Q=mc delta T with the smallest value of Q that I can but I’m not sure what value of Q I need as I tried 10657.5 and got a mass of 0.043kg but it said that although that results in 0degrees it isn’t the smallest mass.

Any help would be much appreciated

There is no description of the final state of matter in the beaker... I guess you don't need to consider the energy used to melt the ice - a beaker containing ice at 0.0 degrees is sufficient to answer the question.

Reply 2

6 years ago

Original post by Joinedup

There is no description of the final state of matter in the beaker... I guess you don't need to consider the energy used to melt the ice - a beaker containing ice at 0.0 degrees is sufficient to answer the question.

That’s what I thought, the values I used came from just the energy needed to heat the ice to 0 degrees so I have 0 degree ice in 0 degrees water.

The hint at the end has said think about the energy transferred as ice goes to water and vice Versa. But I can’t think of any way of using that info.

Thanks again

Original post by Snoozinghamster

Hi,

I’ve been stuck on this question for a bit now.

A mass of 0.35kg ice at -15∘C is lowered into an insulated beaker containing water at 59∘C

. What is the minimum mass of water at this temperature needed in the beaker to achieve a final temperature of 0.0∘C?

From previous parts of the question I worked out that it required 10657.5J to heat the ice to 0 degrees, it then required an additional 117250J to melt the ice.

I think I need to use Q=mc delta T with the smallest value of Q that I can but I’m not sure what value of Q I need as I tried 10657.5 and got a mass of 0.043kg but it said that although that results in 0degrees it isn’t the smallest mass.

Any help would be much appreciated

I’ve been stuck on this question for a bit now.

A mass of 0.35kg ice at -15∘C is lowered into an insulated beaker containing water at 59∘C

. What is the minimum mass of water at this temperature needed in the beaker to achieve a final temperature of 0.0∘C?

From previous parts of the question I worked out that it required 10657.5J to heat the ice to 0 degrees, it then required an additional 117250J to melt the ice.

I think I need to use Q=mc delta T with the smallest value of Q that I can but I’m not sure what value of Q I need as I tried 10657.5 and got a mass of 0.043kg but it said that although that results in 0degrees it isn’t the smallest mass.

Any help would be much appreciated

Figured it out?

Reply 4

5 years ago

Original post by I'msoPi

Figured it out?

Yeh, in the end my teacher proudly told me she had managed all but one question, that question🤦*♀️ but then we had the sudden realisation that the hot water turned into ice as that released more energy. From there it was ok.

Edit: and yes, it took 7 months for us to solve it!

(edited 5 years ago)

Original post by Snoozinghamster

Yeh, in the end my teacher proudly told me she had managed all but one question, that question🤦*♀️ but then we had the sudden realisation that the hot water turned into ice as that released more energy. From there it was ok.

Edit: and yes, it took 7 months for us to solve it!

Edit: and yes, it took 7 months for us to solve it!

Ahaha can't believe you responded even though this was from months ago. I'm doing that question now so lemme give it another crack knowing that it turns to ice

Reply 6

5 years ago

Original post by I'msoPi

Ahaha can't believe you responded even though this was from months ago. I'm doing that question now so lemme give it another crack knowing that it turns to ice

Notifications appear when I’m waiting for a stream to start, made me laugh remembering the annoyance that was this question!

Oh and good luck with it.

(edited 5 years ago)

Original post by Snoozinghamster

Notifications appear when I’m waiting for a stream to start, made me laugh remembering the annoyance that was this question!

Oh and good luck with it.

Oh and good luck with it.

Stream? ergh my brain is actually too frazzled at this point to complete this question lol

Reply 8

5 years ago

Original post by I'msoPi

Stream? ergh my brain is actually too frazzled at this point to complete this question lol

Stream-Show on twitch someone gaming

If you try again and It doesn’t work let me know and I’ll try and explain it better

Original post by Snoozinghamster

Stream-Show on twitch someone gaming

If you try again and It doesn’t work let me know and I’ll try and explain it better

If you try again and It doesn’t work let me know and I’ll try and explain it better

Ah yeah I thought it was something on twitch. Thermal physics is killing me softly, would you mind explaining it

Reply 10

5 years ago

Original post by I'msoPi

Ah yeah I thought it was something on twitch. Thermal physics is killing me softly, would you mind explaining it

I can certainly try.

When ice melts into water that takes energy, when the same mass of water freezes that releases the same amount of energy.

So here we have ice at a cold temperature so we need to raise it up to 0 degrees, we can work out how much energy is needed by Q=mc \delta T. This is the energy we need.

The water is at 59 degrees so we need to work out how much energy is released in cooling it to zero. (This will be in terms of m)

Then the bit that I didn’t know to do.

You need to work out the energy released in freezing the water using the latent heat of fusion times mass.

The energy needed to warm the ice = the total energy released.

From here you just rearrange to find m.

Hoops that helps

Original post by Snoozinghamster

I can certainly try.

When ice melts into water that takes energy, when the same mass of water freezes that releases the same amount of energy.

So here we have ice at a cold temperature so we need to raise it up to 0 degrees, we can work out how much energy is needed by Q=mc \delta T. This is the energy we need.

The water is at 59 degrees so we need to work out how much energy is released in cooling it to zero. (This will be in terms of m)

Then the bit that I didn’t know to do.

You need to work out the energy released in freezing the water using the latent heat of fusion times mass.

The energy needed to warm the ice = the total energy released.

From here you just rearrange to find m.

Hoops that helps

When ice melts into water that takes energy, when the same mass of water freezes that releases the same amount of energy.

So here we have ice at a cold temperature so we need to raise it up to 0 degrees, we can work out how much energy is needed by Q=mc \delta T. This is the energy we need.

The water is at 59 degrees so we need to work out how much energy is released in cooling it to zero. (This will be in terms of m)

Then the bit that I didn’t know to do.

You need to work out the energy released in freezing the water using the latent heat of fusion times mass.

The energy needed to warm the ice = the total energy released.

From here you just rearrange to find m.

Hoops that helps

Yay I just got it now thanks!! Although I don't fully understand why I didn't have to use the energy required to melt the ice (the latent heat one) but i'm assuming it's just because it doesn't actually melt?

Reply 12

5 years ago

Original post by I'msoPi

Yay I just got it now thanks!! Although I don't fully understand why I didn't have to use the energy required to melt the ice (the latent heat one) but i'm assuming it's just because it doesn't actually melt?

Yeh the ice doesn’t melt as we want the minimum energy required to get it to 0 degrees and it would require additional energy to melt the ice

Original post by Snoozinghamster

Yeh the ice doesn’t melt as we want the minimum energy required to get it to 0 degrees and it would require additional energy to melt the ice

Ahhhh okay thanks again for the help. I'm in a good mood now that this is finished lol

Reply 14

3 years ago

minimum is0.018kg0.35*15*2030=10657.5Answer/(59*4180 3.35*10^5)=0.018

Reply 15

3 years ago

can you help me with the maximum mass?

Reply 16

3 years ago

I am not sure how I did it but I was also stuck on this question for ages.

For the MAXIMUM mass:

I found the energy needed for ice to melt (Q = m*c*deltaT) = 10675.5J

Then I found the latent heat of fusion for the ice to melt fully (Q = m*l) and added those values together for the total amount of energy required to melt the ice. (I think that is what it is but I did it and it seemed to work)

For the water I did the same thing as before with the minimum mass, work out how much energy is released in cooling it to zero. (This will be in terms of m)

But I didn't work out the energy released in freezing the water (the latent heat).

As before the energy needed to warm the ice = the total energy released.

And then rearrange for m.

Sorry I couldn't explain how or why this gets the correct answer.

For the MAXIMUM mass:

I found the energy needed for ice to melt (Q = m*c*deltaT) = 10675.5J

Then I found the latent heat of fusion for the ice to melt fully (Q = m*l) and added those values together for the total amount of energy required to melt the ice. (I think that is what it is but I did it and it seemed to work)

For the water I did the same thing as before with the minimum mass, work out how much energy is released in cooling it to zero. (This will be in terms of m)

But I didn't work out the energy released in freezing the water (the latent heat).

As before the energy needed to warm the ice = the total energy released.

And then rearrange for m.

Sorry I couldn't explain how or why this gets the correct answer.

(edited 3 years ago)

Reply 17

1 year ago

To find the minimum mass of water for the mixture to reach zero:

(energy needed to cool water from 59°C to 0°C) + (energy released in freezing this water) = (energy to heat the ice from -15°C to 0°C)

This forms the equation:

(m*4180*59) + (m*3.35e5) = (0.35*2030*15)

rearrange for m:

m = (0.35*2030*15) / ((4180*59) + (3.35e5))

To find the maximum mass of water for the mixture to reach zero:

(energy needed to cool water from 59°C to 0°C) = (energy needed to heat ice from -15°C to 0°C) + (energy needed to melt the ice)

This forms the equation:

(m*4180*59) = (0.35*2030*15) + (0.35*3.35e5)

rearrange for m:

m = ((0.35*2030*15) + (0.35*3.35e5)) / (4180*59)

This thread helped me understand this question and this is my way of thinking about it.

(energy needed to cool water from 59°C to 0°C) + (energy released in freezing this water) = (energy to heat the ice from -15°C to 0°C)

This forms the equation:

(m*4180*59) + (m*3.35e5) = (0.35*2030*15)

rearrange for m:

m = (0.35*2030*15) / ((4180*59) + (3.35e5))

To find the maximum mass of water for the mixture to reach zero:

(energy needed to cool water from 59°C to 0°C) = (energy needed to heat ice from -15°C to 0°C) + (energy needed to melt the ice)

This forms the equation:

(m*4180*59) = (0.35*2030*15) + (0.35*3.35e5)

rearrange for m:

m = ((0.35*2030*15) + (0.35*3.35e5)) / (4180*59)

This thread helped me understand this question and this is my way of thinking about it.

(edited 1 year ago)

- Physics A-level: Thermodynamics
- isaac physics help
- Thermal Physics
- Physics gcse question need help
- Help with physics question on Specific heat capacity.
- physics
- Ocr A Gcse Physics Paper 1 j249/03 25 May 2023
- Physics Equation that I desperately need help with!!!
- What term should I use for boiling?
- physics latent heat helppp!
- The Specific Heat Capacity of Water
- Physics ice melting SHC and latent heat question
- Physics problem-solving difficult thermodynamics/ latent heat/ heat capacity question
- Physics exam help!!
- biology
- physics
- Specific Heat Capacity help G4.2 (a+b)
- A-level physics thermodynamics/ heat capacity/ latent heat difficult problem
- Reaction Feasibility- Gibbs Equation Question
- can somone pls help me with this gcse physics question :)

- Girls Vs. Boys (Part 46)
- EDF Grad Scheme - 2024
- I have a feminist tutor and she is pushing her opinions on the class?
- 2024 UK Drama School Auditions
- Official Dental Hygiene and Therapy (Oral Health Science) 2024 Entry Thread
- A level physics- Engineering topic question (4)
- UCL & KINGS COLLEGE LONDON Law offer 2024
- Can i improve for gcses???
- Vote for the February GYG Winner!
- ***Official Investment Banking Spring Week 2024 Thread***
- EPQ unrelated to what I want to study at uni - should I drop it?
- Creating The Future Of Our Dreams - Study23 GYG
- Official Cambridge Postgraduate Applicants 2024 Thread
- Supermarket Hurt/Heal Game
- Oxford Parents Association
- Medical Ultrasound (Sonography) BSc at Leeds uni
- I'm almost 21 and have never been in a relationship
- The Fast Food Restaurants Hurt/Heal game
- Durham Law 2024
- Arup Graduate Scheme 2023

- Official: University of Leicester A100 2024 Entry Applicants
- Physics A-level density exam Q help needed.Thanks.
- MPhil Advanced Computer Science Cambridge - 2024 Entry
- Hey there!
- IBM Futures Gap Year 2024
- has anyone received an unconditional offer for illustration in leeds art uni?
- What is the best uni in the midlands for biomedical
- gyg: My Villain Origin Story 💣👽🙌🧠
- sonography Leeds uni
- Social life at uni
- Mental Health Support Society XXI
- The daily Connections puzzle thread
- Official Oxford 2024 Postgraduate Applicants Thread
- NICS Staff Officer and Deputy Principal recruitment 2022 2023
- I finally want to be something so that I can stop accepting miserable standards.
- UCAS Extra 2024
- lnat results thread 2024
- essex or stirling? (politics/international politics)
- Official: Keele University A100 2024 Entry Applicants
- Capped module for mark at zero percent

- Isaac Senior Physics Challenge 2024
- Barometric Formula Isaac Physics
- Banked Tracks for Turning Isaac Physics
- How do I study for A Level physics â€˜Explainâ€™ questions?
- A-level Physics Study Group 2023-2024
- Isaac Physics A Vertical Throw
- Mature student studying physics
- Y12 Senior Physics Challenge 2024
- A level physics nuclear question (3)
- uk physics olympiad round 1 2023

- Isaac Senior Physics Challenge 2024
- Barometric Formula Isaac Physics
- Banked Tracks for Turning Isaac Physics
- How do I study for A Level physics â€˜Explainâ€™ questions?
- A-level Physics Study Group 2023-2024
- Isaac Physics A Vertical Throw
- Mature student studying physics
- Y12 Senior Physics Challenge 2024
- A level physics nuclear question (3)
- uk physics olympiad round 1 2023

The Student Room and The Uni Guide are both part of The Student Room Group.

© Copyright The Student Room 2024 all rights reserved

The Student Room and The Uni Guide are trading names of The Student Room Group Ltd.

Register Number: 04666380 (England and Wales), VAT No. 806 8067 22 Registered Office: Imperial House, 2nd Floor, 40-42 Queens Road, Brighton, East Sussex, BN1 3XB