Adam Jan
Badges: 5
Report Thread starter 3 years ago
Hi guys, I just wanted to ask if anyone knows any points and criticisms of Augustine's idea of the Original Sin? Thanks in advance
Badges: 17
Report 3 years ago
You can criticise the idea that we deserve punishment because of the sins of Adam and eve. Augustine claimed we deserved it because we were 'seminally present' in the 'loins of adam'. That's kinda ridiculous though.

We could defend Augustine by adopting a symbolic interpretation of 'The fall' episode. Perhaps we weren't exactly 'seminally present' but Adam and Eve were the 'archetypal' or 'prototypical' humans or perhaps they are just representing the idea of the human in the abstract - their sin then symbolises the sin that we, as inherently naturally sinful creatures, commit perhaps by our mere existence.

So although this involves getting rid of Augustine's taking of the bible literally, we can still reach the same conclusion he did by taking it symbolically: the conclusion being that this would justify the claim that we therefore deserve punishment and explain why we have a sinful nature.

You could also claim the garden of eden story never happened because we in fact evolved, but this can also be countered with the 'take the bible symbolically' counter.

You could also criticise by saying it's abominable to claim a child deserves cancer because of original sin. Though perhaps it's worth it if they get to heaven? Or is saying that even more abominable?

You decide!

Quick Reply

Attached files
Write a reply...
new posts
to top
My Feed

See more of what you like on
The Student Room

You can personalise what you see on TSR. Tell us a little about yourself to get started.


How do you prefer to get careers advice?

I like to speak to my friends and family (15)
I like to do my own research online using careers specific websites (87)
I like speaking to the careers advisors at school, college or uni (17)
I prefer to listen watch videos or listen to podcasts of people in my chosen career (13)
Something else (let us know in the thread) (3)

Watched Threads

View All