The Student Room Group

Did I mess up my LNAT?

Scroll to see replies

Reply 20

charmainecantyx
Was it a title that provoked you to take a stand on one side? I don't know even with them I tend to put a balanced argument (but perhaps favour one side by refuting the points I make for the side I don't agree with), but personal opinion and evaluation I tend to put in the conclusion.

Sounds like you've done fine though, if you're confident. I never leave exams very confident really, always think I've messed up somehow. Ironic that I thought this one went okay haha


Like I said in my post above I argued one side as in Law that's what you're set out to do, either for or against. :biggrin:

Reply 21

LawYah
Not in Law as you're supposed to argue one side, you don't go into a court room and argue both sides do you :wink:


You don't argue both sides. But you suss out the opposing argument, mention it, and knock it flat.

At least, I bloody hope you do, because that is what I did in my LNAT essay.

Reply 22

LawYah
Not in Law as you're supposed to argue one side, you don't go into a court room and argue both sides do you :wink:


Speaking as someone with a Law degree and currently doing my TC I can state with certainty you need to be able to understand and explain both sides of an argument.

Reply 23

Ethereal
Speaking as someone with a Law degree and currently doing my TC I can state with certainty you need to be able to understand and explain both sides of an argument.


Hahaha I know that's why I winked, I was being cheeky.

I know you have to understand both sides of the argument, I mentioned it in like 1-2 lines though, like the guy above said 'suss out' the opposing arguments, but I didnt really make it balanced!

Reply 24

The best way to get good marks in essays in your degree is to consider both sides in depth. If you argue all one way and make a cursory 2 line reference to other points of view you'll struggle to get above a 3rd/low 2:2

Reply 25

Ethereal
The best way to get good marks in essays in your degree is to consider both sides in depth. If you argue all one way and make a cursory 2 line reference to other points of view you'll struggle to get above a 3rd/low 2:2


Er.... we are talking about an essay we all desperately typed out in a panic-stricken 40 minutes. not a degree-standard essay!

Reply 26

LawYah
Not in Law as you're supposed to argue one side, you don't go into a court room and argue both sides do you :wink:



The LNAT isn't just for law. And whether you go into an courtroom and argue both sides isn't the point - essays are supposed to be balanced. Also, in court you also have to anticipate what the otherside might argue, so it's good to show you can think of that stuff------

Reply 27

Ethereal
The best way to get good marks in essays in your degree is to consider both sides in depth. If you argue all one way and make a cursory 2 line reference to other points of view you'll struggle to get above a 3rd/low 2:2


I usually do that in most of my essays.
It was only in the LNAT where I didnt balance arguments, I actually took the advice of people on here when I made a thread about the essay.

Something about arguing your side and not going too in depth to the other side of the argument.

Reply 28

LawYah
Like I said in my post above I argued one side as in Law that's what you're set out to do, either for or against. :biggrin:


I take law a-level and we've always been taught to give a balanced argument - personal opinion and affiliation saved for conclusion.

Reply 29

charmainecantyx
The LNAT isn't just for law. And whether you go into an courtroom and argue both sides isn't the point - essays are supposed to be balanced. Also, in court you also have to anticipate what the otherside might argue, so it's good to show you can think of that stuff------


I know how to structure an essay.

It was just the LNAT where I decided not to based on a lot of advice from here.

It still worked for me.

Reply 30

brightxburns
Er.... we are talking about an essay we all desperately typed out in a panic-stricken 40 minutes. not a degree-standard essay!


Don't the people who wrote/manage/charge extortionate fees claim the LNAT shows aptitude for degree?

Reply 31

charmainecantyx
I take law a-level and we've always been taught to give a balanced argument - personal opinion and affiliation saved for conclusion.


That's usually how you do any essay whether its Law or English.

Reply 32

LawYah
I know how to structure an essay.

It was just the LNAT where I decided not to based on a lot of advice from here.

It still worked for me.




How do you mean it worked for you? Have you received offers based on it?

Reply 33

charmainecantyx
I take law a-level and we've always been taught to give a balanced argument - personal opinion and affiliation saved for conclusion.


So was your LNAT essay thoroughly balanced?

What was your question, out of curiosity?

Reply 34

LawYah
That's usually how you do any essay whether its Law or English.


Then why did you change it on the LNAT?

Reply 35

brightxburns
So was your LNAT essay thoroughly balanced?

What was your question, out of curiosity?



It was balanced, but it provoked a stand one way or another 'to what extent' - so you had to evaluate what extent something was..


Haha was that confusing. I don't think we're allowed to talk about essay titles until the LNAT is finished.

Reply 36

charmainecantyx
How do you mean it worked for you? Have you received offers based on it?


Birmingham University is a LNAT Uni, non?

I don't give a **** how well I did in LNAT as long as I got the offer I wanted from the Uni.

Reply 37

Ethereal
Don't the people who wrote/manage/charge extortionate fees claim the LNAT shows aptitude for degree?


I'm with you on the fees. 40 quid, that's a pair of shoes !!!!!


Although mum paid for it, but it's still not the point!!!!

Reply 38

LawYah
Birmingham University is a LNAT Uni, non?

I don't give a **** how well I did in LNAT as long as I got the offer I wanted from the Uni.




I don't know if it is or isn't. Well if you got the offer you want it doesn't matter :smile:. I was just trying to make a point about essay writing, I don't think the style should have been changed too drastically just because it's a different type of exam.

Reply 39

charmainecantyx
Then why did you change it on the LNAT?


That was the advice given, I took it being pretty new to this whole LNAT business and people seemed to know what they were on about.