# trig c4 question

Watch
Announcements

Page 1 of 1

Go to first unread

Skip to page:

are there any values of a for which sec a, cosec a and cot a (for the range 0<(and equal to) a< (and equal to) 360 are all negative? explain your answer

the answer is no for each of the second, third and fourth quadrants a different function is positive

could you explain what this means? is there are another way of reaching this conclusion without using the cast method (if it even involves the cast method)?

the second part of the question are there any values of a for which sec a, cosec a and cot a are all equal? explain your answer

no the graphs of all three of the functions do not intersect at a single point

how does intersection show that the values are equal

could you explain this answer too please?

the answer is no for each of the second, third and fourth quadrants a different function is positive

could you explain what this means? is there are another way of reaching this conclusion without using the cast method (if it even involves the cast method)?

the second part of the question are there any values of a for which sec a, cosec a and cot a are all equal? explain your answer

no the graphs of all three of the functions do not intersect at a single point

how does intersection show that the values are equal

could you explain this answer too please?

0

reply

Report

#2

(Original post by

...

**esmeralda123**)...

Second part: If they intersect at a single point, then these functions take the same value a, and more importantly the same value, hence they would be equal at that point for some

0

reply

Report

#3

For the first one all three cannot be negative as if cosec(a) and sec(a) are negative then cot(a) will be positive as it’s the same as just cosec(a)/sec(a) so the negatives cancel.

For the second part think of a the definitions of these from the right-triangle. Cosec(a) = hyp/opp, sec(a) = hyp/adj, cot(a) adj/opp. If cosec(a) and sec(a) are equal this means opp = adj. Therefore cot(a) = 1, so now for them all to be equal hyp would have to equal opp and adj. This is impossible in a right triangle so there are no values of a that satisfy this.

For graphs if they intersect at a single point that means values of y and x are equal in all the functions intersecting at that point. You’re plotting y against x where in this case x = a. At a point where x = a on, say, the sec graph y = sec(a) and on cosec graph y = cosec(a). If there is an intersection these are the same point so y = both. So sec(a) = cosec(a)

For the second part think of a the definitions of these from the right-triangle. Cosec(a) = hyp/opp, sec(a) = hyp/adj, cot(a) adj/opp. If cosec(a) and sec(a) are equal this means opp = adj. Therefore cot(a) = 1, so now for them all to be equal hyp would have to equal opp and adj. This is impossible in a right triangle so there are no values of a that satisfy this.

For graphs if they intersect at a single point that means values of y and x are equal in all the functions intersecting at that point. You’re plotting y against x where in this case x = a. At a point where x = a on, say, the sec graph y = sec(a) and on cosec graph y = cosec(a). If there is an intersection these are the same point so y = both. So sec(a) = cosec(a)

0

reply

Report

#4

You can just simplify it and talk about sin cos tan being all negative (since then 1/... will be negative).

Sin is negative between 180 and 360.

Cos is negative between 90 and 270

Tan is negative between 90 and 180 and 270 and 360.

As you can see there is no overlap of all 3 at once. The CAST diagarm is just a way you can see this graphically.

The graphical proof is that all 3 of them never intersect or touch at a certain point

Your question is how does intersection show they are equal?

I mean, that's just how graphs work. For any graph if two functions intersect or touch each other, then at that value of x, they have the same value, they are equal. That's like basic basic maths.

You could do an algebraic proof. 1 over everything makes it

sin = cos = tan

sin x = tan x

=> sin x - tan x = 0

=> sin x(1 - 1/cos x) = 0

Either sin x =0

so x = 0, 180, 360

tan x undefined at 180

so

x= 0, 360

or

1/cos x =1

cos x= 1

x = 0, 360

ie. sin x = tan x

only at 0 deg and 360 deg within the range specified, when both functions = 0.

However obviously cos x doesn't = 0 at those points.

Sin is negative between 180 and 360.

Cos is negative between 90 and 270

Tan is negative between 90 and 180 and 270 and 360.

As you can see there is no overlap of all 3 at once. The CAST diagarm is just a way you can see this graphically.

The graphical proof is that all 3 of them never intersect or touch at a certain point

Your question is how does intersection show they are equal?

I mean, that's just how graphs work. For any graph if two functions intersect or touch each other, then at that value of x, they have the same value, they are equal. That's like basic basic maths.

You could do an algebraic proof. 1 over everything makes it

sin = cos = tan

sin x = tan x

=> sin x - tan x = 0

=> sin x(1 - 1/cos x) = 0

Either sin x =0

so x = 0, 180, 360

tan x undefined at 180

so

x= 0, 360

or

1/cos x =1

cos x= 1

x = 0, 360

ie. sin x = tan x

only at 0 deg and 360 deg within the range specified, when both functions = 0.

However obviously cos x doesn't = 0 at those points.

0

reply

(Original post by

You can just simplify it and talk about sin cos tan being all negative (since then 1/... will be negative).

Sin is negative between 180 and 360.

Cos is negative between 90 and 270

Tan is negative between 90 and 180 and 270 and 360.

As you can see there is no overlap of all 3 at once. The CAST diagarm is just a way you can see this graphically.

The graphical proof is that all 3 of them never intersect or touch at a certain point

Your question is how does intersection show they are equal?

I mean, that's just how graphs work. For any graph if two functions intersect or touch each other, then at that value of x, they have the same value, they are equal. That's like basic basic maths.

You could do an algebraic proof. 1 over everything makes it

sin = cos = tan

sin x = tan x

=> sin x - tan x = 0

=> sin x(1 - 1/cos x) = 0

Either sin x =0

so x = 0, 180, 360

tan x undefined at 180

so

x= 0, 360

or

1/cos x =1

cos x= 1

x = 0, 360

ie. sin x = tan x

only at 0 deg and 360 deg within the range specified, when both functions = 0.

However obviously cos x doesn't = 0 at those points.

**StayWoke**)You can just simplify it and talk about sin cos tan being all negative (since then 1/... will be negative).

Sin is negative between 180 and 360.

Cos is negative between 90 and 270

Tan is negative between 90 and 180 and 270 and 360.

As you can see there is no overlap of all 3 at once. The CAST diagarm is just a way you can see this graphically.

The graphical proof is that all 3 of them never intersect or touch at a certain point

Your question is how does intersection show they are equal?

I mean, that's just how graphs work. For any graph if two functions intersect or touch each other, then at that value of x, they have the same value, they are equal. That's like basic basic maths.

You could do an algebraic proof. 1 over everything makes it

sin = cos = tan

sin x = tan x

=> sin x - tan x = 0

=> sin x(1 - 1/cos x) = 0

Either sin x =0

so x = 0, 180, 360

tan x undefined at 180

so

x= 0, 360

or

1/cos x =1

cos x= 1

x = 0, 360

ie. sin x = tan x

only at 0 deg and 360 deg within the range specified, when both functions = 0.

However obviously cos x doesn't = 0 at those points.

'Sin is negative between 180 and 360.

Cos is negative between 90 and 270

Tan is negative between 90 and 180 and 270 and 360.'

there are curves either side of each other

for them to all be negative what must the graphs be like- should they intersect all at one point ?

0

reply

Report

#6

(Original post by

but how does this show that they are not all negative:

'Sin is negative between 180 and 360.

Cos is negative between 90 and 270

Tan is negative between 90 and 180 and 270 and 360.'

there are curves either side of each other

for them to all be negative what must the graphs be like- should they intersect all at one point ?

**esmeralda123**)but how does this show that they are not all negative:

'Sin is negative between 180 and 360.

Cos is negative between 90 and 270

Tan is negative between 90 and 180 and 270 and 360.'

there are curves either side of each other

for them to all be negative what must the graphs be like- should they intersect all at one point ?

Try and find a value of x where all 3 of them are below the x axis.

That's the graphical way.

Or you can look at what you quoted from me and see that there is no value of x which is

1) between 180 and 360

2) between 90 and 270,

3) between 90 and 180 or 270 and 360.

all of the above^

You can get two of the three required points, but not all 3.

0

reply

(Original post by

For the negative part, they just need to all be below the x axis at the same value of x.

Try and find a value of x where all 3 of them are below the x axis.

That's the graphical way.

Or you can look at what you quoted from me and see that there is no value of x which is

1) between 180 and 360

2) between 90 and 270,

3) between 90 and 180 or 270 and 360.

all of the above^

You can get two of the three required points, but not all 3.

**StayWoke**)For the negative part, they just need to all be below the x axis at the same value of x.

Try and find a value of x where all 3 of them are below the x axis.

That's the graphical way.

Or you can look at what you quoted from me and see that there is no value of x which is

1) between 180 and 360

2) between 90 and 270,

3) between 90 and 180 or 270 and 360.

all of the above^

You can get two of the three required points, but not all 3.

0

reply

Report

#8

(Original post by

so they must intersect at one point below the x axis for them to all be negative

**esmeralda123**)so they must intersect at one point below the x axis for them to all be negative

For them to all be negative, they would all have to be below the axis. No intersection needed.

0

reply

(Original post by

no no, intersection only comes into play in the second part of your OP talking about all of them being the same value.

For them to all be negative, they would all have to be below the axis. No intersection needed.

**StayWoke**)no no, intersection only comes into play in the second part of your OP talking about all of them being the same value.

For them to all be negative, they would all have to be below the axis. No intersection needed.

0

reply

Report

#10

(Original post by

but they are all below the x axis

**esmeralda123**)but they are all below the x axis

but what we're looking for is that they're all below the x axis at the same time.

For a certain value of x, all 3 trig graphs below the axis.

That never happens

0

reply

(Original post by

they all go below the x axis at some point,

but what we're looking for is that they're all below the x axis at the same time.

For a certain value of x, all 3 trig graphs below the axis.

That never happens

**StayWoke**)they all go below the x axis at some point,

but what we're looking for is that they're all below the x axis at the same time.

For a certain value of x, all 3 trig graphs below the axis.

That never happens

0

reply

X

Page 1 of 1

Go to first unread

Skip to page:

### Quick Reply

Back

to top

to top