Change the GCSE English Literature exam from closed book to open book.
Last year, lots of students struggled with GCSE English Literature as it was a closed book exam. Because of this many failed. How can they expect us to remember quotes from 15 poems, plus how to analyse them, plus remembering the whole plot, themes, characters and quotes from another book.
x Turn on thread page Beta
Sign this to allow GCSE Eng Lit students to take copies of books into GCSE exams watch
- Thread Starter
- 12-02-2018 18:12
- 12-02-2018 18:16
How ridiculous, exams are a test of your understanding and ability to recall/remember things within the subject. It would be pointless to just let students read from their books for the answers.
- 12-02-2018 18:24
Look, this is stupid. If you don't know how to analyse the prose you've studied, or cannot recall "themes, characters and quotes" without having the book/poems in front of you, then you must have very poor understanding of the literature. And anyway, in an exam, I can guarantee that you won't have time to write a coherent response to a question, as well as search/read the book to find what you're looking for.
- 12-02-2018 18:28
this is stupid,
i may as well just make a petition and say "scrap a-level revision and let us take out textbooks into the exam."
ngl I'd buy the best and high quality textbooks if that was the new rule .
plus, if you know many failed this exam last year, then you should work even harder for this years literature exam.Last edited by soIiIoquy; 12-02-2018 at 18:33.
- 12-02-2018 21:25
I get both sides of the argument with this. I was in the last year group to sit the old exams before they changed to the new exams where we were given a clean copy of the texts and were able to use this for quotes. All the things related to characters, themes etc we had to revise ourselves. I understand the posters above me saying that these things should be learnt. Yes, perhaps learning them is the best way to demonstrate you've learnt the texts, but it is the study of the texts themselves you're doing your exam on. Having the book/poems themselves do not give the answers to the questions asked.
Literature is now compulsory for all students in my local high school to take, even students who are struggling to pass Language have to take it. It is unfair to ask students, especially at GCSE where not everyone's strong point is Literature or even English in general, to have to learn so much. Even my A Level English Literature syllabus is open book for poetry.
(Original post by soIiIoquy)
this is stupid,
i may as well just make a petition and say "scrap a-level revision and let us take out textbooks into the exam.
Last edited by xEmilyxx; 12-02-2018 at 21:27.
- 12-02-2018 21:30
I did last years new GCSE exam...it wasn't that bad. people failed because it was the first year doing a supposedly harder exam. i can speak on behalf of most people and say remembering the quotes wasn't hard. i never sat down and read through them, when u revise and go through poems and texts you automatically remember quite a few, more than u may think.
- 13-02-2018 00:34
As someone who did a course that has been closed-book for years, I don't think it is unreasonable to keep the exams closed-book. You need to learn the content regardless, most teachers would tell you not to even touch the book if it was on the table because of timings and the fact that it suggests that you may not have learnt the content well enough to answer an essay question on it. Have you also considered the fact that your grade boundaries will undoubtedly go up massively because they allocate grades through trends of results? There's plenty of time in the year to learn the quotes with the content. Sorry.Last edited by death07/08/17; 13-02-2018 at 00:36.