The Student Room Group

The 4 poem method - GCSE AQA conflict poetry 2018

Scroll to see replies

Reply 20

Original post
by Mehru1214
My bad, I actually kicked myself in the exam. Luckily I had London memorised, so yeahhh. My bad - I'll admit it.


Ozymandias is maybe the most versatile out of all of them anyway

Reply 21

Original post
by Sinnoh
Ozymandias is maybe the most versatile out of all of them anyway


Yeah - which is why I was lucky, as you can make practically anything compare with it.

Reply 22

Original post
by Mehru1214
Yeah - which is why I was lucky, as you can make practically anything compare with it.


I did GCSEs last year and thought I was lucky getting Bayonet Charge. Not gonna lie - I was hoping year 11 would be screwed over this year.

Reply 23

Original post
by Sinnoh
I did GCSEs last year and thought I was lucky getting Bayonet Charge. Not gonna lie - I was hoping year 11 would be screwed over this year.

Original post
by Mehru1214
Yeah - which is why I was lucky, as you can make practically anything compare with it.


Can you please tell me what u mean whn u say individual experience for a poem got mocks tomorrow morning

Reply 24

Original post
by aman2002
Can you please tell me what u mean whn u say individual experience for a poem got mocks tomorrow morning


I've no idea. That seems too broad and vague for it to be a question.

Reply 25

Original post
by aman2002
Can you please tell me what u mean whn u say individual experience for a poem got mocks tomorrow morning


It's basically one's feelings and actual experience about an event, you can talk about first person directly involving you in it, and as such.

Reply 26

Original post
by Mehru1214
GCSE EDIT: THEY DID OZYMANDIAS! Luckily I had London memorised - how did you guys find it?


Hey guys,

So I'm having a late mock for Lit paper 2 on Feb 23rd, and I devised a way to do the poetry bit, by only having to learn four poems. The great thing is that these four poems together compare with every other poem in the whole cluster! So just learn maybe 5-6 key quotes from these four poems, along with the main ideas, and you'll be set.

EDIT : I've got my results back, and I got 27/30 for the poetry comparison section, resulting in a grade 8 overall, so I'm happy!

Of course, go over the other poems too, so that it's easy to analyse them in the exam, when it's given to you.

Key: Main Poem, Other Poem, Theme.

I'm learning Bayonet Charge, Poppies, London and Kamikaze. These 4 main poems compare with each other too, so you only need these 4, no matter what poem is given to you in the actual exam.

Bayonet Charge compares with: Exposure, Charge of the Light Brigade, Remains, Poppies and Kamikaze. The themes connecting all of these poems are Reality of Conflict, Effects of Conflict, and Individual Experience.

Poppies compares with: London (Loss and Absence) and Bayonet Charge. It also compares with Kamikaze, Remains and War Photographer for 3 same themes - Effect of Conflict, Memory, and Individual Experience.

London compares with: Poppies, Checking Out Me History (Power of Humans, Anger), My Last Duchess (Abuse of Power), and The Prelude (Individual Experiences). It may also compare with Storm on the Island if you interpret the poems as being about political conflict, but this is quite hard to do. It compares with Ozymandias for Abuse of Power.

Kamikaze compares with: Poppies, The Prelude (Power of Nature, Fear, Individual Experiences), Charge of the Light Brigade (common with Bayonet Charge), and Storm on the Island (Power of Nature).

Hope this helped, and good luck for the actual GCSEs! :wink2:

Thank you so much for this...I really struggle with remembering quotes so this will really help :smile:

Reply 27

I have an alternative method. Get lucky.

Reply 28

Original post
by Tolgarda
I have an alternative method. Get lucky.


Lol good for you - It still worked for me though, I got a 9 in my English GCSE using it.

Reply 29

Original post
by Mehru1214
Lol good for you - It still worked for me though, I got a 9 in my English GCSE using it.

Yeah, true. My method was pretty successful. I too was able to achieve a 9 with it. We all have our secrets. :lol:

Reply 30

Hello, I'm a current year 11 and this helped so much! but where is tissue? :smile:

Reply 31

Original post
by tonibeeverxx
Hello, I'm a current year 11 and this helped so much! but where is tissue? :smile:


Glad to know this helped after 2 years lol, also wow, can't believe I forgot about Tissue. Then again it is like the hardest poem so I think I just neglected it :P

Reply 32

hey, im so glad you got such a high score , i am struggling with my comparison; remains vs exposure. i would be really grateful if you could maybe send me your essay as an example of how to structure it and how to elaborate on poems. also please could you let me know what resources you used to help you write a grade 8 comparison . i would be extremly grateful , maybe contact on insta

Reply 33

Post is still helpful 3 years later for Jan 2022 mocks! :smile:
I did also learn the Emigree in case Tissue came up on the paper.

Reply 34

yh

Reply 35

Original post
by Mehru1214
GCSE EDIT: THEY DID OZYMANDIAS! Luckily I had London memorised - how did you guys find it? I also got a 9 from my method :biggrin:
Hey guys,
So I'm having a late mock for Lit paper 2 on Feb 23rd, and I devised a way to do the poetry bit, by only having to learn four poems. The great thing is that these four poems together compare with every other poem in the whole cluster! So just learn maybe 5-6 key quotes from these four poems, along with the main ideas, and you'll be set.
EDIT : I've got my results back, and I got 27/30 for the poetry comparison section, resulting in a grade 8 overall, so I'm happy!
Of course, go over the other poems too, so that it's easy to analyse them in the exam, when it's given to you.
Key: Main Poem, Other Poem, Theme.
I'm learning Bayonet Charge, Poppies, London and Kamikaze. These 4 main poems compare with each other too, so you only need these 4, no matter what poem is given to you in the actual exam.
Bayonet Charge compares with: Exposure, Charge of the Light Brigade, Remains, Poppies and Kamikaze. The themes connecting all of these poems are Reality of Conflict, Effects of Conflict, and Individual Experience.
Poppies compares with: London (Loss and Absence) and Bayonet Charge. It also compares with Kamikaze, Remains and War Photographer for 3 same themes - Effect of Conflict, Memory, and Individual Experience.
London compares with: Poppies, Checking Out Me History (Power of Humans, Anger), My Last Duchess (Abuse of Power), and The Prelude (Individual Experiences). It may also compare with Storm on the Island if you interpret the poems as being about political conflict, but this is quite hard to do. It compares with Ozymandias for Abuse of Power.
Kamikaze compares with: Poppies, The Prelude (Power of Nature, Fear, Individual Experiences), Charge of the Light Brigade (common with Bayonet Charge), and Storm on the Island (Power of Nature).
Hope this helped, and good luck for the actual GCSEs! :wink2:

omg well done thats incredible im going to do these 4 poems plus ozymandias as its my favourite im praying i get given ozymandias or london as i know them so well and they're my favourites

Reply 36

tissue could compare well to poppies or if you're willing to the Emigree

Reply 37

Original post
by Mehru1214
GCSE EDIT: THEY DID OZYMANDIAS! Luckily I had London memorised - how did you guys find it? I also got a 9 from my method :biggrin:
Hey guys,
So I'm having a late mock for Lit paper 2 on Feb 23rd, and I devised a way to do the poetry bit, by only having to learn four poems. The great thing is that these four poems together compare with every other poem in the whole cluster! So just learn maybe 5-6 key quotes from these four poems, along with the main ideas, and you'll be set.
EDIT : I've got my results back, and I got 27/30 for the poetry comparison section, resulting in a grade 8 overall, so I'm happy!
Of course, go over the other poems too, so that it's easy to analyse them in the exam, when it's given to you.
Key: Main Poem, Other Poem, Theme.
I'm learning Bayonet Charge, Poppies, London and Kamikaze. These 4 main poems compare with each other too, so you only need these 4, no matter what poem is given to you in the actual exam.
Bayonet Charge compares with: Exposure, Charge of the Light Brigade, Remains, Poppies and Kamikaze. The themes connecting all of these poems are Reality of Conflict, Effects of Conflict, and Individual Experience.
Poppies compares with: London (Loss and Absence) and Bayonet Charge. It also compares with Kamikaze, Remains and War Photographer for 3 same themes - Effect of Conflict, Memory, and Individual Experience.
London compares with: Poppies, Checking Out Me History (Power of Humans, Anger), My Last Duchess (Abuse of Power), and The Prelude (Individual Experiences). It may also compare with Storm on the Island if you interpret the poems as being about political conflict, but this is quite hard to do. It compares with Ozymandias for Abuse of Power.
Kamikaze compares with: Poppies, The Prelude (Power of Nature, Fear, Individual Experiences), Charge of the Light Brigade (common with Bayonet Charge), and Storm on the Island (Power of Nature).
Hope this helped, and good luck for the actual GCSEs! :wink2:

pls can u help me with the compering remains and poppies

Quick Reply

How The Student Room is moderated

To keep The Student Room safe for everyone, we moderate posts that are added to the site.