Muslims how do you feel about sharia law?

What about apostates?




Good news. Hell probably doesn't exist.



Considering sharia law punishes homosexuals and wants death for apostates, it is barbaric. Don't get it mixed up.

Also muhammed was the best example of islam makes islam look pretty negative in the eyes of some. He wasnt the best to step foot on earth.

Islam is about equality. Unfortunately there are people who misused ad adapted the shariah law to their advantage e.g. punishing homosexuals which Islam does not tolerate because that is an act of discrimination, not equality.

I don't see why Prophet pbuh makes Islam look negative when he even treated the people who hated him well and with respect. If he wasn't the best person to step their land on foot then who is.

Please shut up.

I am a Muslim and you are the one who is too scared to question your surroundings. I still believe in Allah but there are many areas in Islam that are sexist.

Oh please , if you really are a muslim and not a troll pretending to be a muslim, then you wouldn't even be questioning the high value for women in Islam.
Just because there are muslims who disrespect women and misinterpret the quran doesn't mean the quran tolerates and preaches mistreatment of women.
My advice to you is READ the quran with an open mind, that way you won't be 'scared of going to hell.'

I voted yes.

How do you feel about her?

ummm, you do realise there are currently 11 countries that execute any known apostates? And major islamic countries also prosecute homosexuals. I'm not sure how scholars who have studied islam for their entire lives are wrong.

There is explicit hadith and verses which says to punish homosexuals. These are islamic scholas talking, not me.

Plenty of people. Who is the "best" is subjective.

Muhammed wasn't exactly all that innocent. He was a bit of a warmonger. There is also the fact that he married a 6 year old and had sex with her when she was 9. Not a lot of people like that.

LMFAO you literally didn't reply to my comment, but instead because you weren't able to give justification you resort to emotional manipulation...

So would you agree with the parts of sharia saying women need a male to accompany them outside?

or the fact that after a woman gets raped she must marry her rapist?

Or that homosexuality is strictly forbiden?

I am Muslim, but i truly believe sharia law has no place.

It maybe fine for some Muslims in a country, but what about others in that country? What about the atheists, buddhists, christians and jews? What if they don't follow Islam - aren't you just forcing an idealogy down their throats?

How would you feel if England changed it's laws so you need to follow the old biblical ways?

Homosexuality shouldn't be illegal. Cos that forces homos to hide their sexuality, which religiously is good but they hide this in fear of persecution in legal terms. However making it legal spices it up, cos for those who have patience this is a consensual choice being a muslim, so rewards are fruiter if you get my flow. If you disobey, may Allah help you.

Lots say Sharia law is bad. Thats your opinion dcr. But Allah is the best of planners, his plan is the best. So although our small brains may think its a stupid law, we are merely a creation of Allah, nothing more nothing less. He created this law and many things with life our small minds may never fully understand. Just like heaven is a place no mind has ever thought of, no eye has seen and no ear has heard.

imo if shariah law was implemented its for sure a deterrent for all the criminals, dunno about you but I dont want my hand chopped for stealing (conditions apply ofc)- but it'll keep everyone in check instead of tax-payer prisons.

I have not looked into this issue in depth, so I only know for certain about longer journeys requiring men; nonetheless, whatever the correct ruling is, I accept it.




This is not in the Shariah. This was due to loopholes in modern Arabian criminal law (which is not Shariah). Anyone found guilty of rape would be punished very severely according to Shariah.



Acting on homosexual feelings is forbidden; people cannot control how they feel - similarly, a single heterosexual man cannot go around kissing girls and having sexual relations just because of his feelings, because this too is forbidden, yet his feeling is not Haram in of itself.



This is a statement of Kufr - I would advise you read the Qur'an in a language you understand, and I advise you to reflect and pay specific attention to verses about the People of Book who neglected the teachings and laws of the messengers sent to them, and how Allah (SWT) has condemned them as disbelievers.



The example and precedent of the Khulafah Rashideen is that they made agreements with areas where there were People of the Book (Christians and Jews) that they would allow them to continue to apply certain Biblical rules to themselves.
With regards to other groups, it is simply applying a legal system to a people much like a legal system is enforced in the UK; I disagree with alcohol and gambling and extra-marital sexual relations, but does my opinion matter in the UK? Clearly not - I have to live with it, and so would other groups living within a Shariah run state. This is the way the world works; unless it is only a bad thing when Muslims do something?



If the UK did that, then perhaps it would be better in some ways here; though the original Biblical laws cannot be verified to be completely in tact, so it would be an incomplete legal system. In any case, you would have to clarify and define what Biblical law is, considering we are not Jews/Israelites, and Christians understand the Old Testament differently to them.

LMFAO you literally didn't reply to my comment, but instead because you weren't able to give justification you resort to emotional manipulation...

My only purpose was to make clear of nay misconceptions made about Islam, not spread any for of hate.
My question to you is why start this thread in the first place. Let people feel however they want to feel about the Shariah Law. Plus, Muslims are already get a lot of hate from the media light the flame for more hatred to be spread by spreading misconceptions of Islam.

First of all, I can't speak for the people who have carried out these horrific crimes against homosexuals. I am a muslim and a LGBT supporter. And as for those so called scholars, they must have misinterpreted the teachings of Islam or learnt Islam from the wrong people..

The fact your throwing false facts of the prophet pbuh assaulting a 6yr old wife is disgusting and upsetting. If you don't bother doing thorough research then why throw hurtful, false facts around. He never married a 6 yr old and he treated ALL is wives with respect,
The Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) advised men:
"The best amongst you, are the best for their wives, and I am the best of you for my wives." (Tirmidhi)
Something even men in the 21st Century struggle to do with their wives or partners.

So in future, please be mindful of what you say and research these sensitive topics using reliable sources and be open minded. Twisting facts or stating outright lies as facts is not cool (I'm talking about your 'fact' about the prophet pbuh).

"That's the thinking of a Kufr" <- This is such a childish statement, it's the same as "if you don't agree with me, then your a bad person". Also your idea of making only Muslims follow sharia law is ridiculous, what if you were Muslim but didn't want to follow sharia, but wanted to follow western laws?

"That's the thinking of a Kufr" <- This is such a childish statement, it's the same as "if you don't agree with me, then your a bad person". Also your idea of making only Muslims follow sharia law is ridiculous, what if you were Muslim but didn't want to follow sharia, but wanted to follow western laws?

Note too, your saying gays shouldn't be allowed sexual freedom then. A gay man can have those feelings, but can never act upon them? Thats a terrible thing and imo too controlling. Homosexuality is genetic too, lots of animals in nature exhibit homosexualitiy - so it clearly isn't a man made construct. Do you think if a gay man acts on his feelings, he should deserve death?