From the sounds of it, it seems like you're taking the piss a bit. I mean it seems this nice guy has gone out of the way for you, and you're even considering this bad guy because he turns you on. It's a shame that good guys have to be treated this way. If I was the good guy i'd be pretty hurt if I knew that, seeing that all the things that i'd done for you would have been outshadowed by some guy who seems cooler in image only.
Do you even know this so called bad guy properly? Have you got any proof that he's actually an NHL player, not for us but for yourself, you need to know if what he tells you is the truth, especially since he's apparently a bad guy he may well be prone to being a bull****ter too. I've met many people who claim they are many things, but a lot if not all of them turn out to be bull****ters