Should women Commentate on MOTD?Watch this thread
Does it affect the game? would you rather more/less of it in the futur?
It sounds wrong.
And it is indecently annoying when there is that shreek when she says "GOALL!!!"
Gahh - it annoys any football fan, and most men hate it.
If we could get a fat butch woman who had a man's voice, then I wouldn't have a problem.
Natural male instinct im assuming...
Ive got nothing against female commentators in principle, but she has to work on not making football sound like an episode of eastenders in which something worth shrieking about happens...
the whole enthusiasm for the game seems forced to me
If it has to be that woman, no. Describing dribbling as "like a hot knife through butter"
What was that about? Did she just overhear someone saying that one time and just threw it in? There was like a massive pause between her last, sensible, comment and then this...
Although it does entertain, which i suppose is the point of the entire thing
I don't mind the idea of a female commentator, no prejudice here but that woman commentator on MotD is really, really, really annoying. She seems to think we want to hear a player's life story whenever he gets the ball. And it seems more natural hearing a man's voice commentating too. It just does, sorry.
Yeah, she seems so wooden and when the pen against Man City this weekend came along she was hardly berating them. It was just a bit lame.
i think the problem is, we're hearing something we havent experienced before - so we tend to scrutinise what she's saying. I'll tell you now, half the male commentators are just as bad. Like someone said tho, cant complain with a decent female commentator.
I want Claire Tomlinson back on Sky. She's fit, and good at the job too. Why does she supports Spurs?
I can just about put up with her commentating on some undercard MOTD Fulham/Boro match, but if she were to get a live job it would be unbearable.