You are Here: Home >< Maths

1. Please could I have some help on the following question:

a.) If P is irrational, show by the method of contradiction that 1/P is also irrational.

b.) Give an example of two irrational numbers, a and b, where a does not equal b, such that ab is rational

Many thanks!
2. assume that 1/P is rational.

investigate the product of P and 1/P
3. (Original post by the bear)
assume that 1/P is rational.

investigate the product of P and 1/P
That's great, thank you!
4. For b), it's always useful to think of the formula (x - y) (x + y) = x2 - y2
Make x and y irrational. Their sum and difference will be irrational and different from one another, so they can be your a and b.

Spoiler:
Show
Example: x = sqrt(8), y = sqrt(2)
a = x - y = sqrt(8) - sqrt(2), irrational
b = x + y = sqrt(8) + sqrt(2), irrational
ab = (x - y)(x + y) = 8 - 2 = 6, which is rational
5. Assume 1/P is rational.

i.e. 1/P = a/b; a,b are integers
=> P = b/a which means is rational. This contradicts what we know of P being irrational. Therefore we prove 1/P must be irrational.
6. (Original post by InsertNameHero)
Assume 1/P is rational.

i.e. 1/P = a/b; a,b are integers
=> P = b/a which means is rational. This contradicts what we know of P being irrational. Therefore we prove 1/P must be irrational.
you haven't checked the case where b=0 lol
7. (Original post by asdfghjklcupcake)
For b), it's always useful to think of the formula (x - y) (x y) = x2 - y2
Make x and y irrational. Their sum and difference will be irrational and different from one another, so they can be your a and b.

Spoiler:
Show
Example: x = sqrt(8), y = sqrt(2)
a = x - y = sqrt(8) - sqrt(2), irrational
b = x y = sqrt(8) sqrt(2), irrational
ab = (x - y)(x y) = 8 - 2 = 6, which is rational
It is not necessarily true that if x and y are irrational their sum or their differences are irrational. counter example:
sqrt(2) is irrational
2-sqrt(2) is also irrational but
sqrt(2) + (2-sqrt(2))=2 which is definitely rational.
hence you must prove sqrt(8) (and minus) sqrt(2) is irrational. A better solution is just sqrt(2) is irrational sqrt(8) is irrational but sqrt(2)*sqrt(8) = sqrt(16)=4 is rational lol.
8. (Original post by igotohaggerston)
It is not true that if x and y are irrational their sum and differences are irrational. counter example:
sqrt(2) is irrational
2-sqrt(2) is also irrational but
2 + (2-sqrt(2))=2 which is definitely rational.
hence you must prove sqrt(8) +(and minus) sqrt(2) is irrational. A better solution is just sqrt(2) is irrational sqrt(8) is irrational but sqrt(2)*sqrt(8) = sqrt(16)=4 is rational lol.
2+(2-sqrt(2))= 4-sqrt(2) ≠ 2 and is irrational
9. (Original post by InsertNameHero)
2+(2-sqrt(2))= 4-sqrt(2) ≠ 2 and is irrational
Sorry I meant sqrt(2) + (2-sqrt(2)) I edited the original post
10. (Original post by InsertNameHero)
Assume 1/P is rational.

i.e. 1/P = a/b; a,b are integers
=> P = b/a which means is rational. This contradicts what we know of P being irrational. Therefore we prove 1/P must be irrational.
Not correct - please note in future that 'solutions' should not be posted in the maths forum.
11. (Original post by Muttley79)
Not correct - please note in future that 'solutions' should not be posted in the maths forum.
Sorry, can you clarify the mistake I have made?. I assumed the statement isn't true. I then showed that this lead to a contradiction of a fact we knew to be true. Then I concluded that the assumption was incorrect and the statement must be true. I thought this would be correct but can you show me where I have gone wrong?
12. (Original post by InsertNameHero)
Sorry, can you clarify the mistake I have made?. I assumed the statement isn't true. I then showed that this lead to a contradiction of a fact we knew to be true. Then I concluded that the assumption was incorrect and the statement must be true. I thought this would be correct but can you show me where I have gone wrong?
Read the posts by The Bear and igotohaggerston.
13. (Original post by Muttley79)
Not correct - please note in future that 'solutions' should not be posted in the maths forum.
Apart from not stating the triviality that 1/P isn't 0, it is correct.
14. (Original post by Zacken)
Apart from not stating the triviality that 1/P isn't 0, it is correct.
Yes but without that is is not correct - so as it stands it is wrong.
15. (Original post by Muttley79)
Read the posts by The Bear and igotohaggerston.
Neither of those posts help InsertNameHero see why his solution is "incorrect", which is arguably much more correct than not so. Simply saying it's not correct is unhelpful and pedantic.

Igotohaggerston's post asks him to check the case b=0. When assuming that 1/P=a/b is rational, it is implicit that b is non-zero and this does not need to be stated.

Bear's post, whilst also leading to a correct proof, also skirts over the issue of the product being undefined if 1/P is zero. I wonder if the OP made this distinction in his final solution based on the posts of this thread alone.
16. (Original post by Farhan.Hanif93)
Neither of those posts help InsertNameHero see why his solution is "incorrect", which is arguably much more correct than not so. Simply saying it's not correct is unhelpful and pedantic.

Igotohaggerston's post asks him to check the case b=0. When assuming that 1/P=a/b is rational, it is implicit that b is non-zero and this does not need to be stated.

Bear's post, whilst also leading to a correct proof, also skirts over the issue of the product being undefined if 1/P is zero. I wonder if the OP made this distinction in his final solution based on the posts of this thread alone.
My point, which you have totally overlooked, is that any solution should NOT have been posted at all. Please amend your post as it is unhelpful.

TSR Support Team

We have a brilliant team of more than 60 Support Team members looking after discussions on The Student Room, helping to make it a fun, safe and useful place to hang out.

This forum is supported by:
Updated: August 14, 2018
Today on TSR

### Cambridge interviews

Find out which colleges are sending invitations

### University open days

• University of East Anglia
Fri, 23 Nov '18
• Norwich University of the Arts
Fri, 23 Nov '18
• Edge Hill University
Sat, 24 Nov '18
Poll
Useful resources

### Maths Forum posting guidelines

Not sure where to post? Read the updated guidelines here

### How to use LaTex

Writing equations the easy way

### Study habits of A* students

Top tips from students who have already aced their exams