Year 12s: what will be the first way you research your future options? >>

Corbyn acussed of laying wreath for Munich terrorist

Scroll to see replies

So they were the wrong type of Jews is that it? They were too left wing? Only british newspapers could claim someone going to a Sedar is anti-Semitic.Its kind of anti-Semitic semetic as well to claim they are somehow not real Jews because they're against the government of Israel.

Who claims they are not Jews? Probably they are. But they don't represent the Jewish people, neither the British Jews. And of course they are extremely leftist.

The state of Israel is different from the Jewish people.

Indeed, what can be common between the Jewish state and the Jewish people? :cool:

Reply 81

y.u.mad.bro?

Original post by admonit

Corbyn hates Israel as a country. He hates its history, governments, soldiers, politicians, everyone and everything in Israel. It's a pathological hate. That's why he traveled to Tunisia to honor murderers of Israelis, including olympic sportsmen, and now he lies denying that

Again you reinforced my point. His hate isn't to do with jews. Its to do with Israel as a nation. Some of his remarks are wrong I agree but dont claim he is against Jews. Many jews are against Israel as well. Do you think they are not jewish then?

Reply 82

username2763536

Original post by admonit

Who claims they are not Jews? Probably they are. But they don't represent the Jewish people, neither the British Jews. And of course they are extremely leftist.

Indeed, what can be common between the Jewish state and the Jewish people? :cool:

Why don't they represent them? Because they are left wing? They have just as much claim to represent the Jewish faith as any other Jews.The state of Israel is the government which is doing many things worthy of criticism in the West bank.The Jewish people are merely the people who live under that government.That doesn't mean they approve of all the government does any more than the British people approve of what ours does.To criticise Brexit is not being anti-English.In the same way criticising the Israeli government's actions is not the same as being against Jewish people.I'm not sure why that is so difficult to understand.

Reply 83

admonit

Original post by y.u.mad.bro?

Its to do with Israel as a nation.

Israel is a Jewish state and a homeland for the Jewish people. If you don't understand it or don't accept it then this conversation is useless. Actually this is the main point, and not the West Bank or the Israeli government. Corbyn and his supporters don't accept the Jewish people as a nation.

Some of his remarks are wrong

This thread is not about remarks of Corbyn, but about his actions. Particularly about honoring murderers of Israeli Olympic sportsmen.

Reply 84

admonit

Original post by Robby2312

Why don't they represent them? Because they are left wing?

Because idiots and haters of the Jewish people never represented the Jewish people.

The Jewish people are merely the people who live under that government.

What??

Reply 85

y.u.mad.bro?

Original post by admonit

This thread is not about remarks of Corbyn, but about his actions. Particularly about honoring murderers of Israeli Olympic sportsmen.

How can you claim his supports dont recognise. They are purely against the illegal settlement of Israel in palestenian land and the murder of innocejt people. Theres tons of evidence to show how brutal Israel is and Corbyn is against that. He is not against Jews or their land. But seemindly it appears you and I are on a difference wavelength so lets not discuss this further because no point.

Reply 86

username2763536

Original post by admonit

Because idiots and haters of the Jewish people never represented the Jewish people.

What??

How can they hate Jews if they are themselves Jews? Its a basic point.Hating Israel's government is not the same as hating Jews.

Reply 87

admonit

Jeremy Corbyn pictured with terror chief at Tunisia wreath ceremony

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/edition/news/jeremy-corbyn-pictured-with-pflp-terror-chief-maher-al-taher-at-2014-tunisia-wreath-laying-ceremony-t5rgh0jp5

A month later Mr Taher’s group claimed responsibility for an axe attack at a Jerusalem synagogue in which four rabbis were killed during morning prayers.