The Student Room Group

Scroll to see replies

Original post by gjd800
I do wonder about the self-diagnoses of this stuff. Having a shite day is not equivalent with depression (having several consecutive shite days is not necessarily indicative of depression), but it strikes me that a lot of young people think that it is. Nobody is happy all of the time.
What makes you say that? (just curious)
Reply 41
Original post by 04MR17
What makes you say that? (just curious)


My conversations with them, mainly. I've played in bands with young lads that were guilty of it. 'I was depressed thinking about that gig'. Really, they just felt bad after a grim showing. I don't think it's necessarily the same.
Original post by gjd800
My conversations with them, mainly. I've played in bands with young lads that were guilty of it. 'I was depressed thinking about that gig'. Really, they just felt bad after a grim showing. I don't think it's necessarily the same.
Do you think this is just a use of what is (to you and me) serious terminology with meaningful implications, but to the average young person who is surrounded by discussion about suffering from MH, this sort of language is commonplace? Basically an exaggeration of language.

Because I think it's much more that than people genuinely believing they need/deserve medical help for depression.
Reply 43
Original post by 04MR17
Do you think this is just a use of what is (to you and me) serious terminology with meaningful implications, but to the average young person who is surrounded by discussion about suffering from MH, this sort of language is commonplace? Basically an exaggeration of language.

Because I think it's much more that than people genuinely believing they need/deserve medical help for depression.


Yes, and I worry that the talk around it then becomes a sort of self-fulfilling prophecy in terms of a young person perhaps overstating the case when asked 'have you experienced symptom a?'.

If they need the help, then clearly they need the help, and that's how it is. In such a case, a stat like this would be awful and would indeed indicate a public health problem of some magnitude

I suppose I mirror what others say re the methodology, but that's not so say that I don't recognise that another approach might find similar (or worse) results which would in turn constitute a massive issue.
Original post by gjd800
Yes, and I worry that the talk around it then becomes a sort of self-fulfilling prophecy in terms of a young person perhaps overstating the case when asked 'have you experienced symptom a?'.

If they need the help, then clearly they need the help, and that's how it is. In such a case, a stat like this would be awful and would indeed indicate a public health problem of some magnitude
Yeah I can understand the self-fulfilling prophecy idea. If you use this language so casually about yourself eventually you brain might get hooked on the idea and you begin an inward spiral.

However, I do think the truth lies halfway in between. To casually say it in conversation is one thing. To actually say you're suffering in a survey is going a bit further. And I genuinely believe far more people suffer in silence without getting the help (whether their mental condition is extremely poor or just needs minor treatment) than those who are accessing support.
Reply 45
Original post by 04MR17
Yeah I can understand the self-fulfilling prophecy idea. If you use this language so casually about yourself eventually you brain might get hooked on the idea and you begin an inward spiral.

However, I do think the truth lies halfway in between. To casually say it in conversation is one thing. To actually say you're suffering in a survey is going a bit further. And I genuinely believe far more people suffer in silence without getting the help (whether their mental condition is extremely poor or just needs minor treatment) than those who are accessing support.


I have no doubt at all about that last part.
Reply 46
It's natural to have some anxiety during university but some of us (probably a lot) suffer this continually. It's a perpetual nightmare for us. Anxiety is just in our blood, figuratively speaking.

There are remedies, of course, but none have worked for me. I can continuously fear being ridiculed for being socially anxious or awkward, which I don't think will merely disappear after finding my footing in a routine, i.e. this is universal and not only confined to the university stage.

Though I do have to ask; is intellect and the inquisitive nature that is likely abundant in most students directly correlated with mental health? Are students more depressed because they're smart enough to be subject to existential, social or other relevant crises?

I do wonder.
Original post by Plagued

Though I do have to ask; is intellect and the inquisitive nature that is likely abundant in most students directly correlated with mental health? Are students more depressed because they're smart enough to be subject to existential, social or other relevant crises?

I do wonder.


There are studies that correlate intelligence with mental health worries:

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/health/intelligence-mental-illness-iq-study-findings-depression-a8005801.html (observational study so bear that in mind)

Neuroticism is also relatively high in the student population which is linked to mental illness (and is a factor that tends to be worsened by stress - which students often have in abundance due to money, family, workload etc). https://synapse.koreamed.org/search.php?where=aview&id=10.12701/yujm.1985.2.1.135&code=0109YUJM&vmode=PUBREADER

But there is also another study that says that the overall rate of mental illness amongst college students vs non-college students is not different: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2734947/

And another that suggests it is higher in college students: https://bmcpsychology.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s40359-016-0124-5

So I think the jury's still out on that one. :iiam:

It is inherently quite difficult to say because of how subjective mental illness and the experience of mental illness can be (one person can have the same symptoms as another and not be that bothered whilst for the other person it has a significant impact & classification criteria of mental illness often changes more over time than physical). It's entirely plausible that intelligence could contribute to mental illness (via increased awareness) or it might be protective (more resourceful/resilient).
Reply 48
95% of it is caused by pre-exisiting misbelief of mental health issues and alcohol abuse. How are you gonna sit and cry about your anxiety and depression whilst getting smashed? Alcohol is a depressant, quit complaining and glamourising mental health issues for the attention it brings, ask yourself what have YOU done for YOUR mental well being? have you created a good lifestyle? do you take care of your body? do you do excercises to increase positive functionality of the mind such as mindfulness and meditation? do you look for inspiring stories and work to create your own? you're one of 8 billion people, quit asking for special treatment and making it hard for the 5% of people with real issues. I find the people with genuine struggles are the ones who don't complain often and work on themselves and their lives constantly.
Ngl im not surprised
Being away from your parents for such a period of time and having to get used to doing all these new things e.g bills by yourself for the first time is definitely gonna have an effect on u especially at first
Original post by 3121
95% of it is caused by pre-exisiting misbelief of mental health issues and alcohol abuse. How are you gonna sit and cry about your anxiety and depression whilst getting smashed? Alcohol is a depressant, quit complaining and glamourising mental health issues for the attention it brings, ask yourself what have YOU done for YOUR mental well being? have you created a good lifestyle? do you take care of your body? do you do excercises to increase positive functionality of the mind such as mindfulness and meditation? do you look for inspiring stories and work to create your own? you're one of 8 billion people, quit asking for special treatment and making it hard for the 5% of people with real issues. I find the people with genuine struggles are the ones who don't complain often and work on themselves and their lives constantly.


they whack off to hardcore porn, watch netflix for hours, bs internet use, social media, smart phones, video games, no excersise, no socialising, sitting in room all day, but still go to bed depressed thinking so what the hell is actually wrong with me
Original post by RivalPlayer

This is not to say that talking to sympathetic third party doesn’t help at all. I just don’t see how a dozen 50 minute sessions with a so-called expert whom you are unlikely to see again helps a person to feel significantly better.

I don't know about the different types of therapies offered, but CBT actually modifies people's behaviour. So it's not making you feel better per se, but your thinking gets altered if you're responsive to and engage with the therapy, which consequently improves things.
Original post by ftfy
I don't know about the different types of therapies offered, but CBT actually modifies people's behaviour. So it's not making you feel better per se, but your thinking gets altered if you're responsive to and engage with the therapy, which consequently improves things.


^^ this. :yep:

One of the key parts of therapy is frequency and relationships. A working positive relationship between the service provider (eg psychologist, therapist) and the patient is very important. Bad therapy can put someone off therapy entirely which can have a long-lasting impact in their ability to access care in the future (and indeed trust psychiatrists enough to be open to the point of it being helpful - staying silent in therapy is unlikely to help). Proper therapy is more than just talking about feelings; it's really about uncovering existing issues (both behavioural and deep-seated) and finding coping strategies and techniques to work through these issues, understand them better and feel 'better' as a result.

The problem with some university services (and some aspects of other mental health services) is that four to six 45 minute sessions per year of counselling with a counsellor (who is not a psychologist or therapist) may not be enough for those with persistent problems. Which isn't to say these services shouldn't exist (they absolutely should) but they, unfortunately, fail in some aspects when it comes to helping students with long-term problems simply because the frequency and relationship are not there to the same extent as it should (ideally) be.

There are other methodological problems with proving the efficacy of therapy which make it harder to assess than 'pills'. But speaking generally, quality is what matters when it comes to mental health support. :smile:
Original post by RivalPlayer
With conditions such as schizophrenia, anorexia and OCD, I think analysing thoughts definitely helps. But in my view, therapy especially the type delivered by the NHS has little to no effect for most people who are chronically unhappy and dissatisfied with life.
You’re better off turning to realm of literature than the so-called “mental health services” when it comes to seeking guidance in regard to the problems of human existence.

There's probably some underlying illness though, if someone is chronically unhappy and dissatisfied with life to the point where it has a significant impact on their daily life? Regarding NHS therapies, I don't about them, but I know for a fact that CBT therapists try really hard to steer therapy away from majority of clients' idea of therapy which is just talking your heart out to someone listening, which is just useless apparently.
Reply 54
Original post by chelseadagg3r
According to a new a international study, one in three university level students report symptoms of a mental health disorder, such as major depression, mania, generalised anxiety disorder, panic disorder, alcohol use disorder and substance use disorder.

You can read more about it here

Do these findings surprise you or do they sound like what you've seen or experienced? Are universities doing enough to support students, particularly in their first year of university?

I remember being at uni and my boyfriends dad had killed himself In my first year, I was very down by the end of that year supporting him whilst trying to keep on top of my work load and yet, I couldn't get an ounce of support. I was passed from pillar to post when I finally plucked up the courage to ask for the help. It left me feeling so much worse! There is definitley not enough support.

Also, curious as to why this post came up on tending when the last comment was a year ago! But couldn't help but contribute.

:smile:
My mental problems definitely got worse in first year of university (social anxiety, drinking), I didn't do much to help myself that is true.
people self diagnose stuff all the time that they dont have. plus it is seen as trendy among us young folk to be "depressed" or have "anxiety"... etc. nowadays normal human reactions and behaviours are scene as a disorder that should be given therapy and coddling. these disorders where totally unheard of 10 years ago, and I was around then and people where pretty much the same, in fact since its become more widely known suicide, self harm etc has only risen.

Latest

Trending

Trending